Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

7 smart reasons to sell a stock—and my ‘golden rule’ for offloading shares, says hedge fund CEO

CNBC World •
November 17, 2026 • 03:05 PM
• By Karen Finerman
1
1 reads 0 reactions

"You need a clear, disciplined plan for when to sell," says Karen Finerman. Here are seven smart reasons to sell — and when not to sell.

7 smart reasons to sell a stock—and my ‘golden rule’ for offloading shares, says hedge fund CEO

Nobody is born knowing anything innately about the stock market. And if you feel like you've missed the investing class, you didn't. Usually there isn't one.

So responsible people who are trying to do the responsible thing by building a portfolio for themselves and their families often find huge gaps in their knowledge and don't know where to turn.

As the co-founder and CEO of the hedge fund Metropolitan Capital Advisors and a longtime panelist on CNBC's Fast Money, I know that there's no shortage of advice when you're getting started about great investments to buy. It can feel easy and gratifying, especially when your portfolio is doing well. But then things get tougher.

One of the hardest things to do as an investor is to figure out when to sell. You buy a stock because you believe it will go up in value. But the decision to sell is rarely so straightforward. Personally, I've made just about every selling mistake. But over time, I've developed a framework for knowing when to sell — and when not to.

Selling decisions are often rooted in emotion and cognitive bias rather than logic. One major culprit: anchoring to past performance , a flawed reference point that clouds clear thinking.

Behavioral economics, particularly prospect theory , shows that we experience the pain of a loss more intensely than the joy of a gain. This leads investors to cling to losers ("just need to get back to even") and sell winners too early ("lock in the gain").

We also place too much emphasis on recent events, a phenomenon known as recency bias . If your last tech stock soared, you're more likely to chase another. If your last trade flopped, you may avoid the market altogether. And when recent trades go well, people tend to trade more — often to their detriment.

Finally, selling triggers a storm of second-guessing and rationalization. Here are my responses to common excuses:

These biases and emotional landmines are why you need a clear, disciplined plan for when to sell, including when:

When you've decided to sell for a solid reason — especially the first, second, or third outlined above — don't hesitate. Don't wait for the perfect price. Just sell.

Just as important as knowing when to sell is knowing when not to sell. Avoid emotionally driven decisions that sabotage long-term gains.

Selling well is an advanced investing skill that demands discipline, logic and self-awareness, and there's no place for ego. If you create a sound game plan, you'll be equipped to act confidently, even in the face of uncertainty. I keep a list of reasons to sell handy so I can literally look at it and keep my wits about me.

Karen Finerman is co-founder and CEO of the New York-based hedge fund Metropolitan Capital Advisors and a longtime panelist on CNBC's Fast Money. She is the author of the New York Times bestselling book, " Finerman's Rules: Secrets I'd Only Tell My Daughters About Business and Life " and the host of the podcast How She Does It . Karen is a proud member of the Wharton Board of Advisors, her alma mater, and serves on the board of The Michael J. Fox Foundation for Parkinson's Research.

CNBC Select is editorially independent and may earn a commission from affiliate partners on links.

Excerpt from " Investment Wisdom For Our Friends And Loved Ones: Timeless Lessons from Today's Top Finance Experts " by Jenny Harrington and Rebecca Patterson. Copyright © 2026 Jenny Harrington and Rebecca Patterson. Published by Harriman House, an imprint of Pan Macmillan.

Tags:
Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 6 other independent news outlets reported on this story.

6 Publications
The Next Web (TNW)
2h ago
Oracle co-CEO says tech made a ‘classic mistake’ selling data centres

Oracle co-CEO says tech made a ‘classic mistake’ selling data centres

Mike Sicilia says tech should hire people who live near its data centres, after US voters turned down data centres in 40 of 41 ballot measures.

#ceo #sell
Compare →
The Guardian
1d ago
#ceo #sell
Compare →
The Verge
15h ago
Instagram’s CEO thinks it will be “pretty challenging” to make it feel great on the iPhone Duo.

Instagram’s CEO thinks it will be “pretty challenging” to make it feel great on the iPhone Duo.

From Adam Mosseri, on Threads. In another post, points out how the closed Duo has nav buttons on the right hand side — which is where the like, comment, and share buttons on Reels are too. [Media: https://www.threads.com/@mosseri/post/Df0csMJDN7W?xmt=AQG0Yq8ZDCv1qnbAvLkdTc3LbsdkORo3WHJeI1cd1QYCY58ApxJYJUhjbrT5wKrJ4UeGueZS]

Ars Technica
19h ago
Shareholders sue Intel, its CEO and CFO after stock drops 28.6 percent in one day

Shareholders sue Intel, its CEO and CFO after stock drops 28.6 percent in one day

The PC sales slump "more than offset” AI boom gains, shareholders say.

TechCrunch
20h ago
Trump says ex-Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang's affair with an alleged Chinese spy did not threaten national security | TechCrunch

Trump says ex-Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang's affair with an alleged Chinese spy did not threaten national security | TechCrunch

Trump contradicted his own government's intelligence officials, who reportedly concluded that Alice Huang is a Chinese spy.

The Australian Financial Review (AFR)
22h ago
‘I felt like I was failing’: How a top CEO floundered as a new boss

‘I felt like I was failing’: How a top CEO floundered as a new boss

When Frank Fillmann, CEO of Salesforce in Australia and New Zealand, received his first promotion to a management role, he was no overnight success story.

Related Stories

Business & Economy
Build #2612