Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

Policy debate light in Victorian election debate but there was a clear winner

ABC News Australia •
November 17, 2026 • 08:06 PM
2
2 reads 0 reactions

Audience members picked Liberal leader Jess Wilson as the winner of last night's News24/Herald Sun election debate, but there was little policy discussion.

Policy debate light in Victorian election debate but there was a clear winner

Topic: State and Territory Elections

Premier Ben Carroll and Liberal leader Jess Wilson face off in last night's debate. ( News24 )

When Billy, one of 100 undecided voters, was asked if his question to four Victorian political leaders during last night's debate was answered, he replied, "Not really."

His question was about how politicians would rebuild trust with the public, but it could have been a response to many of those thrown at the Labor premier, Liberal opposition leader, Greens candidate and One Nation candidate.

The News24/Herald-Sun debate never got deep into policy discussion between parties about their competing visions for the state. Instead, the parties mainly stuck to their policy talking points, with little critique or pushback on what their opponents were asserting.

Candidates rattled off lists of achievements and what they want to do.

No-one knocked the debate out of the park.

With four candidates on stage, all the parties will take something away from the night, and in most cases, it was survival.

Premier Ben Carroll was asked about his predecessors, Dan Andrews and Jacinta Allan, at last night's forum. ( News24 )

Premier Ben Carroll was less robotic than at his press conference and appeared more comfortable answering punters' questions. He didn't set the room on fire.

His most difficult moment came when he was pressured about the Andrews and Allan governments he served under, especially the legacy of Daniel Andrews.

It was a tough moment and he was reluctant to speak about it.

"He's not Voldemort", Opposition LeaderJess Wilson chipped in from the side, encouraging him to say Andrews's name.

He challenged her to say Jeff Kennett. She didn't hesitate.

Audience members picked Liberal leader Jess Wilson as the winner of the night. ( News24 )

It was a moment of political theatre, but it underscores the difficulty Carroll faces every day. He and Labor are being judged on 12 years in office.

Carroll is unlikely to have won over many new voters from the debate; it was a chance to show off his "new direction", a task he never rose to, but he is unlikely to have lost any support either.

And in a Labor campaign that is increasingly trying to save as many seats as possible, that's almost a win for Labor.

It's a similar outcome for his main challenger.

Wilson came across as rehearsed, her lines familiar to those who watch politics every day.

But she looked assured and calm, even if some of her answers raised more questions.

With the finishing line in sight and polls showing the opposition is on track to win a majority, the Coalition has reached a critical stage where it can't afford to trip.

There were no real curly moments for Ms Wilson.

The Liberals wanted her to come across as the adult in the room, as someone who was in control. She largely nailed that brief without shining.

Had the debate been just a head-to-head with premier and opposition leader it would have been more comfortable for Wilson, and much more difficult for Carroll.

The focus would have been even more targeted on Labor's track record, rather than the four competing parties' ideas to solve Victoria's problems.

The debate never got into deep policy detail.

One Nation leader Warren Pickering stuck to the party's message about Net Zero. ( News24 )

But the discussion on energy was the trickiest waters for Wilson to navigate; she stressed that her party didn't care what the source of electricity was, as long as it was affordable and reliable.

One Nation's Warren Pickering asked her whether she backed Net Zero, a totemic issue for the party.

After a few prods, Wilson said there would be no change to the state's pathway to that emissions goal.

It is exactly what Pickering wanted to hear. It is an issue that the party is increasingly drumming up ahead of polling centres opening today.

Going into the debate, Pickering loomed as a debate wildcard. He has won many voters over with his direct, unpolished, anti-politician style.

If anything, he appeared a little more muted than normal, but he didn't give his opponents any "out-there" moments to ridicule One Nation's seriousness at this election.

The audience rated Greens leader Ellen Sandell as the second best performer during the debate.

The most surprising performance of the night came from the Greens' Ellen Sandell.

Having been the third biggest presence in state parliament for years, the party has long argued it deserves a seat at these types of events.

Sandell didn't waste the opportunity. She delivered the Greens' rhetoric (which was never going to appeal to many in the audience), but she stuck to her guns and stood out.

She is unlikely to have lost any support over it, even in a tough room, and may have even made some new friends.

The audience did not rate Ben Carroll's performance well during the debate. ( News24 )

After the debate, the undecided audience were asked to vote for a winner.

It was grim for Carroll, with just 7 per cent backing him; Wilson was the clear winner on 39 per cent, with One Nation on 16 per cent and 13 per cent still undecided.

Sandell came second, winning 25 per cent of the room, a story in itself.

Will Tuesday night's People's Forum have much impact on the election?

It is unlikely, but with so many seats to be decided by small first preference margins, the absence of any major stumbles will mean the campaigns can all breathe a sigh of relief, and in some cases maybe give a little cheer.

Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 6 other independent news outlets reported on this story.

6 Publications
The Age
12h ago
Victorian election leaders’ debate LIVE: Ben Carroll, Jess Wilson, Warren Pickering and Ellen Sandell make pitch to undecided voters

Victorian election leaders’ debate LIVE: Ben Carroll, Jess Wilson, Warren Pickering and Ellen Sandell make pitch to undecided voters

With just 11 days until the election, the premier and the opposition leader are squaring off in a four-way debate that also includes the One Nation and Greens leaders.

#victorian #election #debate
Compare →
The Australian Financial Review (AFR)
1d ago
Victorian state election 2026 and the contest in your electorate

Victorian state election 2026 and the contest in your electorate

Explore the key demographics of your seat and our take on who is likely to win.

#victorian #election
Compare →
BBC News
2h ago
Who to watch in race to run Spain after 29 November elections

Who to watch in race to run Spain after 29 November elections

Spain votes on 29 November, with the conservatives and the far right favourites to win after eight years of Socialist-led rule.

#election
Compare →
Sydney Morning Herald (SMH)
2h ago
Why Albanese and Hanson don’t want to win this coming election

Why Albanese and Hanson don’t want to win this coming election

There is, in fact, a relatively fine line between a Labor wipeout and miracle fourth term. It depends on the forgotten voters of this campaign.

#election
Compare →
Domain Property News
2h ago
Noorilim: A rare gem of Victorian heritage

Noorilim: A rare gem of Victorian heritage

Perfectly capturing the grandeur of Victorian Italianate architecture, this Wahring estate has elegantly stood the test of time.

#victorian
Compare →
The Guardian
3h ago
Anti-Arab hate speech surged on social media during Israel’s election, report finds

Anti-Arab hate speech surged on social media during Israel’s election, report finds

Digital monitors recorded 400% rise in posts attacking Arab Israelis, including Netanyahu’s disproven fraud allegations

#election
Compare →

Related Stories

Australia & Pacific
Build #2612