Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

Flawed climate talks are better than silence, any way you look at it

Sydney Morning Herald (SMH) •
November 22, 2026 • 07:30 AM
3
3 reads 0 reactions

The value of the annual global climate talks is questioned every year, and COP31 is no exception

1 / 15
Swipe Photos

You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

Remove items from your saved list to add more.

You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.

The value of the annual global climate talks is questioned every year, and COP31 is no exception (“ Hot air or helping: Are global climate talks working? ” , November 21). There’s no denying the hypocrisy, or the frustration at the fanfare and grandstanding surrounding many leaders’ appearances. But imagine if there were no COP at all. Where would that leave us as the climate crisis escalates? At least this year’s talks have shone a spotlight on the Albanese government’s continued support for coal and gas expansion, built momentum for electrification and consolidated the group of countries pushing for a phase out of fossil fuels. On the defining issue of our time, a flawed table is better than no table at all. Amy Hiller, Kew (Vic)

Limiting global temperature rise due to greenhouse gas emissions from burning fossil fuels is the purpose for COP meetings. It is bizarre that (almost before the ink had dried) the wording in the first draft for the COP31 statement an “immediate transition away from fossil fuels” was openly expected to be removed from a final statement. So, thank you, Nick O’Malley, for detailing the relentless campaign, over many years, by just a handful of countries, to block any consensus that includes the troublesome words “fossil fuels”. UN Secretary-General António Guterres could not have been clearer with his statement that “fossil fuel interests keep making a killing, while killing our planet”. It is excellent to see that climate leaders such as emeritus Professor Lesley Hughes think the whole idea of having to get 100 per cent consensus “has perhaps had its day”, and this is borne out by Saturday’s confronting footage of COP31 delegates’ protests. The UN’s own “majority” voting process is desperately needed but, failing that, “No result at COP31″ could avoid any pretence that fossil fuels are not the problem. Rob Firth, Red Hill (ACT)

After 24 years of COP gatherings, this year looks like ending without any climate protection agreement. Ironically, but poignantly, most of those COP members flew to the meeting in fossil fuel-guzzling planes – accompanied by laptop-carrying staff – driving in fossil-fuelled limos to nice hotels with aircon powered by generators. Of course, the US would not allow the words “fossil fuel” to be included in any agreement, although it is the actual cause of global warming. The US continues its failed moral, ecological and oil-thieving attitude to the rest of the world. That’s not unexpected for a country declining under its current denialist leader, soon to have his wings and lips clipped. COP-out. Rob Buchanan, Kerikeri (New Zealand)

The latest Trumpian move to threaten US big tech companies with punitive taxes if they build data centres in foreign countries (“ Trump talks down Quad AI plan, will penalise US companies that build data centres overseas ”, smh.com.au, November 21) may possibly be the very first move by this creature to offer support and assistance to Australia. Anything which dissuades the tech bros from imposing their self-serving plans on Australia must be considered a good thing. Ian Usman Lewis, Armidale

Here we go. Welcome aboard the Trump rollercoaster. Planned to last about two years only, it’s poorly built, noisy and dangerous, and has all the expected unexpected twists and turns. Designed to arrest the senses and take the spotlight away from all other rides. And in the end, tear itself to pieces. Trump signs an agreement in Manila, sucking up praise from all around him, then returns to the White House to diss the initiative and pander to his base. AI companies won’t listen to his “build it here” rubbish. Corporate greed will steamroller his pathetic ravings, and just as he can veto the now Democratic US Congress, so too can Congress and the courts stymie his attempts at gross malfeasance. We can only hope that his lying and corruption, bolstered by the same latent greed and arrogance in his supporters, can be flushed from the US when he is no longer president. Andrew Scott, Pymble

It has been said that every picture tells a story (“ Trump’s powerful optics handed Xi a vision of a new world order ”, November 21) What I see in this picture is a pile of hypocrisy and self-absorption which threatens global stability. Lyn Savage, Coogee

Describing Trump, Putin and Xi as peacemakers is akin to describing me as a trickle-down economist, my wife as a morning person and my cat, Pippa, as a ferocious lion. Phil Peak, Dubbo

The report on home-birth midwives being required to hold adequate insurance (“ Midwives fear upcoming rule change ”, November 21) reminds us of the purpose of professional indemnity insurance (PII). It is to protect patients. An independent practitioner is held responsible for the outcomes of their decisions, and no provider is immune from human error. This move should not be seen as restricting choice, but about making choices safer. Sue Ieraci, Balmain

Your editorial, “ Has the RBA gone too far? ” (November 21), is both instructive and insightful. It highlights the deteriorating circumstances of lower-paid Australians and those dependent on government benefits. But it raises a more fundamental question: what evidence informs the Reserve Bank’s decisions to wield the blunt instrument of interest rates? The bank appears excessively reliant on historical statistics, particularly those produced by the Australian Bureau of Statistics. Such data records what happened. It does not necessarily provide sufficient evidence of what will happen in rapidly changing circumstances. Retailers are struggling, businesses are closing, manufacturing continues to decline, and major employers, including banks and telecommunications companies, are exporting thousands of Australian jobs. Surely, these developments should have informed the bank’s deliberations before its November decision. Instead, it appears to have disregarded the mounting evidence of economic weakness in favour of backward-looking statistical indicators. With recession in 2027 an increasingly plausible prospect, further monetary tightening risks inflicting disproportionate hardship on those least able to withstand it. The Reserve Bank’s independence is important, but independence must be accompanied by accountability and sound judgement. Should Australians be expected to accept economic hardship imposed by decisions that appear increasingly disconnected from the economy people actually experience? Chris Rivers, Port Macquarie

Millie Muroi has come up with a brilliant suggestion (“ The government can improve its own productivity – and it should ”, November 21). We constantly hear about cost overruns from infrastructure projects. But as Muroi points out, one of the prime reasons is that aspiring companies, when they compile quotes, start from scratch. Yet, from the housing industry, we know there are pattern designs that are modified slightly and used over and over again. Why reinvent the wheel with each infrastructure project when you can reuse previous models with slight variations as well? This could save millions of taxpayer dollars and deserves consideration. Larry Woldenberg, Forest Lodge

I read Chris Barrett’s reflection on Cameron Bancroft’s response to Pat Cummins’ account of Sandpapergate (“ Falling apart at the seams: Inside cricket’s state of emergency ”, November 21). I’ve read Usman Khawaja’s statements. I’ve seen Bancroft’s. I saw Cummins’ press conference and listened to his explanation of the dressing room configuration. I understood for the first time that roughening the ball for swing batting practice was common, as was the presence of sandpaper in a dressing room. I’ve heard nothing from Steve Smith, who took the ultimate blame and paid the ultimate price. The only clarity I have is that everyone who says it happened has nothing to lose but maybe something to gain now. Where was this “truth” from them when it mattered back then, and why are we placing so much weight on their word now? It may sell news, but it doesn’t make sense to me. Let’s get on with the cricket – that has enough of its own challenges. Brian Barrett, Padstow

If cricket is a team sport, surely the whole team should have been punished for ball tampering. It would have been a mess, but not as bad as what is happening now. Lynne Poleson, Kingsford

With a whole lot of couch cricket viewers potentially becoming furious if you don’t win, what bowler wouldn’t be tempted to grab some sandpaper? And why not make this legal if it helps the game? Mary Julian, Glebe

Sandpapergate refuses to die. It’s thrown Australian cricket into a tizz, but I haven’t seen a word from South Africa. If anyone has a right to complain, it’s them. Ian Adair, Hunters Hill

The revival of the Sandpapergate scandal has turned me into an avid reader of cricket stories, after many decades of disdain. I’m sure I’m not the only one who’s converted from “Cricket? Tragic” to a cricket tragic. Richard Mason, Newtown

Maybe we can learn something from this cunning ruse of sandpaper on cricket ball. Is it possible to enhance a rugby ball with velcro to enable our Wallabies to hold on to it? Kent Mayo, Uralla

It is not just the team or individual players who need to ’fess up (“ Lies do more harm than sandpaper ”, November 21). Cricket Australia needs to come clean and apologise for its mishandling of the crisis both then and now. Prioritising corporate reputation over full disclosure has resulted in a tangled web worthy of a Royal Commission, if not a miniseries. CA’s attempts to control the narrative and limit the damage have failed. The decision it makes now will determine both the legacy and legitimacy of this era of cricket for players and fans alike. Best not to let us down again. Philip Cooney, Wentworth Falls

Ball tampering has been around since Robin Hood opened for Nottingham. Simply rubbing the shiny side of the ball on one’s trousers is ball tampering. A lot has been written about the players, but the real culprits in this sorry saga are the members of the CA panel who imposed those ridiculous penalties, which were way out of proportion, causing a storm in a teacup. Lyle Keats, Miranda

One would have thought the Australian Cricket Board and cricketers who were involved in the ball-tampering saga would have learnt from the past, for example: the findings of the Nuremberg Trials, 1945-1946, where the defences of “following orders” and “I saw nothing” were rejected. It is almost insulting and hurtful to the public at large who follow this honourable game, for the cricket board and players to deny any knowledge of such recalcitrant behaviour, bringing this game into disrepute. Please own up and apologise. Gemunu Kumarasinhe, Lismore

You said it well, Kate Halfpenny (“ Once again it takes a woman to call out men’s behaviour ”, November 21). Women and fair-minded men should thank Cameron Bancroft for noting that the team’s media manager, Kate Hutchison, “said it was wrong, said she wanted nothing to do with it. Walked away.” I’d like to know: did they listen to her, ignore her, berate her, say she was interfering, or had no right to object? And afterwards, how did they treat her? Perhaps it’s why she left Cricket Australia soon after. It must have taken courage to confront these male “champions”. If only they’d listened to her and decided she had the rights of it. Or if only one of the blokes had backed her or said forcefully they were better than being cheats. Jennifer Fergus, Croydon

The fact that “the media manager of the Australian cricket team at Cape Town in 2018” (“ The Fitz Files ”, November 21) was on tour says it all. Don Bradman’s legendary unbeaten Invincibles team in England in 1948 required no media manager on tour or otherwise. We can thank Kerry Packer for the fact that since he revolutionised cricket, media managers are as important as batting coaches. Robert Crawford, Cheltenham

I can say, from decades of experience ( Letters , November 21), that a good moustache protects one’s lips from sunburn. Peter Butler, Wyongah

A wonderful and optimistic story and pictures of love and hope winning over hate (“ Dark to light: couple reclaim Bondi Beach for wedding day ”, November 21). Food for the souls of us all. Judy Finch, Taree

I have noticed that well over a month before December 25, Christmas trees are proliferating in public places. It seems to be getting earlier each year. Is this climate change in action? Richard Grant, St Leonards

Prev Swipe Story Next

Related Stories

Science & Climate
Build #2612