Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

OPINION: First Nations peoples should not be afraid to call Triple Zero in a crisis. What needs to change

SBS News Australia •
November 17, 2026 • 08:00 PM
2
2 reads 0 reactions

Registered psychologist and Gamilaraay man Dr Clinton Schultz says good crisis care is not a one-size-fits-all for First Nations peoples.

1 / 2
Swipe Photos

With Australia continuing to grapple with disproportionate rates of incarceration and concerns about deaths in custody, racial profiling and over-policing, Bridging the Justice Divide brings together a panel of voices to ask what it would take to rebuild trust between First Nations communities, police and our justice system. Watch Bridging the Justice Divide Wednesday 18 November at 9:35pm Simulcast on SBS and NITV on SBS On Demand.

Content warning: This article contains references to suicide and the name of an Aboriginal person who has passed away.

When someone is experiencing an acute mental health crisis in Australia, we should be asking the simple question: who is the best person or service to help them?

For too long, the response has often been "send the police".

That's not necessarily a criticism of individual police officers. It's a criticism of a system that relies on policing to fill gaps in our mental health and social support services.

If someone were experiencing a heart attack, we wouldn't expect police to be the primary responders.

Yet when someone is experiencing significant psychological distress, psychotic symptoms or suicidal thoughts, police involvement remains a far too common part of the response.

And many police officers find themselves responding to situations they're not equipped to manage or were never properly trained for.

For Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, this creates particular concerns that cannot be separated from our history or our present-day experiences.

It also raises a broader question about what culturally safe crisis care should look like, and whether our current systems are equipped to deliver it.

First, we cannot have a meaningful conversation about police responding to First Nations mental health crises without acknowledging the longstanding and often deeply damaged relationship between police and our communities.

We must acknowledge the role of policing in the violence, dispossession and deaths of Aboriginal people since Australia’s colonial history.

Police were also historically central to enforcing government policies that controlled almost every aspect of Aboriginal lives — including forced removals from Country, restrictions on movement and the removal of our children.

These experiences continue to shape family stories, community experiences and relationships with authority — as well as emergency responders.

During 2024-25 in Australia, 33 Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people died in custody, including six deaths in police custody or custody-related operations.

Behind these staggering figures are people, families and communities experiencing profound and ongoing grief – and who have been affected by police brutality and institutional racism.

For example, the 2025 coronial findings into the police shooting of Kumanjayi Walker in the Northern Territory found his death was avoidable and identified serious failures in police conduct and accountability. This exposed deeply concerning racism and systemic failures within policing.

Against the backdrop, how can we assume that a First Nations person experiencing significant distress will feel safer when police arrive?

We need to recognise that sometimes the very presence of police can escalate a crisis rather than help resolve it.

For some people, the arrival of uniformed officers can trigger fear, traumatic memories, distrust and a heightened sense of threat.

What responders interpret as aggression, resistance or non-compliance in someone psychologically distressed may actually be a person's fear response.

The situation can escalate quickly if that isn't recognised by responders who might meet the fear with more force, louder instructions, or increasingly controlling behaviour.

Responses aimed at protecting someone can unintentionally increase distress, which is why understanding trauma, perceived threat and the relationship between individuals and authorities is so important in crisis care.

This doesn't mean police should never be involved.

There will be circumstances where they are needed to protect someone's immediate safety or the safety of the public.

But we should be questioning why policing remains such a prominent response to people who are fundamentally asking for help, healthcare and support.

The ways First Nations peoples experience and express distress are not always well understood by mainstream services.

Grief, exposure to racism, disconnection, family responsibilities, cultural obligations, spiritual experiences and the ongoing impacts of colonisation can all influence our social and emotional wellbeing and our responses.

When responders don't understand these contexts, they risk misinterpreting what is happening and responding in ways that make things worse.

Service providers must be accountable for delivering culturally responsive care — supported by clear standards, appropriate training, ongoing evaluation and government policy.

Cultural responsiveness cannot be only expected from Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander-specific services. It should extend to Triple Zero, mainstream emergency departments, ambulance officers, police and mental health professionals.

They must understand how history, racism and previous experiences influence someone's response to authority in an already frightening situation – and they must be mindful of how they exercise power in that moment.

Cultural responsiveness also requires individuals and organisations to reflect critically on their own assumptions, practices and approaches to care.

Good crisis care must be responsive to differences between people rather than relying on a one-size-fits-all approach — as no two Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people asking for help have identical histories, circumstances or expectations.

Cultural safety must be embedded in the foundation of support services. But crucially, a health-led response in crisis care is not automatically a culturally safe response.

If we replace police officers with clinicians but retain approaches that are controlling, culturally uninformed or disconnected from people’s circumstances, we risk reproducing the same problems within a different system.

But there are promising developments for changes to mental health crisis care across Australia.

Queensland has introduced mental health co-responder teams that bring paramedics and mental health clinicians together to support people experiencing crisis, often in their own homes.

NSW has announced reforms towards health-led crisis responses, while Victoria is also strengthening the role of health professionals in mental health emergencies.

Services such as 13YARN and Thirrili provide culturally grounded crisis and suicide-related support. The Institute for Urban Indigenous Health's Staying Deadly Hubs in south-east Queensland and Safe Havens in NSW provide further examples of community-based approaches.

While these initiatives serve different purposes, they demonstrate that support for people experiencing distress does not need to rely exclusively on traditional emergency response systems, such as the police.

These are important developments, but access remains inconsistent, and many culturally grounded services operate alongside emergency response systems rather than being integrated into them.

We also need stronger evidence about which models work, for whom and under what circumstances.

A response that resolves an immediate crisis but leaves someone feeling frightened, disrespected or disconnected from support cannot be considered wholly successful.

Reform must consider how services build trust, recognise cultural needs and involve people in decisions about their own care — and not just change the professional who arrives at someone's door.

I'd like to see mental health crises treated primarily as health and social and emotional wellbeing matters — with police involvement determined by genuine safety needs rather than being the default.

This requires better clinical and culturally responsive assessment when someone first calls for help.

It also calls for first-response teams that can include mental health clinicians, paramedics, peer workers and Aboriginal health practitioners (with access to additional cultural expertise where needed).

It means funding Aboriginal community-controlled organisations to help design and deliver local responses, while ensuring mainstream services are equally accountable for cultural responsiveness.

And it means having genuine alternatives to emergency departments — including community safe spaces, home-based support and appropriate involvement of family and trusted people.

These reforms must be developed in genuine partnership with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, with meaningful decision-making authority over how services are designed, governed, delivered and evaluated. This is not simply about consultation.

It is about recognising that First Nations communities hold essential knowledge about what culturally safe and effective care looks like and ensuring that knowledge shapes the systems intended to support them.

We need to reconsider what successful crisis care looks like. Along with reducing police involvement in mental health crises and hospital presentations of people in custody, are people being treated with dignity, having their culture respected and receiving meaningful follow-up support?

These outcomes should be measured and used to inform how we fund, evaluate and improve crisis-responsive services.

Perhaps the most important question is whether that person would feel comfortable asking for help again.

If seeking help leaves someone frightened, traumatised or distrustful of services, the system has failed them, their families and our communities.

We already have much of the knowledge and many of the services needed to do things differently. We now need the commitment to build a health-led crisis response system grounded in social and emotional wellbeing, cultural safety and evidence-informed care.

When someone reaches out in crisis, they are asking for help. The last thing our response should do is give them another reason to be afraid.

For crisis and mental health support, contact Lifeline (13 11 14), SANE Australia (1800 187 263) or 13Yarn (139 276), a 24/7 Aboriginal & Torres Strait Islanders crisis support line, Brother to Brother (1800 435 799) or Yarning SafeNStrong (1800 959 563).

Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 1 other independent news outlet reported on this story.

1 Publication
ABC News Australia
5d ago
Questions over police response to Triple Zero calls before Floreat murders

Questions over police response to Triple Zero calls before Floreat murders

The coroner in the Floreat murder-suicide inquest questions why a desperate call to Triple Zero stating someone had been shot in a family violence situation was not marked as requiring a priority one response.

#triple-zero #triple #zero
Compare →

Related Stories

Technology
Build #2612