Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

American Doctor review – medics put their lives on the line in Gaza amid the carnage

The Guardian •
November 17, 2026 • 11:00 AM
1
1 reads 0 reactions

Poh Si Teng’s powerful documentary follows three doctors from the US who sign up to volunteer at the Nasser hospital

American Doctor review – medics put their lives on the line in Gaza amid the carnage

T his is the latest documentary about medics travelling to Palestine to treat civilian casualties; it’s a powerful, angry film, in a state of despair at the scale of suffering and devastation. A sliver of hope is the trio of doctors it profiles, individuals acting on their conscience. (The same can be said of director Poh Si Teng , who quit her job at ABC News and cashed in her savings to get the documentary off the ground.) It follows three American doctors who sign up to volunteer at the Nasser hospital in southern Gaza in early 2025 – though one of the trio, Thaer Ahmad, an ER doctor of Palestinian heritage from Chicago, is refused entry the night before they enter Gaza.

His colleagues, Dr Feroze Sidhwa, a trauma surgeon, and Dr Mark Perlmutter, a Jewish-American orthopaedic surgeon, complete the mission. This is not the first time in Gaza for either of them. Before he leaves, Perlmutter packs antibiotics into a dozen or so little plastic bags dotted around his luggage; that way if he gets turned back at the border, he stands a chance of getting some of the life-saving medication through. Given the high death rate of medics in the war, he also gets a will drawn up before he goes.

Inside the hospital, we see the camaraderie between medics of all nationalities, bantering in the universal language of good-natured jibes. Then come the mass casualty events; there is not always pain medicine for patients with limbs blown off. All three doctors eventually find themselves in the spotlight, advocating for Palestine on podcasts, TV news and in the corridors of Washington DC. When it is time to leave the hospital, Perlmutter and Sidhwa feel a sense of guilt returning to their lives. Nasser hospital has been attacked seven times since the start of the war; the cameras are there to witness one hit. The latest Israeli airstrike came just last week , killing one of the Palestinian doctors in the film, surgeon Rizk Abu Shaira, who was among six reported fatalities.

Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 6 other independent news outlets reported on this story.

6 Publications
Hamro Patro News
3h ago
Trump administration moves to block China from indirect access to American AI technology

Trump administration moves to block China from indirect access to American AI technology

WASHINGTON, Nov 17: The Trump administration on Monday issued new rules to restrict remote access to advanced U.S. computing chips and servers, marking the latest step to limit China’s abilities to...

BBC News
12h ago
Customers report outages at Chase, Bank of America and Wells Fargo

Customers report outages at Chase, Bank of America and Wells Fargo

Chase Bank, the largest US bank, said a software bug might be causing the issue, but that it was not "systemic'" or "cyber-related".

CNN International
17h ago
Pope Leo’s return to Latin America reveals the missionary message of his papacy | CNN

Pope Leo’s return to Latin America reveals the missionary message of his papacy | CNN

His visit to South America will go down as one of the lasting images of his papacy. It also sends message to the wider church: that it is the people on the margins who must take priority.

Sydney Morning Herald (SMH)
18h ago
Good grilling: Barbecue tips from a top American pitmaster

Good grilling: Barbecue tips from a top American pitmaster

Don’t have time to go low and slow? Here’s how to get smoky, flavourful meat in half the time.

Al Jazeera English
21h ago
‘My arms are empty’: Tragedy strikes Gaza family after baby dies from cold

‘My arms are empty’: Tragedy strikes Gaza family after baby dies from cold

A nine-month-old baby has died from hypothermia inside his family’s displacement tent in Gaza, as winter returns.

SBS News Australia
1d ago
Australia and allies urge Israel to unblock Gaza aid

Australia and allies urge Israel to unblock Gaza aid

The foreign ministers of Australia, Canada, Italy and the UK have jointly called on Israel to urgently allow the rapid entry of aid into Gaza, as flooding in the region exacerbates the humanitarian situation.

Related Stories

World News
Build #2612