First published 20 Nov 2026, 10:23am
DIY roof repairs could actually be causing more of a problem than they fix, and lead to costly remediation bills, one expert says.
With the current cost-of-living crisis, many homeowners are opting for a do-it-yourself approach to home repairs and maintenance, however ABE Roofing founder and director Peter Abednego said the wrong approach could lead to a more costly fix down the track.
It’s a matter of knowing what can be done, and what should be left to the experts, he says, with some problems able to be fixed in-house, and others requiring a more specialised repair.
Some proper maintenance can avoid a costly repair. Stuff up a small job, mind you, and you’ll cause one.
While some roofing problems require professional attention, not every cracked tile, small hole or leaking gutter needs to result in a call-out.
Proper maintenance, Mr Abednego says, can help prevent minor damage from becoming a bigger problem.
“Regular roof maintenance can help prevent small problems from becoming major repairs,” he said.
“We often see homeowners attempting to fix leaks using silicone or other products that aren’t necessarily suited to the job.
“Some smaller repairs can be tackled with purpose-designed products, but more extensive damage is best left to professionals.”
ABE Roofing founder and director Peter Abednego. Supplied
According to Compare the Market research from earlier this month, 68 per cent of surveyed Australians have attempted repairs to walls, floors, doors, or windows, with 64 per cent doing repairs to roofs, gutters, or outdoor areas.
Compare the Market’s Chris Ford said the cost-of-living crisis had many Australians looking for ways to save money.
“Spring has a funny way of making every unfinished job around the house impossible to ignore,” Mr Ford said.
“Suddenly the leaky tap, loose fence panel and overflowing gutter that’s been on the to-do list for months is demanding attention all at once.
“With household budgets still under pressure from higher interest rates and increased costs across the board, it’s understandable that many Australians are looking to save money by doing the work themselves.
“Painting a wall is one thing, but jobs involving plumbing, electrical work or structural repairs can come with much bigger risks if something goes wrong.”
Mr Ford said homeowners should also understand the potential insurance implications before taking on larger repair jobs.
“Every insurer and policy is different, but if faulty workmanship contributes to damage later on, it could complicate an insurance claim,” Mr Ford said.
“Insurers will typically investigate the cause of any damage and whether repairs were carried out appropriately.
“If in doubt, contact your insurer ahead of time to confirm whether your renovations or repairs would be covered.
“We’ve all been tempted to watch a few online tutorials and give it a crack, but some jobs can end up costing far more if they don’t go to plan.
“What looks like a money-saving exercise today could become a very expensive repair job tomorrow.”
Workers undertake repair work on the roof of a building. Picture: Anna Rogers
For those considering doing their own roof repairs, Mr Abednego supplied five common roof repair mistakes to avoid.
Got a gap? Add silicone. Still leaking? Add more silicone.
While silicone has its place, it’s not a universal solution for roof leaks. Applying it incorrectly to cracked tiles, damaged flashing or leaking gutters can trap water, interfere with drainage or conceal damage without stopping the leak.
For minor damage, such as an isolated cracked tile or small hole in metal roofing, a purpose-designed flashing patch and waterproofing compound can provide a more suitable solution.
“Using the right products can make a significant difference to the effectiveness of a repair,” Mr Abednego said.
The before-and-after transformation of a freshly cleaned roof can be satisfying, but reaching for a high-pressure water can damage roofing materials, dislodge ageing surfaces or force water into areas it wouldn’t ordinarily reach.
High-pressure cleaning is generally better suited to professional roof restoration projects. For routine maintenance, gentler cleaning methods may be more appropriate, depending on the roof’s condition.
Importantly, cleaning won’t fix existing damage. Cracked tiles, small holes or deteriorating flashing need to be addressed using suitable repair methods.
A ceiling stain doesn’t necessarily mean the leak is directly above it. Water can travel along roof components before appearing inside the home, meaning patching the most obvious spot may not solve the problem.
“We start by checking where water appears inside the home, such as a ceiling stain. We then inspect the roof for broken or dislodged tiles, cracked ridge capping, overflowing gutters and damaged flashing,” said Mr Abednego.
“Water can travel quite a distance, so the source isn’t always where you’d expect.”
While an identifiable crack or small hole may be suitable for a straightforward patch repair, unexplained or recurring leaks are best investigated by a professional.
A cracked roof tile, small hole in metal roofing or damaged gutter might not seem urgent, but leaving minor damage unattended can allow water to penetrate surrounding materials, potentially turning a simple repair into a more expensive problem.
Homeowners should monitor visible damage from the ground, particularly after heavy winds or storms.
Where damage is minor, clearly identified and safely accessible, a purpose-designed repair product allows homeowners to address it before it worsens.
Not every minor roof repair requires a professional, but knowing your limits is essential.
“Safety always comes first. Roof surfaces can be slippery, even in dry conditions, so homeowners need to consider whether they can safely access the area,” said Mr Abednego.
“Extensive damage, ongoing leaks or problems you can’t identify should be left to a roofer.”
Help us improve your reading experience
Got a minute? Your feedback will help us build a better experience for you.