Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

‘We want our story to be told’: inside a shocking 36-year fight for justice in Baltimore

The Guardian •
November 18, 2026 • 10:00 AM
3
3 reads 0 reactions

A staggering case of injustice is explored in the galling HBO documentary When a Witness Recants. The three subjects and producer Ta-Nehisi Coates explain how it unfolded

1 / 3
Swipe Photos

F or most of his life, the writer Ta-Nehisi Coates would occasionally think of a chilling episode from his childhood in West Baltimore: almost exactly 43 years ago, on 18 November 1983, a 14-year-old boy named DeWitt Duckett was shot and killed in a hallway of Harlem Park junior high school in the middle of the afternoon, by an older teenager who stole his blue satin Georgetown jacket.

Coates was only eight years old at the time, too young to know the details, but old enough to perceive the collective horror around him. The sensational event – the first time a kid was killed inside a Baltimore public school, according to wall-to-wall local press – was a rupture in his child’s view of the world. “It was first time I had the sense that, oh, actually, I exist in a very dangerous world,” he told the Guardian. “And then you cut to the TV and it’s clear the rest of America is not existing in that dangerous world. The dangerous world is only for you and people who look like you.” Coates always assumed that the three teenage boys arrested and convicted for the murder were the right guys, and the episode faded into one of those strange imprints from the past, a blurry but foundational event.

That is, until a 2021 New Yorker article by the journalist Jennifer Gonnerman, which detailed the long haunting of Ron Bishop, Duckett’s friend who was walking alongside him when he was shot. For those four decades, Bishop had recurring nightmares not about the killing of his friend, but the trial afterward: under threat of violence and arrest from police, Bishop, then 14, testified that three teenage boys – Alfred Chestnut, Ransom Watkins and Andrew Stewart – had together shot and killed Duckett, though Bishop knew they were innocent. In 2019, Bishop officially recanted his coerced testimony. The retraction, along with reams of long-buried evidence composing, as one Maryland state attorney puts it in the new HBO documentary When a Witness Recants, “the most egregious wrongful conviction case in my career”, led to the men’s release . They had each spent 36 years in prison, always maintaining their innocence.

Soon after the article ran, a stunned Coates, one of the nation’s pre-eminent public intellectuals on racial injustice, teamed up with the documentarian Dawn Porter to meet the three men in Baltimore. Coates offered an apology on behalf of the community where they all grew up. “I was obviously very young, so I couldn’t have done anything at that point in time,” he recalled, “but I just thought as a community, we had let these brothers down, and somebody needed to say that to them.” “The guys”, as Coates and Porter call them, accepted the apology, and agreed to participate in a documentary exploring the aftermath of both wrongful incarceration and long-sought resolution.

The “Harlem Park Three”, separated in prison for 27 years, still operate as a unit, one picking up where another leaves off. “We want our story to be told,” Chestnut said of the decision. Stewart added: “We have an opportunity with this documentary to tell the world that in spite of what people say, in spite of what people feel and how they look at us, that ain’t us … We don’t want the world to see us because of our pain, because that’s never going to change. We want the world to see us overcoming our pain.” As a group, “they just said, will you tell the truth?” Porter recalled. “And that weighed on us. For most people, that’s a very obvious question. But when you have been lied about and violated in this way, it’s the only question.”

When a Witness Recants, directed by Porter with Coates as participant and executive producer, delves into truths both emotional and literal. It is a love letter to Baltimore and a galling account of systemic injustice, a document of appalling failures on every level, from life-ruining lack of interest on the part of police to stunning callousness by state prosecutors. And it is above all a singular account of the possibly unhealable wounds of wrongful incarceration – for the exonerated men, for the witnesses coerced to send those men to prison, for the community whose sense of trust and safety was shattered.

The first half of the film traces just how this travesty could happen. The facts “were even more egregious”, than they expected, said Porter. On camera, Bishop recalls being pressured by detective Donald Kincaid to change his initial statement to police, from one shooter to Chestnut, Watkins and Stewart, with threats of violence or prison: “I know I am not leaving alive if I don’t tell him that Alfred shot Dewitt, Alfred had the gun, Andrew and Ransom were pulling the jacket off of him.” The judge, Robert M Bell, did not question a grand jury testimony riddled with inconsistencies. The prosecutor, Jonathan Shoup, brushed off Bishop’s protestations about not telling the truth, pressured him back on the stand, and failed to share any police files with the defense.

Those files, obtained by Chestnut via public records request in 2018, showed that multiple people reported to police that another teen named Michael Willis wore Duckett’s jacket to a roller rink and bragged about the crime; he was never questioned. (Willis was shot and killed in 2002. Shoup died in 2016; his obituary listed the “Georgetown jacket” case as one of his noteworthy accomplishments as a prosecutor. Kincaid declined to participate; asked in a 2022 deposition what he would have changed about his investigation, he answered: “Nothing.”)

“The deeper we got into it, the clearer it was that they had been railroaded in this horrible way,” said Porter of the evidence. “It all just became even more enraging.” The film relies in part on graphic novel-style illustrations to convey the boys’ fear and pain, as actual courtroom sketches from the trial depict the three 16-year-olds as adults. “It’s disgusting,” said Coates of the legal proceedings. “The police department showed about as much regard for DeWitt Duckett’s life as the person who killed him. They did not even bother to seriously investigate it, to try to seriously find out. They just pinned it on some people. They just closed the case, and that was it.”

In the 36 years after, Chestnut, Watkins and Stewart strove to overturn their convictions, and make sense of lives thwarted before they really began. Bishop graduated high school, went to college, got married and became a mental health counsellor. After the guys’ release, all four expressed a desire to meet in person. The film’s final third documents that meeting, to devastating effect. There is no mutual rapprochement between Bishop and the trio, no path forward to forgiveness, as suggested by the conclusion of the New Yorker article or expected by viewers of a documentary years in the making. The meeting, instead, is derailed by Bishop’s rambling self-justifications, then ended by each man’s blisteringly honest expressions of anger. “It was painful,” Chestnut recalled of the moment he realized that no satisfying apology would arrive. “It made us all angry to listen to him talk,” knowing they could have been freed had someone spoken up years, decades earlier.

“This could have been the moment that turned our lives around,” Stewart added. Instead, it became a release for all the hurt and betrayal that could never be assuaged. “When I walked in there, I was trying to be politically correct, say what people want to hear,” said Watkins. But he found himself thinking “if I don’t tell this man how I feel, and I’ve been waiting on this for 36 years … you ain’t going to never in your life get a chance to do it again. So I just let it flow.”

It is an astonishing scene to watch, unflinching and revelatory in its refusal to bend toward soothing conclusions or deny anyone their time. Life does go on – Watkins, Stewart and Chestnut are each partnered, building their lives in middle age. Chestnut now has a young daughter. All express an enthusiasm for what lies ahead. But the film stands in testament to damage that also carries forward, despite or in tandem with great persistence. “There’s a lot of victims here,” said Porter. “We can’t correct the harm of a wrongful incarceration. We have to stop it from happening in the first place.

“To me, that’s the lesson: you can’t fix this. Money doesn’t fix it. Nothing fixes it. You have to just not do it.”

When a Witness Recants premieres on HBO on 18 November and will be available on HBO Max in the US and UK

Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 1 other independent news outlet reported on this story.

1 Publication
SBS News Australia
1d ago
Uncle Ned's fight for justice and hope for his Warlpiri community

Uncle Ned's fight for justice and hope for his Warlpiri community

Despite years of frustration, devastating loss and heartbreak, an iconic Warlpiri Elder shares his hopes for his grandchildren and future generations.

#fight #justice
Compare →

Related Stories

World News
Build #2612