Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

'Let the whole nation down': The world's response to 'sandpapergate' has been clear

SBS News Australia •
November 19, 2026 • 06:21 AM
3
3 reads 0 reactions

Australia prides itself on being a good sport. But what does it say about us if our men's cricket team staged a cover-up?

1 / 3
Swipe Photos

It's a batsman's word against his captain's — did everyone on the Australian cricket team know about the use of sandpaper on the ball in South Africa eight year ago?

Each repeatedly insists they're telling the truth and the 'sandpapergate' scandal refuses to die, cementing itself as important to Australia's identity.

In 1997, Prime Minister John Howard said captaining the Australian cricket team was the "absolute pinnacle of sporting achievement, and really, the pinnacle of human achievement".

It was a standard that set the role up to fail, according to David Rowe, emeritus professor of Cultural Research at Western Sydney University's Institute for Culture and Society.

He said Australia's decision to incorporate cricket into its national identity backfires when there's controversy.

Your trusted source for staying up-to-date with the world around you. Get free daily news updates and analysis, straight to your inbox.

"If you tie your national identity so closely to not just the performance of your sporting team, but their ethics, almost by definition, if they let themselves down — they let the whole nation down," he said.

Rowe said sandpapergate affects the reputation of the everyday Australian.

"It draws you in by implication if you're Australian, even if you don't know anything about cricket, because it's become part of our national image."

Ahead of the release of his biography, Sabr, on 10 November, retired Australian cricketer Usman Khawaja alleged that the entire Australian men's team knew about the use of sandpaper during the 2018 South African tour.

"It was all of us," Khawaja told Nine newspapers.

"Not the batters, not the bowlers, not the staff. All of us."

The use of sandpaper was aimed at making the ball 'reverse swing' to gain a perceived advantage over batsmen.

Cummins held a 70-minute press conference in Sydney last Friday denying Khawaja's allegations, saying they were "100 per cent wrong".

"I did not know that was happening ... He says that I and others were architects of a scheme to ball tamper with sandpaper. That's complete and utter nonsense."

On Wednesday, Cricket Australia (CA) announced it would establish an "independent forum" for players and staff who "were involved in the 2018 tour of South Africa" to "share their version of events and recollections in a confidential environment".

It said it will not initiate a new investigation.

CA ran an initial investigation after opening batsman Cameron Bancroft had been caught with sandpaper during the third Test in 2018. It found fellow opener David Warner had crafted the sandpaper plan, Bancroft carried it out and captain Steve Smith was aware.

CA banned Smith and Warner for 12 months and Bancroft for nine months. Coach Darren Lehmann resigned. For its part, the International Cricket Council fined the trio and suspended Smith for one Test match.

On Wednesday evening, Bancroft issued a 4,000-word statement via the West Australian website, supporting many of Khawaja's allegations and saying he would attend CA's forum.

He said he'd spent eight years "carrying the burden" and "took the bullet for everybody".

He said Cummins' press conference was "the final straw" and made him feel "angry, betrayed and alone".

Bancroft admitted that he "did not give a complete and truthful account" and "withheld important details" in CA's investigation.

He said that sandpaper was not used in the first Test in Durban. But it was used during the second Test in Port Elizabeth.

He recalled discussing using sandpaper with fast bowlers Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh, and wicketkeeper Tim Paine. He said all gave him feedback on the ball's behaviour.

Bancroft said bowling coach David Saker had urged him "do more with the sandpaper".

He said the only person who objected was media manager Kate Hutchinson.

Bancroft said when he was caught, he was pulled into "frantic conversations" in which he was given advice on how to "minimise the damage on the team".

"I ended up becoming the scapegoat for the entire team."

Since Bancroft's statement, Cummins' management has released a statement doubling down on the captain's position that he had no knowledge of the tampering.

Warner addressed Khawaja's initial allegations via Instagram, saying, "It's 100 per cent accurate what you've said." He later accused CA of a "cover-up".

"As far as I am aware, CA did not interview Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc or Nathan Lyon in their 2018 investigation. If that’s correct, then how can CA push the idea that the bowlers didn’t know?" Warner wrote.

He said it appeared Cricket Australia had "decided who they wanted to blame from the very beginning" and "ran a shoddy investigation".

"Now they want to maintain the false narrative that the bowlers had no idea. That stinks of a cover-up."

Rowe said the scandal doesn't reflect well on our international reputation.

He believes other nations, particularly competitors like India and the UK, would be experiencing "schadenfreude" — a German word meaning the act of taking pleasure in others' misfortune.

Former England captain and The Times chief cricket correspondent Mike Atherton said there was "obviously" no "better time" to be English than "when Australian cricket is tearing itself apart".

Sports journalist for Daily Mail UK, Oliver Holt, penned an opinion piece calling for Cummins' resignation — saying he had "torched his own reputation over sandpapergate".

"The poster boy of Australian cricket betrayed the essence of his nation's character, savaged his own teammates and let three pals swing in the wind."

South African and English cricketer Matt Prior told The Cricketer that he believes the bowlers were aware of the sandpaper scheme.

"There is just no way that a conversation wouldn't have been had in any of the dressing rooms that I've played in," he said.

Former India spinner Murali Kartik shared the same sentiment, telling Cricbuzz that "when something like this happens, it's for the sake of the bowlers".

He said he doesn't know how any bowler could say they "didn't know about it".

"When you're trying to do something for the sake of the bowlers, wouldn't you tell the bowlers? How can anyone believe that? Are we in kindergarten to accept that sort of thing?"

This is the second time Bancroft has spoken publicly about sandpapergate.

In a 2021 interview with The Guardian, he was asked about the bowler's awareness of the plan to use sandpaper.

"Yeah, obviously what I did benefits bowlers and the awareness around that, probably, is self-explanatory," he said.

Shortly after, Cummins, Starc, Hazlewood and Lyon released a joint statement denying any knowledge of the scheme.

Bancroft addressed this in his recent statement, saying it was "deeply painful".

Rowe isn't surprised the scandal's back — saying its popularity is a credit to "badly botched" management.

He said CA couldn't "kill off a scandal of that magnitude", but they could have "contained it".

"Sandpapergate will take its place in history as something that is talked about long after it happened because it is such a fascinating case," he said.

Rowe said sandpapergate was and is still "wickedly amusing".

Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 6 other independent news outlets reported on this story.

6 Publications
ABC News Australia
2h ago
The context you need to understand Bancroft's version of Sandpapergate

The context you need to understand Bancroft's version of Sandpapergate

If you feel like you missed a beat with the Australian cricket's sandpaper scandal and why its back in the news, this breakdown of Cameron Bancroft's article will bring you up to speed.

#cricket #sandpapergate
Compare →
The Australian Financial Review (AFR)
3h ago
Would Sandpapergate be blowing up if playing politics wasn’t cricket?

Would Sandpapergate be blowing up if playing politics wasn’t cricket?

In terms of politically inflicted carnage, the best comparison is the so-called “Blackest Day in Australian Sport”.

#cricket #sandpapergate
Compare →
The Age
9h ago
Sandpapergate scandal LIVE updates: Pat Cummins responds after Bancroft backs Khawaja in statement; says entire Australian cricket team knew about ball tampering in 2018 South Africa Test

Sandpapergate scandal LIVE updates: Pat Cummins responds after Bancroft backs Khawaja in statement; says entire Australian cricket team knew about ball tampering in 2018 South Africa Test

The sandpaper scandal continues to unfold after Cameron Bancroft released his version of the 2018 South Africa tour in a tell-all piece on Wednesday night. Follow all the action.

#cricket #sandpapergate
Compare →
Al Jazeera English
19h ago
Cameron Bancroft claims entire Australian team knew about ‘sandpapergate’

Cameron Bancroft claims entire Australian team knew about ‘sandpapergate’

Batsman Cameron Bancroft also admitted that he lied about the extent of the plot to protect Cricket Australia's investigation during the incident.

#cricket #sandpapergate
Compare →
The Guardian
8h ago
‘We all knew’: Cameron Bancroft – his full ‘sandpapergate’ statement

‘We all knew’: Cameron Bancroft – his full ‘sandpapergate’ statement

Eight years of carrying the burden of the country on my shoulders. The public need to know my story today

#cricket #sandpapergate
Compare →
Sydney Morning Herald (SMH)
22h ago
Broken trust is the biggest obstacle facing Boon’s Sandpapergate truth forum

Broken trust is the biggest obstacle facing Boon’s Sandpapergate truth forum

Cricket Australia is desperate for the sport to get some clear air for cricket, but there are plenty of questions already arising about the Band-Aid solution they’ve put over the wounds of the sandpaper saga.

#cricket #sandpapergate
Compare →

Related Stories

World News
Sandpapergate means us Poms can stop feeling guilty about Bodyline
The Australian Financial Review (AFR) • 6h ago
Simon Heffer
#simon-heffer

Simon Heffer

The Australian Financial Review (AFR) • 4h ago
Build #2612