I'm Annie Kritcher, nuclear engineer and physicist.
Let's answer some questions from the internet.
thetradingchick asks, WTF is nuclear energy?
Nuclear energy is energy that's released
Unlike other forms of energy that we know and love
where it's rearranging chemical bonds or electrons,
this is directly coming from the nucleus,
That energy is released through Einstein's equation,
and when you have a small reduction in mass,
that translates to a huge amount of emitted energy.
Wait, didn't scientists finally get more energy
out of nuclear fusion than they put in?
In 2022, we finally generated more energy from the fusion
to make the fusion in the first place.
was at the National Ignition Facility.
We shined the biggest laser in the world.
It's actually 192 individual laser beams
all coming into the end of a hollow cylinder
Those laser beams hit the can itself,
and that creates a three million degree x-ray oven.
that is suspended in the center of the can
holds our deuterium-tritium fuel for fusion.
When we make this three million degree x-ray oven,
it heats up the outside of that capsule material,
which is carbon, in the center of the can.
That blows up that carbon, expands it outward,
and just like a rocket, when the rocket fuel goes down,
it squeezes and compresses the fuel inside
down to half the width of a human hair.
So this little tiny miniature star is being created,
for about the time it takes light to travel one inch.
is we're making it so hot and so dense
that it actually exceeds sun-like conditions.
So we're five times hotter than the center of the sun
is getting the plasma hot enough and fast enough
so that you can create the conditions
for self-sustaining ignition and burn
where the fusion reactions actually heat the plasma,
and that's what gives you your yield.
If you don't have self-heating of the plasma,
you could never have the biggest laser in the world
to heat all the fuel to fusion conditions on its own.
the thing that made this experiment unique
is we ignited the core of that fusion plasma
and then it sat there and burned up
the rest of the fuel in the experiment
and enabled us to generate more energy from the fusion
than it took to make the fusion plasma.
mbgelman asks, My wife is trying to figure out
and I'm pretty sure that's what caused Chernobyl.
It actually is an interesting analog.
Both systems heat water under high pressure.
An instapot heats water electrically.
A nuclear reactor heats water through neutron deposition.
that caused a runaway reaction, additional heating,
which blew the reactor lid off and spread radioactive waste.
and this is when the core gets so hot it actually melts,
and so this can happen in a fission reactor.
It actually cannot happen in a fusion reactor
which is another advantage of fusion energy.
starchode asks, Ironman uses an arc reactor for power.
We have already invented nuclear reactors.
Why can't we just make them smaller?
the fusion arc reactor in Ironman is fictitional.
The major challenge with fusion reactors
is that you need large amounts of driver energy
to put enough of that energy into a very small space
that you can create these fusion conditions,
and you could never do that in a small enough space
On top of that, there's all the other things of the system
like cooling the reactor parts and also shielding.
So you wouldn't want a nuclear reaction to happen
ZyMazza asks, When they finally crack nuclear fusion,
how will they convert that energy into electricity?
Don't tell me it's just going to be boiling water again.
That's exactly what we're going to do. [laughs]
So a few things need to happen first though
and scale it to commercial fusion energy.
You have to scale the whole system bigger,
you have to make parts of the system more efficient,
and you have continuous fusion energy production,
what you do is you actually take the neutrons
that come out of that fusion reaction
and you use those neutrons to heat material.
and that is exactly how we're generating electricity.
It's the same way that current nuclear fission reactors
There is also a market for high temperature heat
which lets you bypass that electrical energy production,
when we have continuous fusion energy generation
is we're going to capture the neutrons that come out
from that fusion reaction away, 17.6 MEV.
and we use it to boil water, the steam turbine,
and that's how we generate our electricity.
Gomi-panda wants to know, What exactly does it mean
it wants to release energy and become stable.
So it can release energy by emitting alpha particles,
It wants to emit that energy as radiation and become stable,
and that's what it means when it's radioactive.
some of the materials that surround the core
When particles hit those materials,
they become excited, and then they decay energy away.
Radon, which can exist in some people's basements,
that's generated from nuclear reactors
which is radioactive, like forms of uranium
What is the difference between nuclear fusion and fission?
Nuclear fusion is squeezing together two atoms
to get them to fuse and create energy,
and nuclear fission is splitting the atom apart
In both cases, this generates energy
because the products weigh slightly less
and that mass is converted to energy
through Einstein's equation E = mc squared.
So, fission has been around for many decades.
It was actually first discovered in 1938,
and this actually fed into the idea
that you could use this as an extreme source
for the fission bomb during the Manhattan Project.
It's actually quite easy to get fission to happen.
so that you can start this chain reaction.
just had its breakthrough moment not too long ago in 2022,
where we finally generated more energy out from fusion
than it took to create fusion conditions.
ianlasco asks, What makes fusion energy
so difficult to produce and sustain compared to fission?
Fusion energy is so difficult to produce
because you have two atoms both positively charged,
where the strong nuclear force takes over,
you need to get them going high speed
So that requires extreme temperatures and densities,
more hot than the center of the sun
and higher pressures than the center of the sun.
scientists have tried to create these plasmas
One is with large high-powered magnets,
and the other main approach is inertial confinement fusion
where you're confining this little hot plasma
with its own inertia for a brief moment in time,
and that's the approach that we took at the NIF
where we're making a tiny little star from the fusion plasma
and holding it together with its own inertia
So each different confinement method
and we're continuing to explore all the different methods.
From the explainlikeimfive subreddit,
How can we make something hotter than the sun?
So the way that we get our plasma or our miniature star
We're squeezing and compressing fusion fuel
We're doing this extremely rapidly with a lot of energy.
So we're using a high-powered laser to come in here,
create a three million degree x-ray oven by hitting a can.
Then that oven heats up the outside of a carbon capsule
that sits in the center of the can.
That capsule explodes material out just like a rocket,
and that squeezes and compresses the fusion fuel down
to these very hot, dense conditions.
On top of that, we actually need the fusion reactions
So without the fusion reaction's self-heating,
we won't get to these crazy hot, dense conditions.
We actually need to get hotter than the center of the sun
because we don't have the sun's massive gravity behind us.
The sun also has the same process of fusion,
but it fuses light elements to generate energy.
It's huge and massive and billions of years of confinement,
and that helps the reactions happen even at a slow rate,
the extreme temperature and density
If we can't get to higher temperatures and higher densities,
we can't get enough fusion to occur
Omarkakk asks, How is plasma created?
Plasma is created when you're heating material
that you can actually rip electrons off of the atoms,
and that's how you're creating a plasma.
There's a lot of different ways to create plasmas,
and actually plasmas are all around us.
So plasmas are in neon tubes, for example.
The way that we create plasma's in fusion systems
is by dumping laser energy in very quickly into a material.
JaniceCantSpell asks, Why are bananas radioactive?
because they contain an isotope of potassium
It's a very tiny amount of radiation that's emitted.
It's such a tiny amount of radiation that's emitted
that it's inconsequential to human life.
NairobiTrending asks, How does uranium enrichment happen
So Uranium-235, it's an isotope of uranium.
It's what's mostly used in our nuclear fission reactors.
It's naturally occurring in small fractions
We try to separate 238 from the 235
so you can concentrate the amount of 235
is because these two isotopes have slightly different mass
because one has three more neutrons on it,
and spin them around in a centrifuge
and you can separate them out that way.
between something as a nuclear reactor
and something like a nuclear weapon.
How are they different, and how are they the same?
Well, a nuclear weapon releases huge amounts of energy
but continuously over time for power generation.
between a nuclear fusion reactor and a weapon
is that you can only get a tiny fraction of the fuel
to ignition in fusion conditions with our traditional ways
and so you want all the fuel in the system
There is no chance of a runaway fusion event or explosion
because you can't get the amount of fuel
to those fusion conditions in a reactor.
Question from Not a Nuclear Physicist:
How possible is it to use nuclear reactor powered engines
We've also tested using fission reactors in space,
because of shielding, cooling, weight, cost, safety.
How can you cool that reactor system?
How can you shield the crew from the radioactivity
that's happening in that reactor system?
So far, we have not been able to scale down a fusion reactor
the challenge there is the scale of the reactor required
to generate nuclear fusion in the first place,
where there's too much mass on your spaceship.
some of these things were ground tested,
kind of like the ones that we put on submarines.
There you actually have the advantage
In terms of a fusion reactor in space,
it's just conceptual and theoretical,
Currently, there's no way to generate fusion on a spacecraft
where you can shield the crew from the intense radiation.
So they make up the protons and neutrons
and ultimately for nuclear fusion in the laboratory
how those protons and neutrons come together
and react with the material around it.
of the building blocks of our nuclear systems.
What is the deal with the hadron collider?
Why is it considered dangerous by some people?
Well, the Large Hadron Collider in Switzerland
that accelerates protons at extreme speeds
close to the speed of light and smashes them together,
because they think what can happen when that occurs
that's so much energy in a small space.
Well, on relative terms, it's actually less energy
than some of our cosmic rays hitting Earth.
So really it's not dangerous at all.
where many important scientific discoveries have been made,
such as how does electrons have mass
and also lets us study the building blocks of life
How much of Christopher Nolan's 'Oppenheimer' movie
was accurate versus exaggerated and fake?
This movie was extremely fun for me to watch.
Most of the history was actually accurate.
but one of the parts that stood out to me personally
was how Oppenheimer felt right before the big test.
So right before the Trinity test, he made a comment,
He was stressed about a lot of things:
it creating a thermonuclear burn throughout the atmosphere.
All these things weighed heavy in his heart.
Every time we do a fusion experiment at the lab,
One of the fears leading up to the Trinity test
was that we would ignite thermonuclear burn
And although this was an actual concern,
it was sensationalized in the movie.
before the actual experiment happens.
All these people are coming together, working together,
Everybody wants their part of the system to be exactly right
and you're sitting there waiting for a moment in time
when it'll either work or it won't.
but also hard on your heart as Oppenheimer puts it.
Okay, next question from berskeezz.
How do you build a laser? Do you put fire in a tube?
light amplification by stimulated emission of radiation.
To put that simply, what you're doing here
is you're taking a big slab of glass,
you're exciting this glass up to an excited state
so that you can send a little tiny laser beam in,
and all the photons that are excited come down,
so you can get the power that you need
on the short time scale that you need.
So here's a comment from Elon Musk.
The sun is an enormous free fusion reactor in the sky.
It's super dumb to make tiny fusion reactors on Earth.
The fusion reactor in the sky is amazing,
but we can't capture all of that energy
We still need other sources of clean energy
And another nice thing about fusion power and nuclear power
is the sun doesn't have to be shining,
and also we don't have to cover the entire world
The world needs as many sources of clean energy as possible.
These aren't in competition with one another
Those are all the questions for today.
Hope you learned something. Thanks for watching.