[Announcer] Terra 9 may have already detected Earth long
And no one thinks this. No scientists think this.
I'm David Grinspoon. I'm an astrobiologist.
One of course is the saucer shaped spacecraft.
Why are so many spacecrafts shaped like saucers?
And turns out that the origin of the flying saucer myth
was because this guy named Ken Arnold, I think in 1947,
saw something that he didn't even describe as saucer shaped.
as though it was skipping like a saucer on water.
of something he thought he saw from his airplane.
by some newspaper reporter who called it a flying saucer.
And then suddenly the reports of spacecraft started
And then now of course, people see flying saucers
because they've heard of flying saucers.
of course is these aliens are underwater.
Again, the kind of gray cliche aliens.
But it does lead to the interesting question,
could you have intelligent life that evolved underwater?
And this is something that astrobiologists have thought
on Earth we have intelligent life that lives in water.
We have the cetaceans, whales, dolphins,
have very large brains for the size of their bodies,
approaching the brain body ratio of humans
and clearly very intelligent creatures.
And there's been a lot of speculation.
Could aquatic organisms evolve technology?
as though they're in a way prevented from doing
that because they evolve these streamlined shapes to move
through the water and be good predators
and good navigators of that medium.
And those streamlined shapes prevent them from developing
of appendages that would allow them to manipulate matter
in a way that has allowed us to develop technology.
So it's been said therefore that in terms of technology,
And also other things they say, Well,
but our technology depends on combustion, the development
of fire, that couldn't happen underwater.
And I often wonder, I mean those are true points,
good points, but are we being too narrow-minded?
Are we just not thinking of the ways
that underwater intelligent life could someday get
around those problems and develop technology?
I mean, you do have to think about, for instance,
and we've seen octopi even using tools in various ways,
picking up rocks and running around
with them and building things and doing things.
And so I'm not entirely convinced that that conclusion
that underwater life could never develop technology
I'm not holding my breath, which I would have to be doing
if I were underwater looking for it.
This is actually a well-known hoax and a pretty good one.
I think it's called the Panama Meteorite.
It's supposedly this meteorite that landed in Panama,
And this guy who later came forward
and admitted it, made these elaborate videos
where first he made it look like a potato that was kind
And then he made it kind of like start to grow and quiver
and some creature was growing out of it.
But it turned out he did this by mixing these two polymers
they kind of grow and quiver like that.
And then he made these videos of these things splashing
around in the water like we see here.
And it turns out that there's some kind of rubber
or plastic thing that he's pulling around with strings
It was a pretty well done elaborate hoax
And I think there are probably people
that are still out there very convinced by it.
But it turned out that it was an exposed hoax
and this guy came forward and admitted
but it's not aliens, it's human creativity.
[Announcer] Did you know there's a planet
that supposedly looks exactly like Earth, same oceans,
But according to the theory, there's no life on it at all.
There is no planet called Terra 9 that's been detected
but it does speak to the fact that we are very interested
to find planets that are in some ways like Earth.
In fact, you could say we're almost obsessed with trying
to find planets that are similar sized,
maybe have atmospheres and continents and oceans
but it's an astrobiologist's dream would be to find a planet
[Announcer] When scientists map the planet's surface
yet have the ability to map the surface of an exoplanet.
Again, this is sort of a future dream of ours
and we want to develop fantastic new space telescopes
that can do direct imaging of exoplanets,
but this is far beyond what we've been able to do.
[Announcer] The land masses looked shockingly similar
to find one like this with the same continents and so forth.
We could find continents in oceans and it's a cool question.
as Earth be mostly oceanic, three quarters ocean
and a little one quarter continents like Earth
Questions of those similarities are fascinating,
if you looked a hundred million years in the past
or 100 million years in the future,
they'd be in a different place with different shapes.
or in the worlds would you ever find a planet
that had the exact same continents as Earth?
and Earth is created by trickster aliens,
but I don't think we need to go there.
[Announcer] And a few researchers believe something
on Terra 9 may have already detected Earth long
No one thinks this. No scientists think this.
I can't say that there isn't such a conspiracy theory out
there because people are going to conspiracy about all kinds
of things, but this has no basis in anything
that's ever actually been observed by a space scientist
or anybody working with a spacecraft.
Okay, this is a obviously fake video,
but it does raise the interesting question
It looks reasonable to me if I were there
and saw this, I'd probably be running around
and trying to take pictures like those people.
of discussion in the SETI community
and literature about how the public would respond
not necessarily a spaceship hovering over Athens,
but even the detection of a real signal.
that maybe there would be mass panic, maybe not.
And people have tried to use historical analogies
of first contact between civilizations
when the Spanish galleon showed up at the Mexican coast,
And none of the historical analogies are completely accurate
or completely applicable, but the mass dislocation
and extreme fear and reaction is plausible.
Other than the fact that the spaceship is completely fake
in this video, the crowd scene seemed plausible
if the spaceship suddenly showed up over one of our cities.
Yeah, so this is obviously some kind
of an alien creature walking around in some distant world.
to some fun questions that we think about a lot.
Namely, what would aliens look like?
Is there any basis at all for us to say?
On the one hand, evolution is very random, unpredictable,
and something evolving in the physical constraints
of another world would be responding
to different evolutionary pressures.
So there's no reason why it would look anything
which we call convergent evolution,
which is that evolution often solves the same problem
So on Earth, you have different completely independently
evolved organisms that have similar shapes
like eyes have evolved independently more
And the streamlined shapes of fishes
and dolphins, they're not ancient relatives,
but they evolve that same shape to solve the problem
of how you move effectively through water.
So you could imagine that alien evolution
on other worlds is going to solve some of the same problems
because the alien that you think is the big scary alien
ends up being the little alien that gets consumed
Again, it illustrates something that we think about,
which is that predator-prey relationships
are quite plausible to evolve on other worlds.
If you think about why that evolves, I mean,
you think about the different mechanisms
that creatures evolve to feed themselves to survive.
We have herbivores, but we also have carnivores,
creatures that eat other creatures.
It makes sense as a way to get energy.
I mean, the whole game of life is about how you get energy
And if there are other creatures you can eat,
then something's probably going to evolve to do that.
And then there are going to be evolutionary races
between the predator and the prey to be faster
and have defenses and counter defenses.
Oh yeah, so Area 51 is a real place
and is the source of a lot of alien conspiracy theories.
and abetted by the fact that the government was very,
very secretive about Area 51 for a long time
and denied its existence for a while.
And it's a place where experimental aircraft
like the U2 spy plane and other spy planes
and stealth technology were developed.
And it is a top secret place out in the desert
and they didn't want people there and chased people away.
And there were a lot of sightings in that area,
unsurprisingly, of very high altitude aircraft,
much higher than anybody knew aircraft could actually fly
This led to a lot of the lore around Area 51
And the US military did not discourage that alien lore.
We've seen this happen in a few situations where it was kind
for what was really going on there for people
to believe this other story about it.
So they didn't completely encourage it,
but they also didn't really discourage
The other thing you notice that aliens are these very kind
of cliche, almost prototype of what's come to be known
as the gray alien type where they have small bodies,
And that's so common that it's interesting
And it seems to have its origin in some old science fiction,
In fact, H.G. Wells in 1895 wrote The Time Machine,
the time traveler encounters these future humans
from like hundreds of thousands of years
in the future that look kind of like the gray aliens.
They've evolved or devolved to have small bodies, big heads,
because they don't really do physical stuff anymore.
And of course it's the future, so they have big heads.
that we have captured alien spaceships
and that they've got secret technology from them.
These spaceships always just look like models
I just can't imagine that the aliens are that sort
of unimaginative that their spaceships look like 1950s cars
And they just don't look very convincing to me.
Having worked at NASA studying some of this stuff,
you realize that none of this stuff would stay hidden.
If scientists knew about any of this stuff,
The idea that you could keep something like this hidden
and thousands of people were in on it and kept it secret,
it just doesn't conform to the way scientists work
[Announcer 2] Scientists just discovered a super Earth.
Meet the super Earth, it's about 70% wider than Earth,
but seven times heavier, meaning gravity is way stronger.
If you weigh 70 kilograms on Earth,
We've in fact discovered lots of super Earths.
One of the most common type of exoplanets are sort
And all that means is that the mass
of these planets is substantially larger than Earth,
but substantially smaller than the gas giants
So we don't consider them gas giants like Neptune, Uranus,
But what we have discovered is that there are a lot of them.
In fact, it may be the most common type of exoplanet.
[Announcer 2] This planet also has three times
massive mountain ranges, endless skies.
It's the kind of planet that could host civilizations
Yeah, so that's a little overconfident in terms
of what we really know about any of these super Earths.
We're still trying to figure out if they even are rocky
with rocky surfaces or if there may be mostly water,
or even if some of them are sort of mini gas giants.
We're not sure about the composition of these super Earths,
but they could be giant rocky worlds like the one described
in this video, which would be really cool
because then you could imagine that they would be sort
of like Earth in terms of the kinds of geological features,
and that's a lot of real estate for potential life.
All right, let's move on to the next one.
[Announcer 3] For 60 years, scientists
in SETI have been scanning the sky for alien radio signals.
They built the biggest listening equipment on Earth.
They searched billions of frequencies. They heard nothing.
But a new study published this week reveals a critical flaw.
Space itself is full of turbulent plasma, charged gas,
surrounding distant stars, and that plasma scrambles
Okay, this is actually a real thing.
It's a little bit exaggerated here, but it's real.
There are a lot of natural radio sources out
in the universe, stars and even planets give off radiation,
but they're not artificial narrowband.
and these scientists discovered that there is this phenomena
where narrowband signals get broadened naturally
by this turbulent plasma, which is just the stuff
of solar winds and so forth, that there is this mechanism
that wasn't previously identified that's real,
that spreads out narrowband signals.
And so maybe we've been overemphasizing just looking
However, it's not true that we've been looking all wrong
and we have to start over and it's complete.
to relax that criterion a little bit
and look for slightly broadened signals.
[Announcer 4] James Webb Telescope may have just
found signs of an atmosphere on TRAPPIST-1e,
in the habitable zone where liquid water could exist.
If confirmed, it would be the first Earth-sized world
beyond our solar system with an atmosphere
and a massive step toward finding life.
Amongst the roughly 5,000 exoplanets
perhaps the most intriguing system is the TRAPPIST-1 system,
which has seven exoplanets orbiting this distant star.
And fortunately for us, the orientation of the orbits
of those planets is such that they pass in between the star
which if you think about it, it doesn't have to be that way.
If the system was tilted a little bit
in a different way then as the planets orbited,
they would not pass in front of that star from our view.
But because it's lined up so well, each time one
of those planets orbits, it blocks out a little bit
of the star, which helps us characterize them
and it even helps us look for an atmosphere
because if a little bit of that starlight is passing
through an atmosphere as that planet transits in front
of that star, then we can see the way the light
from that star is filtered through the atmosphere.
So we've been intensely studying these.
And in particular, there are three TRAPPIST-1 planets
that are in what we call the classical habitable zone,
meaning they're the right distance from that star
to possibly have liquid water on the surface,
They're not too hot, not too cold, just right.
And one of those planets that seems
to be in the habitable zone is TRAPPIST-1e,
in distance from the TRAPPIST-1 star.
The video is correct that James Webb has made observations
that may indicate that that planet has an atmosphere.
[Announcer 6] Using the power of machine learning,
eight new possible alien radio signals.
The word possible is doing a lot of work here.
This is a real result, but it's very tentative
to doubt these particular detections.
[Announcer 6] All of them were narrowband signals,
which are rarely produced by natural sources.
Yeah, this part is true, we're looking especially
for what we call narrowband signals, meaning a lot
of radiation in a very specific frequency range.
This is why you can tune a radio dial
and the numbers of different stations are different
frequencies and they're very narrow.
That's why they don't all bleed into each other
because that's the way you convey a lot
And so it makes sense that if you're trying
and you don't want to waste a lot of energy
and you want to send a powerful signal out, use narrowband.
to let other intelligences out there know
that they're seeing a deliberately created signal
because they'll presumably be looking
It's both an efficient way to send information
and it's a way to let creatures, whoever's looking,
[Announcer 6] It remains to be seen what these signals
but this new machine learning approach could radically
accelerate the search for alien intelligence.
That's true that we're looking for narrowband signals,
and it's true that now machine learning is starting
to be applied to those huge data sets.
And if you think about it, that makes sense
because there's so much data and humans can only do so much.
And it's the kind of thing that you can use AI
in machines very well to say, Search through all this data
see if there are any narrowband signals.
However, AI, as you know, there can be a lot of false alarms
and hallucinations and wrong signals.
Hey, here's this one and this one, and this one,
So this video is a little bit over promising.
[Announcer 6] This breakthrough suggests that the question
of are we alone may not be answered by us humans,
The last point made in the video is quite good.
Not necessarily that if we find the aliens,
with machines is probably the right way to look.
Well, yeah. I mean, the thing of upscaling is really dicey.
You can't really create information where there isn't
any unless you're trying to create an impression.
You're creating more misinformation than information
[Announcer 7] There may be a terrifying reason
and it's called the dark forest theory.
At first, the universe seems like it should be full of life.
There are billions of stars, trillions of planets,
and many of them are older than Earth.
intelligent civilizations should be everywhere.
This is all true that scientists wonder
In fact, this is often called the Fermi Paradox, named
after the famous Italian American physicist, Enrico Fermi,
who was important in the Manhattan Project,
great 20th century important physicist,
who at Los Alamos in 1950 asked some of his colleagues sort
He actually meant it as a physicist, meaning
if you look at the age of the galaxy
if there were civilizations anywhere, even limited
by the speed of light, they should have by now been able
to sort of spread throughout the galaxy.
And so why isn't their presence obvious?
That's what we call the Fermi paradox.
You can extrapolate from that and say,
Well, we've been looking for the aliens
and there aren't any, so therefore there
of what's implied at the beginning of this video.
[Announcer 7] But when scientists look out into space,
we hear nothing, no signals, no messages,
no proof that anyone else is out there.
And that's where the dark forest theory comes in.
We haven't really been looking that long
It may not be that the universe is empty and silent.
It may be that while we've just started looking
and we don't really know how to search in the right way
or recognize the presence of aliens.
However, there is something called the dark forest theory,
which is one of the possible answers to the Fermi paradox,
Let's see what they say about it here.
Every civilization is like a hunter hiding silently
Nobody knows who is peaceful, who is dangerous,
And because the distances between stars are so massive,
there's no easy way to explain your intentions
once another civilization notices you.
the safest option might be to stay completely silent.
There are a lot of potential answers to the Fermi paradox.
One popular answer is that advanced civilizations
have a rule against communicating with primitive
or not very advanced civilizations like our own.
There's variations on that, there's the zoo hypothesis
that we're basically being kept from that knowledge.
One of the sort of darker possibilities being discussed
that the smart civilizations don't reveal themselves
or something really dangerous out there that goes
around finding evidence of other civilizations
So this is a reason for sort of cosmic paranoia
and taken to an extreme, we should go radio silent on Earth
and black out our lights and make sure nobody detects us.
and now you have to get into theories of alien psychology
But why would somebody from another star system want
It seems like it would be an awful lot of effort
And there are even arguments that anybody
that advanced would probably not have those kinds
or they would not have survived to their own maturity.
[Announcer 8] The Drake equation created by astronomer
of intelligent civilizations that might exist
Yeah, this is all true, the Drake equation was created
by the great radio astronomer, Frank Drake, in 1961.
And Frank Drake was an amazing person, by the way.
and of many people in our field, brilliant and brave
and nurturing to a whole generation of scientists.
In a lot of ways, he's the father of SETI.
At one of the first ever SETI meetings in 1961,
Drake wrote this equation on the blackboard, which he meant
as a guide to the conversation at the meeting.
And he said, Okay, how do we assess all the factors
how many civilizations there might be in the galaxy?
of stars that have planets orbiting them.
of those planets that have habitable conditions.
here's the fraction where life actually develops.
Here's the fraction where intelligence develops.
Here's the fraction that are communicating with radio
or some other means that we could detect,
and here's the longevity of those civilizations.
If you put all that together in an equation,
then if you put in numbers for those factors,
Here's the number of civilizations in the galaxy.
[Announcer 8] The equation is represented
by the formula N equals R star, times F sub P,
times F sub I, times F sub C, times L.
Yeah, I mean, that is the equation,
although I think it's sort of obnoxious
to make a video where you just rattle
that off and don't say what any of these means
because it makes it sound like mathematical gobbledygook.
he never meant this to actually calculate a specific number
because of course we don't know what to assume
But what he meant was we can use this as the basis
to figure out how everything depends on everything else.
you can ask these what if questions with the Drake equation.
What if all stars had planets, which they didn't know then
What if half of those planets had habitable conditions?
What if on all planets with life you develop intelligence?
You can say these what if questions.
And what's amazing is that when Frank Drake put
that equation together in 1961, he meant that as sort
of the basis for a conversation at that meeting.
and that conversation is still going on.
in basically its original form, and we've figured
out some of those terms now that they didn't know.
Now we know how many planets there are.
to figure out some of the biological questions.
does it inevitably become complex and intelligent?
But the point is if you have a hunch about one
Here's how it changes the number of civilizations.
So it's actually been a very useful and very powerful idea.
All right, let's move on to the next one.
[Announcer 9] If we ever detect a signal
from an alien intelligence, we are ordered not to reply.
It is the official SETI post-detection protocol.
but it's being presented in a sensationalist fashion.
There is something, the SETI post-detection protocol,
which is an agreement amongst the SETI researchers
of the world to conform to certain rules.
If we detect a signal, what do we do?
You don't just announce it like our observatory has detected
a signal because you don't want to spread a false alarm.
and you get them to search for it from their observatory
Then the rule is you don't keep it secret,
basically announce it to the world.
But then the next part of the protocol,
and that's what this video is getting at,
there's an agreement that you don't just send a reply.
That is true, there's a prohibition against sending a reply
until it's decided by some international body.
You have an international agreement.
and yes, we agree on what we're going to say.
[Announcer 9] But why? The first reason is us.
A 1960 NASA commission study, the Brookings Report,
of a superior intelligence could collapse society.
Yeah, now that's a little bit, again, sensationalist.
People have studied this question of what the detection
of an alien intelligence would mean
and how it would affect our society.
And there's opinions all over the map, including
that it could be very beneficial that the knowledge
that there's somebody out there would have
this uniting effect on humanity because after all,
our differences would seem even more trivial compared
to the difference between us and whoever they are.
So there's been a lot of sort of optimistic talk
about how it could really help us solve some of our problems
because so many of our problems need global responses
and we're so globally incoherent right now,
and maybe the discovery of them would be that catalyst
for us to be more of a globally integrated society.
Okay, that's enough AI slop for today.