Why does the pastry base of my apple pie always come out soggy? What am I doing wrong? Sophie, by email “The very first thing I would say is that Sophie has got to look at her filling, and how wet it is,” says Calum Franklin, author of The Modern Pie Maker and all-round pie Yoda. “Apples contain quite a lot of water already, so you don’t generally need to add any extra liquid to the filling.” Instead, he’d simply cook the apples with sugar: “Just let them break down.”
That said, Sophie could always consider including some sort of barrier, too, says Dee Rettali, co-founder of Fortitude Bakehouse in London: “My mother was an amazing baker, and she always sprinkled a very fine crumble mix [just sugar and flour, no fat] on the bottom of her pie before putting in any fruit. That will then absorb most of the liquid.”
You need to let the dough rest first, mind, which Rettali does in the freezer until firm: “That will set you up for a good, longer bake, which obviously means you’re baking the bottom more.” Sophie will also need to consider how she gets the heat to her pie bottom, Rettali adds: “When I was a kid, we’d bake apple pies in ceramic dishes or in the lid of a Pyrex casserole dish, and you’d look at the bottom and think, well, that looks a bit raw. Now, I would never tell my mother she did it the wrong way, but when I became a pastry chef, the first thing I was taught was that if you’re making a pie, do it in a metal tin, because it conducts heat better.” If you have a perforated one to hand, so much the better: “That allows the steam to come out, meaning you get a nice, brown bottom.” This is also why she doesn’t bother making a hole in the top of her pies. Franklin, however, does go for a hole, then finishes proceedings with egg wash: “Pure egg yolk, though; no white, because that makes the pastry dull. Then I top that with some demerara sugar for crunch.”
On to the bake itself, and Rettali always pops her tin on a baking stone in the oven, because “it really conducts heat into the bottom of the pie”. Franklin, however, thinks that’s a “slightly unnecessary step”. The reason? “It puts a barrier between the base of the pie and the direct heat.” Instead, he simply slides the tin straight on to a rack in the oven: “It will just cook better.”
Gummy, undercooked pastry can also be avoided simply by baking the pie for a bit longer, Franklin says: “With the exception of my own cookbooks, of course, I never think pie recipes give the right cooking times. Always give yourself an extra 10 minutes.” After all, not every home oven is as hot as it says on the dial. And a large pie, Franklin adds, is going to take at least 40 minutes.
So how do you know it’s ready? “Look for a mahogany colour,” Franklin says. “That means it’s caramelised, it’s tasty and the likelihood is that the base is crisp.” Or, in other words, pie perfection.
Got a culinary dilemma? Email [email protected]