Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

Irony at play with the grievance parties

The Age •
November 20, 2026 • 09:00 AM
2
2 reads 0 reactions

Readers respond to what the parties are offering voters at the election.

1 / 8
Swipe Photos

To submit a letter to The Age , email [email protected] . Please include your home address and telephone number. No attachments, please include your letter in the body of the email. See here for our rules and tips on getting your letter published.

Annika Smethurst (“ Teal movement faces test in a changed political environment ”, 18/11) reports that traditional areas of teal policy strength have been overshadowed and that independent candidates have missed the current zeitgeist issues, namely crime and cost of living. Because here, and in most countries, wages are not keeping up with the cost of everything. The reason is mostly related to high fuel prices affecting costs, especially so for Australia at the end of a long supply chain. Until the wars we have no control over are finished, this will continue. It seems ironic that many will vote for a grievance party and will elect people who have no solutions and who will probably last a single term. The community independents have proved their worth with allegiance only to their electorates. Helen Hook, Black Rock

Have voters stopped listening? So the Coalition’s solution to the housing issue is mostly a return to urban sprawl (“ Voters back more housing to be built in the outer suburbs″⁣ , 14/11). It’s surprising that voters from the urban fringes, who appear highly disgruntled about issues such as traffic congestion and a lack of services, would vote for more of the same. It poses the question, have voters in these areas just stopped listening and thinking about what’s being offered. What they want is change and the details don’t matter. The problem with this is that the details do matter. You don’t solve a problem by simply doing more of the same. We often hear from outer urban voters that they are neglected and yet there is nothing on offer when Jess Wilson’s solution is more housing and logically more congestion and a scramble for limited services in these areas. If voters stop listening, thinking and scrutinising and just vote on grievance then they might find that four years will drift by while they just get more of the same. Michael Cormick, Carnegie

The wrongs overshadow the rights Whatever Ben Carroll and his party may have done right in past terms is now unfortunately overshadowed by what’s been done wrong in this one. David Johnston, Healesville

Pickering’s pickle on nuclear energy One Nation’s man in Victoria (″ ⁣How Warren Pickering wants to soften One Nation and smash rivals ″⁣, 20/11) says he “wants to see the true state of the budget after the election before getting policies costed”. How, then, to explain such certainty around nuclear energy? The party would end Victoria’s ban on nuclear energy “so that the state can consider modern nuclear technology as part of a proper, technology-neutral energy mix”. Nuclear has been considered by energy experts and scientists, and has been found to be the most costly option, especially for a nation with no history of the technology. A “technology-neutral” approach would include at least a recognition of the success of our renewables adoption. But One Nation disputes human-caused global warming and Pickering vows he will not “answer to the cult of climate change”. Fiona Colin, Malvern East

A private forum? So Cricket Australia’s grand solution to this mess is that any interested parties voluntarily testify to a closed, supervised forum, with any results to be released at its discretion. The word “forum” originally meant a public place. No danger of that here. Henry Woolley, East Keilor

What of sledging? Cricket has a long history in Australia and the phrase “it is not cricket” has been passed into the vernacular to mean play by the rules. But sandpapering the ball “is not cricket”. But polishing the ball is. Is sledging not in the same class as ball tampering? It would be called bullying in the workplace and its sole aim is to unsettle the batsman and give the fielding team an advantage. Adrian Tabor, Point Lonsdale

Watch the women I follow and support the Australian women’s cricket team. They are friendly, amusing, play fair and are dominant in world cricket. A joy to watch. Peter Williams, Alphington

Cricket’s fallout A quick perusal of the articles and letters correspondents in The Age has one wondering, if a nuclear weapon were dropped on an Australian city would it command as many column inches as sandpapergate? James Ischia, Hawthorn East

An inspiring legacy When I read about Sharman Stone I said, Wow (″⁣ Former MP Stone bows out on her own terms ″⁣, 20/11). What an amazing woman and her work with abortion reform and her commitment to break with conservative thinking regarding embryonic stem-cell research and reducing suffering with medical cannabis made her a strong advocate for women. She was described as having stubborn independence. She left this world a better place and now her decision to use voluntary assisted dying shows her determination to make her own decision and leave this world on her own terms. Julie Ottobre, Brunswick East

Discordant trio The Three Tenors burst into our consciousness in 1990. They were Jose Carreras (Spain), Placido Domingo (Spain) and Luciano Pavarotti (Italy). And by their work they gave many of us a lot of pleasure. Today we have another triumvirate striding the world stage, Vladimir Putin (Russia), Donald Trump (US) and Xi Jinping (China). So what are they giving us and what should we call them? Henry Haszler, Eltham

Not a fan If anything, I view the frenzied celebration of Grand Theft Auto VI not as the shared cultural moment and relationship education opportunity columnist Alice Clarke does ( Comment , 20/11), but as diagnostic of a mass societal illness we deny we have. Beyond the obscenity of investing billions of dollars to fuel corporate profit from the glamorisation of violence, there is the almost blanket adulation of media complicit in this dismal phenomenon. To have the game ennobled as somehow worthy only heightens a sickening sense of a society that has lost its bearings. Clarke’s praise of the game feels something like squeezing a laudable anti-smoking message from an ad featuring the Malboro Man. I agree we should be in search of shared cultural moments, but ones that celebrate human meaning, not immersive virtual despair. Darren Lewin-Hill, Northcote

Scrap the activity laws There are many Melburnians unfamiliar with the extent of Labor’s Activity Centres planning laws. Media coverage tends to focus on the core business and retail areas affected. Many are unaware that the residential areas affected and which surround the cores are kilometres wide. In the case of Bayside, the new Inner Catchment residential area now allows for residential buildings up to six storeys and the new Outer Catchment residential area now allows for buildings up to four storeys. These areas are extensive throughout Bayside and actually form one area stretching across the Activity Centres of North Brighton, Middle Brighton, Hampton and Sandringham. They have the potential to destroy these Bayside suburbs as we now know them. Other Melbourne suburbs are also detrimentally affected by these new controls. Many Melbourne people are also unaware that these changes allow a speculative developer, satisfying bare minimum standards, to be given the go ahead, taking away the right of the local council or those affected to object. A new government should scrap these Activity Centres, effective from day one! John Isaac, Brighton

Economy blues Maybe the Reserve Bank will now be satisfied with causing struggling families financial stress and many to become unemployed. In the meantime, large corporations send jobs offshore. Arthur Pritchard, Ascot Vale

Our new plates With the advent of Christmas spirit, and of holiday travel on our roads, a seasonal variant for our number plates could read: Victoria – The Holey State. Brian Jacka, Kew

Well done, PM At the leaders’ summit, it looks like Anthony Albanese has done what former prime minister Tony Abbott boasted he would do and then didn’t. In his speech Albanese called out Vladimir Putin directly and to his face – a very clear shirt-fronting – about ending the Ukraine war immediately. Well done, PM. Robyn Westwood, Heidelberg Heights

And not so well done I wonder if it even crossed the mind of Anthony Albanese that being photographed alongside the man responsible for the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Ukrainians, could be seen as a betrayal of Ukrainians everywhere. It certainly doesn’t look like he did. Chris Burgess, Port Melbourne

Grandstanding galore The Xi Jinping, Vladimir Putin, Donald Trump love fest on the sidelines of APEC was merely a distraction and a chance for Trump to big note himself. Was there mention of the war in Ukraine and in the Middle East in their communique? No. Was there a plan to reduce nuclear arms? No. What we did get was the push for more fossil fuel, so it is safe to assume that these three don’t see global warming as an issue. These meetings are normally choreographed and have agreed to outcomes worked out behind the scenes. This one looked hastily called and what we saw was two leaders allowing another, who has just had a humiliating defeat, to grandstand. Why Xi and Putin agreed to meet is a matter of conjecture, but surely, they got something out of it more than watching a lame duck president make a fool of himself yet again. He doesn’t need their help to do that. Greg Tuck, Warragul

Terrifying image There was a time when a photo of an amicable meeting between the leaders of Russia, China and the US would have made me think I was watching the world becoming a safer place. Now I feel like I’m watching the genesis of a terrifying global triumvirate agreeing on the mutual benefits of their association. Stephen Farrelly, Donvale

Digital memories I am intrigued by the faith that many readers have in artificial intelligence. The ″⁣memories″⁣ of Claude, chatGTP, et al, are limited to what exists digitally. The feeds that come to you from (anti)social media would indicate that some flaws are still in evidence. Richard McLoughlin, Dromana

Truth in illustration After years of enjoyment from illustrator Matt Golding, I believe I was treated to his most compelling, truthful and unfortunately accurate depiction in his take on the ball tampering saga this week. David West, Essendon

World affairs Vladimir Putin’s army invades Ukraine causing death, pain, trauma and destruction and US President Donald Trump calls him “a friend”? Words fail me. Warwick Spinaze, Rosebud

Could someone tell Donald Trump that Vladimir Putin doesn’t have friends, only patsies that he can use for his own benefit. Michael Brinkman, Ventnor

If only telling Vladimir Putin directly, face to face, to end his war would make a difference. And pigs might fly. Marie Nash, Balwyn

So three blokes get together and reckon they will change the UN, ICC, etc sounds like a boozy Wednesday afternoon lunch to me. James Lane, Hampton East

The International Criminal Court claimed to be “out of control”? Coming from those three immunity claimants, I don’t think so. Alan McLean, Queenscliff

Cricket Time, surely, to call stumps on sandpapergate. Please. Raeleene Gregory, Ballarat East

Cricket: it’s only a game, you know. Keith Fletcher, Glenlyon

Why is it legal to shine one side of the ball but illegal to scratch the other side of the ball? Bruce Hartnett, Alphington

As the ancients said: Truth is the daughter of time. Robert Gray, Glen Iris

Furthermore It’s long overdue that businesses sending jobs offshore for cheaper labour, should need to prove it’s in the national interest. Rob Gordon, Kew

Perhaps someone could come up with a list of companies that outsource their labour overseas, so I have a more comprehensive list of companies to avoid. George Stockman, Bendigo

Finally I don’t know what you are paying Nick McKenzie, but you should double it (″⁣McKenzie takes Gold Walkey″⁣, 20/11). The dude is a phenomenon. Michael Helman, St Kilda East

You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

Remove items from your saved list to add more.

You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.

Prev Swipe Story Next

Related Stories

Australia & Pacific
Build #2612