Axar became India’s fixer because each collapse in the series put him in the firing line, and a left-hander at number five changes the look of the batting order. India won the five-game series on New Zealand soil 3-1, but he arrived after an early wicket in every game he batted. His tally was 74 runs from four innings, as the third match was rained off. The sharper question is whether a bowling all-rounder should be repairing a middle order that keeps coming apart.
Trouble arrived in every game that got played. In the Auckland chase of a revised 143 on 4 November, India sat comfortably on 114 for one before losing four more wickets by 136. Wellington, three days later, was messier: 39 for three, then 111 for seven, and a four-run win that owed everything to rain and the DLS method.
The fourth match, played at Mount Maunganui on the 13th, was the worst. Shreyas Iyer, Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli each made ducks, and India folded for 89 while chasing 334. In the decider two days later, the trio of Rohit, Kohli and Ruturaj Gaikwad had departed with 34 up, nine overs in.
Each time Axar walked out, a wicket had just fallen. The highest team score he came in at was 124 for three. Over four innings, he gathered 74 runs off 110 balls, averaging 18.50 and striking at 67.27, and his 46 in the decider equalled Ishan Kishan’s as the best score of that innings.
For context, he scored 109 across five Champions Trophy innings in 2025 and 60 in three games on the 2026 England tour. Before this series, his record at number five read 365 runs in 13 innings at 30.41, as of 9 November.
Handedness comes first. All four of India’s top batters bat right-handed, so a left-hander at five breaks the pattern. Batting coach Sitanshu Kotak made the point before the Hamilton game, adding that Axar ranks ahead of KL Rahul partly because Rahul is better used as a finisher.
Captain Shubman Gill has described the batting positions from five downward as flexible, shifting with the game. Head coach Gautam Gambhir backed that approach in February 2025, arguing the game is meant to be played that way. Sunil Gavaskar sees another benefit, because a left-hander makes bowlers adjust line and length.
Wellington showed the risk. He came in at 39 for three, lasted 17 balls, scored 7 and fell to a short delivery from Matthew Fisher with India 47 for four. At Auckland, Jacob Duffy dismissed him the same way, a short ball ending a two-ball stay without a run.
The decider was the exception. Walking in at 34 for three, Axar batted 55 balls for 46 and built a 52-run partnership with Iyer. That base let India defend 209 and win by 22 runs.
The role succeeded once in four tries, which reflects on the top order more than on Axar. Rohit and Kohli both failed to reach ten when it mattered most. Rahul, who followed Axar to the crease in the opening pair of games, has 1,646 ODI runs at 68.58 when batting at five, including four hundreds.
Axar remains a real all-rounder, after taking six wickets in the series, plus an Edgbaston performance in July of 57 not out plus 4 for 62. Going into the fourth match, his career return of 925 runs in ODIs at 22.56 does not make him the batter to stabilise a collapse. India’s real weakness is the top three, so the better arrangement puts Axar behind Rahul, at six or seven, with Axar Patel’s New Zealand ODI batting evidence pointing the same way ahead of the 2027 World Cup.
Do you want Axar kept at number five, or moved down so Rahul can anchor the middle order? Tell us in the comments.
How many runs did Axar score on the New Zealand tour?
Axar made 74 runs from four innings, scoring 0, 7, 21 and 46. The rained-off third match meant he had no chance to bat in it.
Who bats at number six for India in ODIs?
India has no fixed number six, with Axar Patel and KL Rahul sharing the slots at five and six. Rahul followed Axar at six in the series opener and the second game.
Is Axar Patel a genuine all-rounder in ODI cricket?
Yes, he is a genuine all-rounder, but not a specialist batter. At number five, he averages 30.41 at a strike rate of 87.11, and he bowls a full quota of spin.
What are India’s biggest batting problems in ODIs right now?
The top order is the biggest problem, since Rohit and Kohli both failed in the decider. No batter reached 100 runs in the series, and India once collapsed to 89 all out.
Why do India pick a left-hander at number five?
Selectors want a left-hander because the top four in India’s order all bat right-handed. Batting coach Sitanshu Kotak also described Rahul as a finisher, so Axar sits above him.