A council is trying to recruit Sir Elton John to back its bid to become UK Town of Culture in 2028.
Grimsby hopes the musical superstar's support will boost its chances of winning the year-long arts festival award.
Sir Elton released an album track in 1974 called Grimsby, written by his Lincolnshire-born songwriting partner Bernie Taupin.
The lyrics mention "a thousand delights couldn't match the sweet sights of my Grimsby".
Grimsby-born Elton John tribute act Tom Weston said the Rocketman singer "should stand by those words".
"Because there is a thousand delights in its history and its future and of course its present," he told BBC Radio Humberside Breakfast Show.
The song joins others extolling the virtues of town and cities, such as Frank Sinatra's New York, New York, but instead of "a city that doesn't sleep" Sir Elton sings about trawlers, funfairs and drinking in pubs.
Taupin's lyrical longing for his home town also covers its culinary delights "no Cordon Bleu can match the beauty of your pies and peas".
North East Lincolnshire Council and local Labour MP Melanie Onn have written an open letter to Sir Elton in an attempt to get him on board.
Sarah Smith, from the council, is also encouraging a social media campaign to persuade the star to endorse the GY28 bid.
"When you're trying to put Grimsby on the national stage, who better to ask than someone who already did it in a song," she said
"We know Sir Elton receives thousands of requests, so perhaps this one is a little bold, but GY28 is all about ambition, confidence and believing big things can happen.
"This could just be the rocket fuel that fires it even further."
Grimsby has made it to the final large towns shortlist alongside Basildon, Birkenhead and Rotherham, with the winner receiving a £3m grant for cultural events and two runners-up receiving £250,000 each.
The winner is due to be announced in March 2027.
Listen to highlights from Lincolnshire on BBC Sounds , watch the latest episode of Look North .
Download the BBC News app from the App Store for iPhone and iPad or Google Play for Android devices