David Warner and Usman Khawaja doubt an independent forum created by Cricket Australia will heal all wounds from the sandpaper scandal.
Warner and Khawaja both questioned if the independent forum will find the truth of the controversy — and the CA hierarchy agrees.
"Someone's version of events will contradict someone else's version of events," CA chief executive Todd Greenberg told reporters in Hobart on Wednesday.
"So looking for the perfect truth doesn't exist — and we're not chasing that."
CA wants players and staffers from the infamous 2018 Test tour of South Africa, when Australia tampered with the ball, to tell their version of events to the forum.
Your trusted source for staying up-to-date with the world around you. Get free daily news updates and analysis, straight to your inbox.
"This forum is not about re-litigating the past," CA's interim chairman David Boon told reporters in Hobart on Wednesday.
"It's about creating an opportunity for those who wish to be heard to tell their stories in a respectful, safe environment — and for our sport to listen."
Khawaja, whose recount of the events in his autobiography released last week triggered the fresh furore, applauded CA's board for establishing the forum, but doubted its effectiveness.
"The biggest question I have is ... the board makes the decisions on what comes out at the end," Khawaja told Fox Cricket.
"How is that an actual way of trying to present what people have said? I just feel that then we just go in a circle again.
"I appreciate where their heart is and I will support the board in this ... but for me there are still a few questions."
Warner, who was banned from cricket for 12 months for his role in the sandpaper scheme, concurred.
"This safe space again — is it really going to be safe? Where do we actually end here?" he told Fox Cricket.
Greenberg said players and staffers from the time wouldn't be forced to attend the forum, likely to be headed by a King's Counsel and operated entirely independent of CA.
"Over the past week, we have had several different and conflicting accounts of what transpired in Cape Town in 2018," he said.
"And it has been an incredibly difficult and uncomfortable time for the game and for everyone who was involved.
"The game is really hurting at the moment.
"These events were eight years ago. They caused enormous pain and hurt for lots of people, and they're doing it again.
"And at some point we have to move forward, and we can't move forward without putting some of these steps in place."
Greenberg said CA would decide what, if any, outcome from the forum would be released publicly.
"The premise is that they (players and staff) are coming through and it's confidential," he said.
"That (outcome release) will ultimately be a matter for the CA board at the time. And, where possible, we would like to think that we can make as much of that public as we can."
There would not be sanctions for anyone involved in the forum, he said, hoping it would be completed in a month.
And Greenberg again ruled out reopening CA's investigation into the 2018 scandal completed at the time.
Eight of the 11 Australian players who played in the Cape Town Test were interviewed by that investigation, which Warner has described as a botched cover-up.
Khawaja, in his book, said the entire Test touring squad was aware of plans to tamper with the ball.
But current Test captain Pat Cummins, who was in the 2018 team, described Khawaja's claims as nonsense, while dismissing any notion of a masterplan to tamper with the ball.
CA banned Steve Smith, along with Warner, for 12 months and stripped them of the captaincy and vice-captaincy respectively for their role in the controversy.
Batsman Cameron Bancroft, who was caught by television cameras with sandpaper in his trousers during the Cape Town Test, was suspended for nine months.