Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

A much-loved story of freedom and sexual awakening arrives on the Melbourne stage

The Age •
November 19, 2026 • 02:45 AM
• By Thuy On, Will Cox, Tony Way
7
7 reads 0 reactions

Based on E.M. Forster’s 1908 novel, A Room with a View at Southbank Theatre is not quite a tribute to the original text nor a wholesale modernisation.

1 / 15
Swipe Photos

THEATRE A Room with a View ★★★ Melbourne Theatre Company, Southbank Theatre, until December 19

The first question the trepidatious theatregoer who has read E.M. Forster’s 1908 novel and seen the 1985 Merchant Ivory movie adaptation will ask is: do we even need a stage version?

It’s certainly treacherous territory to approach a much-loved classic with the aim of revitalising it for a new audience, and this iteration is an uneven one – not quite a tribute to the original text nor a wholesale modernisation.

Adapted by Grace Chapple and directed by Hannah Goodwin, A Room with a View follows the convoluted getting-of-wisdom path of Lucy Honeychurch (Nathalie Morris) as she travels from England to Italy with her companion-chaperone cousin Charlotte (Hayley McElhinney).

Charlotte’s minder role seems to be a proprietary and protective one: to be in charge of Lucy’s moral education. After all, the Edwardian era dictates that a young, wealthy, unmarried woman of a certain class must conduct herself with decorum – which certainly does not extend to fraternising with men of questionable, socialist backgrounds.

When Lucy meets and finds herself attracted to George Emerson (Luke Wiltshire) in Florence, she slowly begins to unbutton herself to possibilities beyond those predetermined for her. In terms of social standing, and despite his pomposity, Cecil Vyse (Charles Wu), a family friend, is a far more appropriate partner, but George offers a sense of the unknown, of freedom.

Wu brings an energy to him that’s not present in Wiltshire until the later scenes; so too does Tomáš Kantor, who doubles as Lucy’s exuberant brother Freddy and as an Italian driver. The rest of the cast acquit themselves well, including McElhinney’s turn as the shrewish, gossipy Charlotte and Tom Conroy as the vicar with secrets of his own.

Chapple’s script moves from first-person dialogue to third-person narration, giving us both the individual and the omniscient perspective. Lucy’s sexual awakening is gradual and mired in confusion and self-deception.

Morris offers a spirited, open-eyed performance as she experiences the frisson of the new. But Wiltshire’s performance feels lacklustre next to her. Their budding relationship never feels genuinely lit up, and part of the problem lies with the disappointing, sparse set, which is primarily made up of a series of window frames upon which various scenes are projected – none memorable.

The novel and the film both credit the glamour and radiance of Italy as pivotal to Lucy’s ripening – her falling into the throes of romance, but here such golden-lit vistas are missing.

There are no costuming updates; the production sticks to Edwardian period-appropriate clothing. However, there are some innovations to this adaptation that playfully lend themselves to theatricality, with various set pieces (a tennis match and the infamous lakeside skinny-dipping) that are wordless but dynamic and fun.

While there are times when the momentum flags and it feels like there’s too much unnecessary exposition on the choices laid out for Lucy, one of the most poignant scenes is right towards the end, when McElhinney has her back to the audience and is looking out a window, her arms raised, leading us to wonder: will Charlotte ever have a possibility of choice like Lucy, a view of her choosing? Reviewed by Thuy On

MUSIC Aldous Harding ★★★★ Forum Melbourne, November 18

Tonight, New Zealand-born folk-pop songwriter Aldous Harding and her band spend most of the show sitting, meaning a lot of my view is the backs of people’s heads. If I angle it right, and the ocean of people sways in the right direction, I can see her, acoustic guitar in hand. But now what?

Seeing her isn’t important tonight, and neither is small talk. Harding is no showboat. Between songs, she and the band mill silently, changing instruments, tuning. The audience wait patiently. The music converges somewhere over our heads.

There’s plenty to fill the void left in place of sight lines and audience chatter. Harding’s songs are oblique. Much of tonight’s set is from her new album, Train on the Island .

Its songs are strange little machines, full of memorable images and unpredictable structures. She offers them with no context. “Mummy said my inception was like eating a pearl,” she sings on title track Train on the Island , over piano like knots in silk. Several tracks spin off into tangential outros, like on tonight’s highlight, If Lady Does It .

The lyrics might be very personal, but she keeps herself at a tantalising distance. “This one’s about me,” she says in the introduction to Coats , but the chorus goes “Big thick coats on the dogs of people just trying to help.” Happily, we learn nothing tangible.

“What is that accent?” my friend says during Leathery Whip . It’s no accent. It coils around Kiwi, American and something Germanic. These songs are from her subconscious, and she speaks her own language there.

The sold-out crowd is mostly reverent, but silence invites people to fill it. A man yelps something incomprehensible. “So funny,” Harding almost whispers, dismissively. One fan yells out a too-complicated, impassioned plea that the lighting balance is wrong. “I can’t hear you, mate,” says Harding, and launches into Worms (“I flew down to the brewery / All wool dead on my waist”).

“You’ll be all right,” she says later. “I know the quiet is hard.”

Harding closes her set with an encore of some older songs, Imagining My Man , with its twee little “Hey!” yelp, and the uncharacteristically sunny Designer (“Do not lose your young eyes / Laughing at good work with your ugly son”).

As we leave, I hear a few people saying it would have been a perfect show if she played The Barrel , and if they could have seen her.

I say embrace the obscured vision. There’s irreplicable joy in standing in silence with this many people, trying to get a glimpse at something you’ll never quite see and never quite understand. Reviewed by Will Cox

MUSIC Anne Sofie von Otter and Kristian Bezuidenhout ★★★★ Classical Music Australia, Melbourne Recital Centre, November 18

Swedish mezzo-soprano Anne Sofie von Otter has returned to Melbourne with the world-class stagecraft that has characterised her stellar career.

Presenting 16 Schubert songs with pianist Kristian Bezuidenhout, von Otter impressed an appreciative audience by bringing her compelling storytelling skills to the composer’s unique world where happiness and sadness, hope and disappointment are codependent.

Schubert’s famous trout featured early on, along with revelling impish spirits in The Ghost Dance .

Further evidence of von Otter’s chameleonic versatility came with a gentle Lullaby, D. 867, the lyrical solemnity of Mignon’s Let me appear so , D. 877 and the effective use of her rich lower register in the nocturnal rustlings of In the Forest , D. 708.

Bezuidenhout’s solo interludes included an engrossing account of Mozart’s bittersweet Rondo in A minor, K. 511, very aligned with the Schubertian mood, while later came a spiky reading of Schubert’s Hungarian Melody in B minor, D. 817 and the long melodic arcs of the second-movement allegretto from the Piano Sonata in A minor, D. 537.

In a lighter vein, four varied songs by von Otter’s 19th-century compatriot Adolf Lindblad proved a good foil for the final bracket of seven songs from Schwanengesang , D. 957, in which von Otter laid bare the stark anguish of unrequited love.

Among Schubert’s last utterances, these songs include the popular Ständchen and Abschied , in which von Otter put on the lover’s brave face, while with Die Stadt and Der Doppelgänger came a confronting rawness.

Supported by Bezuidenhout’s empathy and dexterity, von Otter’s highly developed musicianship kept the focus on musical communication rather than on any understandable mellowing of her famously lustrous instrument.

Two poignant encores, Schubert’s Lachen und Weinen and the ’60s hit Try to Remember , summed up the mood created by a memorable encounter with a great singer. Reviewed by Tony Way

The Booklist is a weekly newsletter for book lovers from Jason Steger. Get it delivered every Friday .

You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

Remove items from your saved list to add more.

You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.

Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 6 other independent news outlets reported on this story.

6 Publications
RealEstate.com.au News
8h ago
Wollemi pine planned for level 66 of $800m Southbank skyscraper - realestate.com.au

Wollemi pine planned for level 66 of $800m Southbank skyscraper - realestate.com.au

Once thought extinct for millions of years, a rare ‘dinosaur tree’ is heading to the top of an $800m Melbourne tower – if builders can solve one major catch.

#melbourne #southbank
Compare →
ABC News Australia
11h ago
CCTV stills show armed men in wild Melbourne brawl

CCTV stills show armed men in wild Melbourne brawl

Investigators say up to 20 people armed with baseball and cricket bats were involved in the early October brawl, which left one man with life-threatening injuries.

#melbourne
Compare →
The Australian Financial Review (AFR)
1d ago
Rental listings fall 23,000 in five years across Sydney and Melbourne

Rental listings fall 23,000 in five years across Sydney and Melbourne

Homes available to lease in Australia’s two largest cities have plummeted in the past five years. More pain is expected for tenants in coming years.

#melbourne
Compare →
The Urban Developer
1d ago
Unlikely Showstopper Planned for South Melbourne Office Block

Unlikely Showstopper Planned for South Melbourne Office Block

Developer Kervale is rethinking workplace amenity for its 10-storey proposal that also embraces the site’s wartime heritage...

#melbourne
Compare →
The Guardian
1d ago
‘Heads should roll’: owner of Melbourne Cup horse found dumped in skip bin demands investigation

‘Heads should roll’: owner of Melbourne Cup horse found dumped in skip bin demands investigation

Stuart Ramsey says it is a ‘bloody disgrace’ the gelding was left in the skip bin while awaiting burial

#melbourne
Compare →
CNN International
1d ago
Melbourne Cup horse So You Are found dead in a waste facility, sparking an inquiry | CNN

Melbourne Cup horse So You Are found dead in a waste facility, sparking an inquiry | CNN

The dead body of Melbourne Cup horse So You Are was found in a waste facility in Sydney less than two weeks after competing in the most prestigious event in Australian horse racing.

#melbourne
Compare →

Related Stories

Technology
Build #2612