Santos has been accused of taking gas out of the domestic market instead of supplying it. ( ABC News )
It was, according to Queensland Coalition senator Susan McDonald, a "most unsatisfactory" mistake.
The Senate was interrogating the federal government's plans for a domestic gas reservation scheme, and bitter rivals had accidentally been lumped together to appear at the same time.
In one corner was Dan Clark, the head of giant east coast gas exporter Australia Pacific LNG (APLNG).
In the other was Tracey Winters, chief strategy officer of Australia's second-biggest oil and gas company, Santos, the operator of a neighbouring plant on Queensland's Curtis Island known as Gladstone LNG (GLNG).
It did not take long for sparks to fly.
Mr Clark pointed out that APLNG had supplied the equivalent of four years of the eastern states' entire domestic gas demand since starting operations 10 years ago.
By contrast, and in none-too-subtle terms, he said, "another" player had taken almost as much gas out of the domestic market.
"Since the startup of our LNG facility, APLNG has delivered over 1,900 petajoules to the domestic market," Mr Clark told the Senate's Economics Legislation Committee.
"But for every four of those petajoules APLNG has contributed to Australia, another exporter on the east coast has taken three petajoules back out."
Dan Clark and Tracey Winters gave evidence to the Senate regarding the reservation scheme. ( Supplied )
Before long, Ms Winters was firing back.
"In the evidence that we just heard, APLNG is acting purely in its commercial interests," she argued.
That the two were exchanging home truths is testament to how heated the debate about gas reservation on the east coast has become and how high the stakes have risen.
In the normally clubby and civilised world of Australia's oil and gas industry, relations between some of its biggest players have descended into open conflict.
On one side is APLNG and its partners, led by Australian energy giant Origin and US major ConocoPhillips.
It is joined by British-Dutch company Shell, which operates the third of the east coast gas exporters, Queensland Curtis LNG (QCLNG), along with users and many industry observers.
But on the other side is Santos, the country's mid-sized gas producer, and the foreign interests that have invested in GLNG and are banking on the gas it can provide them.
Adelaide-based Santos has pushed heavily into exports through projects like GLNG. ( ABC News: Che Chorley )
Josh Stabler, the founder of consultancy Energy Edge, said the dispute playing out publicly had been going on privately for years.
"It does appear that now that there's been legislative shifts, it's become more public in terms of the concerns," Mr Stabler said.
At the heart of the dispute, he said, was a fundamental mismatch between the three east coast exporters and what they were providing to the local market.
Whereas APLNG and QCLNG had more than enough gas to run their export plants at capacity and supply plenty of gas to domestic users, it was a very different story for Santos and its partners.
To plug the gap, he said GLNG had consistently sucked up huge volumes of gas from the domestic market so it could be sold overseas.
"The numbers do back that up," he said.
"It is certainly taking a large amount of gas, be it under long-term foundational contracts or short-term ones, to meet its LNG exports."
Research from Energy Edge reveals Santos has taken much of this gas from the Cooper Basin, a vast onshore gas field operated by Santos in outback South Australia and Queensland.
Historically, it was one of the biggest sources of supply to South Australia and New South Wales.
The Moomba gas field, tapped to supply the domestic market, is in outback South Australia. ( ABC News: Mike Sexton )
But that all changed in 2016, when Santos began sending 140 terajoules a day from the basin north to its export facility at Gladstone.
The east coast domestic gas market uses about 1,400 terajoules of gas a day.
Despite assurances to the market operator in 2013 that production from the basin would increase to 600 terajoules a day, more than compensating for export volumes, output has instead declined.
Since GLNG started, Santos has diverted more than half of the gas produced in the Cooper Basin to exports.
Mr Stabler says the Cooper Basin is the most obvious example of Santos depleting the local market for its export needs, but there are others.
Among them is a contract the company signed with AGL last decade, described by others as a sellout of Australian gas consumers.
The gas was originally sold to AGL by Shell, which signed a 20-year deal at discounted prices to ensure domestic consumers could get access to affordable supplies.
However, AGL, under controversial former chief Andy Vesey, flipped the contract to Santos in 2015.
The deal locked in profits for AGL but deprived local consumers of huge volumes of gas which were then exported through GLNG.
"It certainly doesn't look good in retrospect, that deal," Mr Stabler said.
Santos has repeatedly stated the contract with AGL will not be renewed when it expires at the end of next year.
The company has also noted GLNG is no longer buying gas from Origin, an arrangement that finished at the end of last year, since when prices local prices have eased.
Ms Winters has argued it is not correct to suggest Santos has been depleting the local market, saying the company had supplied the equivalent of 26 per cent of its export volumes to the east coast.
"The east coast gas market … faces future projected shortfalls … because of the failure of state governments in New South Wales and Victoria to facilitate the development of their gas resources for the last 15 years," Ms Winters told the committee.
Under the Commonwealth's plans, gas exporters would be required to supply the equivalent of up to 20 per cent of their annual production to the domestic market.
The scheme would be aimed at ensuring producers supplied 110 per cent of forecast demand to put downward pressure on prices.
But with federal parliament set to pass the legislation underpinning the scheme in the coming days, analysts are warning it is still riddled with shortcomings.
Inpex is celebrating its 100th LNG shipment from Darwin. ( Supplied: Inpex )
Hamish McKenzie, the deputy director of climate change and energy at the Grattan Institute, said the government's oversupply target of 110 per cent of demand was too much.
"A big oversupply risks tanking the domestic gas sector and pushing up gas prices," Mr McKenzie wrote on social media.
"A straightforward solution would be to amend the legislation to cap the oversupply at a much smaller level: we have suggested 2 to 5 [per cent]."
In its testimony before the Senate, Shell echoed Mr McKenzie's comments while saying a domestic reservation scheme "overall … would be a good thing for Australia".
But Cameron Crowther, Shell's general manager of growth and strategy in Australia, said that, as the company had been a long-term supplier to the local market, "must-sell" provisions were unnecessary, as was the possibility of prosecution.
However, in a veiled swipe at GLNG and Santos, he warned the government against playing favourites or exempting producers from providing their fair share of supply.
"The problem is that the granting of exemption or variation for one exporter in the way the bill is drafted simply transfers that obligation onto other exporters," Mr Crowther said.
"What that means for Shell and our partners … who have consistently and voluntarily made good on our commitment to the domestic market, is that we're left uncertain as to what the ongoing commitment is going to need to be."
Independent senator David Pocock was more blunt, using his additional comments in the Senate inquiry report into the scheme to argue Santos and GLNG must not be allowed to "avoid their obligations".
According to Senator Pocock, the bill contained "loopholes" that could let Santos slip free "through accounting arrangements that leave Australian consumers no better off".
David Pocock is demanding more safeguards to avoid lobbying from gas companies. ( ABC News: David Sciasci )
Crucially, he said it appeared the legislation would do little to prevent a gas exporter from acquiring a domestic gas producer or field and counting the production towards their quota.
"Compliance must be based on a real increase in gas available to the domestic market."
And he said the discretion available to the minister risked turning the scheme into a "lobbyists' picnic unless there are appropriate safeguards".
While Senator Pocock stressed the policy should go hand in hand with a gas export tax to ensure Australians received a better return on the sale of their resources, he said it should not be used to foster increased gas production.
A Santos spokesman said Senator Pocock's arguments would make it virtually impossible for the company to meet its domestic obligations without breaking its long-term contracts with overseas customers.
Josh Stabler said the spectacle of huge corporate interests duking it out would normally not concern consumers.
But it was different when they were caught in the melee, as they were in the fight over gas supplies.
"It's a fight about fairness," he said.