A teenager and a 27-year-old woman charged with the kidnapping of a Malvern East mother and her young child have been granted bail.
The mother and seven-year-old daughter were allegedly taken from their Waverley Road home in the early hours of Tuesday, locked in the boot of a car, and held hostage overnight at a property in Clyde North.
Special operations group officers raided the Clyde North property on Wednesday, finding the mother and daughter in the lounge room and arresting 18-year-old Thabit Moussa in the garage.
The victims were not physically injured, police said.
A 27-year-old Roxburgh Park man was also arrested at the Clyde North property, believed to be an Airbnb, and remains in hospital under police guard.
Another person, 27-year-old Marina Benyamen was arrested in Craigieburn on Wednesday. A fourth alleged offender, a 26-year-old Roxburgh Park man, was arrested in connection to the kidnapping on Thursday afternoon.
Benyamen and Moussa appeared at the Melbourne Magistrates’ Court on Thursday facing charges of kidnapping and false imprisonment. The magistrate accepted the current evidence suggested Moussa and Benyamen had played a “limited” role in the alleged kidnapping.
The court heard police found a text message on Moussa’s phone, received after the victims had been kidnapped, that read, “hey bro do you want to make some money tonight?”
Moussa gave a no-comment interview to police, the court heard.
Benyamen is accused of driving the car while the victims were held in the boot.
“It’s not clear of what involvement, if any, she had beyond that. To the extent of driving someone from A to B, depending on her knowledge of what she was doing and why,” the magistrate said.
The prosecution opposed bail, arguing the alleged kidnapping followed a crime-for-hire model organised through the encrypted messaging app Signal, which the prosecution argued was all too prevalent in Victoria.
The court heard police believed the pair were at risk of reoffending if released, as they had been “comfortable being involved with something so serious at the outset”.
“They’ve started with a bang, we say, is the problem,” the prosecutor said.
In granting bail, the magistrate noted the pair had strong family support. The court heard it was Benyamen’s first time in custody. Moussa has no criminal record.
Addressing Moussa directly, the magistrate said “whatever” his role in the alleged kidnapping, it was “very serious offending”.
“You’re a young man. I’m taking that into account. You’re only 18,” he said. “I don’t know what ultimately your role in all this is, but you’re getting bail today, and you’re very lucky.”
When Benyamen smiled from the dock after being granted bail, the magistrate warned her about what would happen if she breached her conditions.
“You won’t be smiling because my decision will be very easy,” he said. “You’ll go out that door. I’ll go out that door, go to my chambers and have a cup of tea and a sandwich. I won’t think about you again.”
You have reached your maximum number of saved items.
Remove items from your saved list to add more.
You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.