Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

Enforce the rules for signs of the time

The Age •
November 17, 2026 • 09:00 AM
3
3 reads 0 reactions

Readers have questions about polling day and party promises without financials attached.

1 / 8
Swipe Photos

To submit a letter to The Age , email [email protected] . Please include your home address and telephone number below your letter. No attachments. See here for our rules and tips on getting your letter pub lished.

The state election is nearly with us, and already we’re seeing the usual confrontations about election signage start up again. The Australian Electoral Commission and the Victorian Electoral Commission should make, and enforce, very clear rules about where, and how many, election signs can be displayed. This is especially needed near polling places, but also other public locations, such as shopping centres and train stations. Last election, one ‘early bird’ candidate would attempt to completely fill the available space with their signs. The next candidate would arrive, and find almost nowhere to put their signs up, other than in front of the existing signs. Subsequent candidates would arrive and find the situation even worse. Simply restricting each candidate to a set number of signs, or perhaps a quota of no more than 10 per cent of the available space, would remove a lot of confrontation. Any breach could be penalised by a ban of the offending candidate’s signs at that location for 48 hours. Geoffrey McNaughton, Glen Huntly

Avoiding the rat run of pamphleteers Isn’t it time we banned ‘how-to-vote’ cards – especially at polling booths, both on-the-day and pre-polling? I and many others find the rat run of party workers handing them out at booths intensely annoying and likely to elicit brusque or even rude comments. Why cannot parties treat voters like intelligent adults and encourage us to make up our own minds? We have an amazingly democratic electoral system, an example to the rest of the world, but this is the one feature that really makes me angry. Mick Webster, Chiltern

Living in the Hawthorn bubble If it were not for a smattering of corflutes from two candidates and three pamphlets between them thrust in our letter box, we in the Hawthorn electorate would not know there was an election under way. We have no idea who the other candidates are. We feel treated with disdain by two of the parties vying for government. It is inexplicable they are uninterested in a winnable lower house seat, much less garnering upper house votes. Graham Devries, Camberwell

More to voters’ concerns than potholes Your correspondent is spot on (Letters 17/11 ): voter surveys cover very limited ground. They effectively push-poll by omitting important topics such as nature. They waste a golden opportunity to tap into voters’ values. Are we OK with the destruction of old-growth forests that protect native animals facing extinction? Are we concerned about the wounded waterbirds left by duck shooters? Do we feel safe in national parks where deer hunters operate? Do we support the routine bashing of kangaroo joeys when commercial shooters kill the mother? Should we have tighter controls on gun ownership? Of course, we worry about bills, jobs, crime and potholes. But most of us can walk and chew gum. Joan Reilly, Surrey Hills

Who is premier if Wilson loses seat? Your correspondent ( 15/11 ) ponders the consequences if the Liberals win the election and Jess Wilson loses her seat, then who would be premier? Considering the Liberals are outpolling Labor, with the opposition leader on a net approval rating of plus 24 and Ben Carroll on minus 19, there is a higher probability of the premier losing his seat of Niddrie than the alternative scenario. Let’s remember, the opposition does not win elections, the government loses them. Christo Krousoratis, Templestowe

What does my vote buy? A political party should be compelled to release its policy costings at least by the time pre-poll voting is available to electors. Major parties are waiting until the last minute despite releasing the main thrust and some of the content of their policies. This election, the costings are more important as the parties are trying to prove themselves to be the best economic managers. Are we supposed to just trust them? The State Parliamentary Budget Office hasn’t received any details yet, and so it can’t publish anything. One Nation has said it won’t even publish costings before the election. The political parties are trying to sell us something, and we are supposed to buy it with our vote. We don’t yet know what we are buying or what it costs. I’ve already got too much unusable snake oil from the last federal election. Greg Tuck, Warragul

AFL has enough funding Pay for your own facilities, AFL. You get enough money from the population via gambling. Taxpayers shouldn’t be funding you. Budget like everyone else does for things you want -- like stadiums in Tasmania (″⁣ Carroll kicks in $55m for AFL clubs ″⁣, 16/11). Belinda Burke, Hawthorn

How to alienate voters Adam Carey’s article (“ Labor’s fast-track planning scheme gives tick to all but one proposal ”, 17/11) exemplifies how the corporatisation of political parties in Australia has replaced community consultation with centralised control. Labor’s barge-through and build-big attitude has alienated many previous supporters. There is little evidence that the Coalition will be much better. It’s time to hunt around for candidates who are not captured by vested interests or party control and can independently represent their communities. Allan Dowsett, Preston

Kennett’s shadow As a resident of another community whose train station was shut down by Jeff Kennett in the 1990s, I sympathise with the Mildurans who want their passenger rail services back (″⁣ Can trains stop Hanson ‘Beatlemania’ in its tracks? Jess Wilson hopes so ″⁣, 16/11). Kennett’s campaign closures of services from technical high schools to regional railway stations destroyed jobs and devastated local communities. In recent years, both major parties have repeatedly promised to bring back many of the stations that Kennett shut down, but are always unable to do so due to the high costs involved, demonstrating that reversing Kennett’s legacy is easier said than done. The conservative philosopher Roger Scruton once remarked that ″⁣good things are easily destroyed but not easily created″⁣. This maxim has clearly been vindicated by Kennett’s premiership and its aftermath. Nikhil Dhanabal, Clyde North

Electricity transformation Reading ″⁣ Jess we can – but campaign launch serves a reminder the Liberals haven’t yet ″⁣, (15/11) provides a handy look at many of the reasons a Liberal Victorian government might be anything but the best thing for the state. Showcasing the most recent four leaders in the past four years with Matthew Guy, Brad Battin, John Pesutto, and now Jess Wilson reminds us of the recent disunity and in-fighting. Mention of Ted Baillieu and Denis Napthine sends shivers of the damaging approach to restructuring the energy system they presided over. And yet, the underwhelming Ben Carroll does not seem to realise the solid gold he sits on following the great work of Lily D’Ambrosio in setting up a vast renewable energy transformation that has given Victoria’s power the lowest wholesale electricity prices in the country (according to the Australian Energy Market Operator). Not once have we heard reference to this. Of equal concern is the lack of parliamentary depth that looms with an influx of inexperienced One Nation and Liberal candidates. Robert Brown, Camberwell

Contain measles threat Re ″⁣ US anti-vax rhetoric sparks fears over measles ″⁣, 17/11. I am a former registered nurse and among the thousands of patients I cared for over many years, one memory remains vivid – the tragic death of a 14-year-old girl from pan encephalitis, a rare, but well recognised, complication of the measles virus. There are also other non life-threatening complications such as ear infections which can lead to permanent hearing impairment. Robert F Kennedy Jr is profoundly uninformed, and sadly, Americans are now paying the price of the folly of his selection as health secretary. The public need to be educated on science-based facts, and dangerous so-called “wellness influencers” shut down where possible. Travellers to Australia from infected areas of America, and elsewhere, should be required to have a current vaccination certificate for entry here. It is time for immediate responsible action. Christine Harris, Mordialloc

Puberty blockers Federal Health Minister Mark Butler’s challenge to state and territory governments to align with the National Health and Medical Research Council’s interim advice (″⁣ Butler challenges states to allow puberty blockers ″⁣, 16/11) is a welcome and necessary intervention against politically motivated healthcare bans. Medical decisions for vulnerable adolescents must be guided by clinical expertise and scientific evidence, not populist political interference. Denying access to puberty blockers does not stop young people from experiencing gender dysphoria; it simply forces them into a harmful ″⁣wait and see″⁣ approach that withholds essential care and causes preventable psychological distress during an already difficult stage of life. Puberty blockers offer vital breathing room, safely pausing unwanted and irreversible physiological changes that conflict with a young person’s identity. Decades of clinical use and research show that timely, supportive, gender-affirming care drastically improves mental health and wellbeing among transgender teenagers. State governments must listen to medical consensus. Tim Singleton Norton, Reservoir

Flinders St patina Reading restaurateur Chris Lucas’ vision for the demolition of all but the facade of Flinders Street Station, one can only wonder if he has spent much time overseas? If he has, how could he fail to grasp that it’s the old buildings, tiled and plastered with character and history, which attract millions of people to Europe year after year, feeding our collective soul. The thought of rampaging through Flinders Street Station to make way for more new hotels, more new restaurants and yet more shopping is abhorrent. As one who has attended many exhibitions in the beautiful rooms above the station, I see it as a truly magical space, offering huge potential to anyone clever enough to be inventive while fully embracing the character and patina already on offer. Laurie Chartres, Hawksburn

No pride in selling rocks Being a quarry for the world didn’t make Donald Horne proud. (“That’s the difference Australian mining makes”, 17/11). He saw us not as a country to be proud of, but a lucky one, run by second-rate people who share its luck. Much of his assessment is still true. I might take more pride in Australia if we owned up to the fact that, including exports, our small nation is responsible for 4.5 per cent of global emissions. I would also be proud if we stopped exporting LNG to the several countries that are undermining decarbonising by creating new gas markets and that on-sell our gas. Taxing those gas exports more appropriately would show we valued our people’s futures and would make me proud. There are many ways I want to be proud of my country. Selling rocks isn’t one of them. Helen Bowman, Preston

Mapping the world I am struck by the letters in The Age worrying about the cuts to immigration and effects on care. One aged care facility I have been told of has a map of the world on display. Pins indicate all the places the workers in the facility come from, such as Nepal, India and the Philippines. This reportedly encourages all sorts of positive conversations about migration and immigrant workers. A good idea to foster understanding? Maila Stivens, St Kilda

Pat Cummins’ delivery I found the description of Pat Cummins’ performance in his press conference as statesman-like by some commentators disappointing. He was well-prepared and stood for 68 minutes taking questions. There is more to statesmanship than that. There was little substance to many of his answers which essentially defended his previous response, and that of his employer. He was scant on detail, had selective memory, did not address issues of institutional accountability and dismissed Usman Khawaja’s accounts as ″⁣nonsense″⁣. He accuses Khawaja of being ″⁣casual″⁣. Calling for collective responsibility and challenging a convenient narrative is not casual in my opinion. Dismissing someone’s lived experience strikes me as someone speaking from a position of privilege with little understanding of how systemic bias, unconscious prejudice and exclusion occur. Pat Cummins wants to draw a line under Sandpaper-gate. That means confronting uncomfortable truths not defending a flawed investigation and system by saying ″⁣nothing else to see here″⁣. Dhiren Singh, Malvern

State election They’ve all got plans, but who’s got the money? Wendy Baker, Lilydale

Your correspondent (Letters, 17/11 ) equates informal voting with wasting a vote. This is not quite right – to leave a poorly stocked shop without buying anything is still to vote with your feet. Peter Drum, Coburg

If three AFL clubs are promised $55 million, then what about the arts? How about a measly $1 million or so to put an organ in Hamer Hall to complete its recent upgrade? Rod Watson, East Brighton

I’m waiting for One Nation to offer every Victorian $5000 if we vote for them. Peter Sherry, Maidstone

Great to see Ben Carroll is currently reading anti-corruption crusader Robert F. Kennedy’s book, The Last Campaign (CBD 17/11 ). Maybe he could next start on Dale Carnegie’s book, How to Win Friends and Influence People. Robin Jensen, Castlemaine

Furthermore Prime Minister – don’t embarrass Australia by standing in the same photo as Putin. Graham Fetherstonhaugh, North Fitzroy

Re US measles outbreak. If you go with medieval medicine, you get medieval outcomes Nina Wellington Iser, Hawthorn

Cricket Were the field umpires asleep when ball tampering was occurring? Surely, the umpires must also bear some of the responsibility for the sandpaper saga. Martin Newington, Aspendale

Re the sandpapergate issue, I haven’t lost any respect for the Australian cricket team; women’s that is. In fact, I am still very proud of them. Jill Kennare, Henley Beach SA

We had sandpapergate, now we have sandpapergategate. David Priest, Cabarita

Finally When is the AFL going to introduce being able to handball a goal? Richard Sykes, Bell Park

The opinion newsletter i s a weekly wrap of views that will challenge, champion and inform your own. Sign up here .

You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

Remove items from your saved list to add more.

You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.

Prev Swipe Story Next

Related Stories

Australia & Pacific
Build #2612