When a legal system introduces a close-in-age exemption—commonly known as the Romeo-Juliet clause—and removes the threat of prison for consensual teenage intimacy, it’s only natural for a hidden reality to emerge into daylight. Since adolescents can finally speak honestly to doctors, counsellors, educators, researchers, etc., without the fear of incriminating themselves or their partner, it produces a predictable optical illusion. Because teenage sexuality is now being discussed and treated openly, the statistics appear to spike. This can cause us to confuse this newfound visibility for increased frequency. In doing so, we would be making the elementary mistake of confusing turning on a light with building the furniture in the room. The furniture was always there in the dark; flipping the switch merely made it visible.
Under Section 219(2) of Nepal’s National Penal Code, 2017 , the age of sexual consent is fixed at 18. The statute is absolute: sexual intercourse with anyone under 18 constitutes rape, regardless of mutuality, affection or the age of the other partner. While the law scales prison sentences according to the younger person’s age, it draws no distinction between predatory coercion and peer-to-peer adolescent romance.
The concern that a close-in-age exemption could shield young men from prison while leaving young women to navigate social ostracisation, school expulsion and unwanted pregnancy is not baseless. That concern is an accurate diagnosis of our harsh patriarchal reality, but keeping the prevailing law intact is the wrong prescription. An unequal social reality is no justification for perpetuating state violence. The flaw in defending the status quo lies in the assumption that Section 219 actually protects young women. It does not. A statute that treats a 35-year-old predator exploiting a 16-year-old girl identically to two 17-year-old classmates being together, as if power, coercion and age gaps did not exist, protects no one. Instead, it hands privileged families and the state a sweeping mandate to police young people’s choices and punish relationships they disapprove of, which, in Nepal, cannot be viewed in isolation from caste hierarchies.
Moreover, any close-in-age reform must explicitly protect adolescents across all gender identities and sexual orientations. A genuine Romeo-Juliet provision must be gender-neutral and queer-inclusive, decriminalising consensual, non-exploitative intimacy among all close-in-age peers: whether cisgender, transgender, non-binary, straight or queer. If the final wording contains loopholes that fail to screen out coercion, abuse or power imbalances, or leaves out gender and sexual minorities, feminists, queer advocates and legal reformers must fight together to fix them. The mistake we must not make, however, is defending the current casteist social-legal regime, because in practice, Nepal’s rigid statutory rape law has rarely functioned as a shield for vulnerable girls; far more often, it operates as a blunt weapon wielded against marginalised youth.
When an upper-caste or wealthy family discovers their young child is with someone from a lower-caste or poorer background, Section 219 becomes the ultimate tool of social enforcement. Parents routinely file statutory rape or abduction complaints, not to rescue their child from abuse, but to break up an inter-caste romance and salvage family ‘honour’. Even the Supreme Court has practised flexibility in recent verdicts, cautioning courts against interpreting the law mechanically in adolescent relationships.
The Saptari case , decided by the Supreme Court in November 2022, shows how this plays out. According to the Post , a 17-year-old boy and a 15-year-old girl from the same neighbourhood had a consensual relationship. When their families found out, the two eloped and married. The girl’s family then reported the boy to the police for rape and abduction, and he was arrested and tried. The district court acquitted him, and the couple stayed together and later had a child. Even so, the Biratnagar High Court reversed the acquittal on appeal. It gave him seven years in prison and a Rs50,000 fine, plus two extra years because the girl was a minor. The Supreme Court finally cleared him of both rape and abduction, but still sentenced him to six months for child marriage.
A nationwide survey by the Public Defender Society of Nepal (PDS-Nepal) across all eight juvenile correction homes found that out of 917 detained youths, the disproportionate majority came from Dalit and Indigenous communities , compared to just 41 youths from the Brahmin community. According to the International Legal Foundation (ILF), more than 70 percent of clients served by the PDS-Nepal belong to historically marginalised communities who would otherwise have no access to legal counsel.
Legal researchers across South Asia—particularly in India and Nepal—have documented that statutory rape, child protection and kidnapping laws are frequently used by families to criminalise consensual inter-caste relationships . Dominant caste families often invoke these statutes to break up a young intercaste couple, enforce caste endogamy and penalise the man. Dalit boys who date or elope with non-Dalit peers are routinely arrested on non-bailable statutory rape and kidnapping charges, spending years in overcrowded pre-trial detention or reform homes while their families face social boycotts and violence.
As we acknowledge the differences in the privileges that young men and women hold, we must recognise that throwing a 17-year-old into prison for a mutual relationship has done nothing to dismantle gender inequality in all the years Section 219 has existed. Locking up a teenager does not grant their similarly aged partner bodily autonomy or economic independence. It does not teach young people about affirmative consent, healthy boundaries or contraception. It doesn’t make healthcare more accessible for them. All it does is pile a ruinous criminal record onto an already precarious young life.
Dismantling a legal mechanism that incarcerates marginalised youth simply because a disapproving family used the police to punish the ‘sins’ of caste, class, gender identity or sexual orientation is a victory worth fighting for.
Even so, let us not be mistaken: passing a well-crafted, inclusive Romeo and Juliet provision is not the finish line. Legally establishing flexibility for the court to look at context and case-specific details and only then pass a verdict on teenage relationships will not automatically build adolescent-friendly health clinics, mandate comprehensive and queer-inclusive sexuality education in schools or protect young people from patriarchal and caste-based stigma. The Romeo-Juliet legal reform will merely be one small, necessary step in the right direction.
Sapkota is a queer feminist writer.