Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

Adelaide woman guilty of manslaughter after neighbour stabbed 34 times

ABC News Australia •
November 18, 2026 • 07:02 AM
1
1 reads 0 reactions

Adelaide woman Cynthia Rigney has been found not guilty of murder but guilty of the stabbing manslaughter of 61-year-old cannabis dealer Maria Luis in 2018.

1 / 2
Swipe Photos

Cynthia Rigney was found guilty of manslaughter, not guilty of murder. ( ABC News )

Cynthia Ellen Rigney has been found guilty of manslaughter after fatally stabbing a 61-year-old Adelaide woman in 2018.

Rigney was found not guilty of murder.

An updated psychiatric report has been ordered ahead of Rigney's sentencing.

An Adelaide woman who stood trial for stabbing another woman 34 times because the victim refused to sell cannabis to her has been found not guilty of murder, but guilty of manslaughter.

South Australia's Supreme Court today found Cynthia Ellen Rigney killed Maria Luis in December 2018 at the victim's home on Goodman Avenue at Kilburn.

The court found Rigney, who was then aged 19 and lived on the same street, had treatment-resistant schizophrenia.

Rigney appeared in court via video link from forensic mental health facility James Nash House and smiled as the verdict of "manslaughter by an unlawful and dangerous act" was handed down.

In her published reasons for the verdict, Justice Anne Bampton said she could not find Rigney stabbed Ms Luis with the specific intent to kill or cause really serious bodily harm.

She noted Rigney had been captured on CCTV arriving at the address and leaving three minutes later.

Police outside a home at Kilburn where a 61-year-old woman was fatally stabbed. ( ABC News: Carl Saville )

Justice Bampton said Ms Luis had lived in the area for "quite some time" and was known in the local community as a cannabis dealer.

She said Ms Luis's husband told police his wife did not sell cannabis to Aboriginal or young people.

A neighbour had also reported days before the incident Rigney was screaming on Ms Luis's porch, and had told Rigney to "snap out of it" and "have some respect".

Justice Bampton noted that Rigney had then asked the neighbour if she could "get me a bag then".

According to the ruling, Rigney was arrested a short time after the stabbing incident.

Specialised police officers had forced entry into her home where she was found sleeping with a plastic bag containing cannabis attached to her leg.

Justice Bampton said medical experts in the trial had identified a non-psychotic, alternative explanation for Rigney's conduct, which is why she was not considered unfit to stand trial.

"She had a history of buying cannabis from Maria Luis, had conflict with her in the days leading up to the stabbing, and had possibly attempted to buy or had bought cannabis from Maria Luis but had some form of disagreement with her in the course of that interaction," Justice Bampton wrote.

"It is likely that if such a disagreement had occurred, in her psychotic state, Ms Rigney would have been predisposed to react in a paranoid, impulsive, and aggressive manner."

Justice Anne Bampton found Rigney guilty of manslaughter, but not guilty of murder.

Justic Bampton said one of the medical expert's concluded Rigney would have acted on impulse and in a heightened emotional state but would nonetheless have "known the wrongfulness of her behaviour."

But Justice Bampton said she considered Rigney's mental condition when taking into account the "specific intent" element of murder.

"The number and location of the stab wounds inflicted is undoubtedly suggestive of specific intent," she said.

But she said that since Rigney had treatment‑resistant schizophrenia and was likely suffering from psychosis at the time of the stabbing, she could not be satisfied that "the reasonable possibility the stabbing was the result of a psychotic motive in the context of a delusion held has been excluded".

Justice Bampton granted the defence time to seek an updated psychiatric report ahead of Rigney's sentencing.

The matter will return to court in December.

Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 5 other independent news outlets reported on this story.

5 Publications
The Urban Developer
5d ago
Adelaide Hills Village Weighs Highrise Shift for Downsizers

Adelaide Hills Village Weighs Highrise Shift for Downsizers

Housing and services designed around ageing in place is planned for a 1.4ha site behind the town’s tree-lined retail strip...

#adelaide
Compare →
RealEstate.com.au News
5d ago
Rose Park penthouse draws 60+ groups at Adelaide launch - realestate.com.au

Rose Park penthouse draws 60+ groups at Adelaide launch - realestate.com.au

In a market categorised by value loss, low auction clearance rates and more days on market, one offering – which attracted more than 60 groups to its launch – is proving this segment is still on fire.

#adelaide
Compare →
The Australian Financial Review (AFR)
1w ago
Mayne Pharma sells Adelaide plant to focus on US

Mayne Pharma sells Adelaide plant to focus on US

Shareholders are betting on the sale of Mayne’s US operations once it no longer owns an Australian manufacturing site.

#adelaide
Compare →
Build Australia
1w ago
Councils and local builder to accelerate project delivery in Adelaide

Councils and local builder to accelerate project delivery in Adelaide

Three South Australian local councils have formed a partnership with Adelaide-based builder Kennett to streamline project delivery

#adelaide
Compare →
BBC News
1w ago
County Louth: Robert O'Connor found guilty of manslaughter for killing 3 family members

County Louth: Robert O'Connor found guilty of manslaughter for killing 3 family members

Louise O'Connor, Mark O'Connor, and Evan O'Connor were found dead at their rural home in Drumgowna in 2025.

#guilty #manslaughter
Compare →

Related Stories

Australia & Pacific
Build #2612