The Supreme Court (SC) has ruled that individuals accused of violating Sections 3, 4 and 5 of the Foreign Exchange (Regulation) Act cannot be held guilty if the seized denominations of a currency had already been withdrawn from circulation.
A division bench of Justices Tek Prasad Dhungana and Meghraj Pokharel issued the verdict in response to an appeal filed by defendants Hemraj Kathariya and Dudhnath Yogi. The apex court also acquitted two other defendants - Ganesh Dagami Thapa and Raju Budhathoki - who had not appealed against the lower courts' rulings.
While the SC acknowledged that the Nepal Rastra Bank (NRB)'s advisory cautioning the public and financial institutions against accepting or holding demonetised notes was an appropriate regulatory measure, it clarified that an item must first legally qualify as 'foreign exchange' to warrant punishment under Section 17 (1) of the act.
The ruling stems from the case of an August 1, 2018 police raid in which Yogi, Thapa and Kathariya were found in a room containing a bag with 2,650 notes of INR 1,000 and 5,300 notes of INR 500, totalling INR 5.3 million. Upon questioning, Kathariya had stated that Budhathoki had given him the cash, prompting police to arrest Budhathoki as well.
Prosecutors had charged the four men with conducting illegal foreign currency transactions in violation of Sections 3, 4, 5 and 12 of the Foreign Exchange (Regulation) Act and a July 7 NRB circular.
Both the Rupandehi District Court and the Tulsipur High Court had subsequently convicted the defendants under Section 17 (1), ordering the confiscation of the cash and imposing fines equal to the seized amount.
Overturning the convictions, the Supreme Court noted that Indian banknotes of 500 and 1,000 denominations were demonetised on November 9, 2016 - more than a year-and-a-half before the police seizure of these notes. Because the notes had lost their legal tender status and no longer fell under the definition of foreign currency, their possession did not constitute an offence under the act.
The bench also rejected the application of a subsequent NRB circular issued on January 19, 2020, stating that a directive cannot retroactively criminalise an act committed prior to its issuance.
During the lower court proceedings, all four defendants had denied owning the cash and had alleged that police had coerced their confessions.
Although the SC cleared the men of criminal liability and waived off the fines, it upheld the Butwal Bench of the Tulsipur High Court's decision to confiscate the INR 5.3 million, citing that none of the defendants claimed ownership of the money and that NRB prohibited transactions involving withdrawn denominations of the Indian currency.
The verdict was initially delivered on July 30, with the full text released recently.