Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

One Nation, Greens weigh in after some states reject medical guidance on puberty blockers

SBS News Australia •
November 17, 2026 • 02:49 AM
3
3 reads 0 reactions

The interim advice was released by Australia's independent medical council and has been welcomed by LGBTQI+ advocacy groups.

One Nation, Greens weigh in after some states reject medical guidance on puberty blockers

New advice from Australia's independent medical council recommending puberty blockers for teenage trans and gender diverse people, in limited cases, will be ignored in Queensland and the Northern Territory, and One Nation says it will not support the treatment nationally or if elected in Victoria.

Meanwhile the federal government, Opposition and greens all welcomed the advice.

The National Health and Medical Research Council (NHMRC) released interim advice on Monday that, as part of a shared decision between a young person, their parents or carers, and their doctors, puberty blockers can be considered if the young person has reached puberty and is assessed as suitable. The treatment is reversible.

Health Minister Mark Butler told Channel Nine on Tuesday that the public debate concerned a relatively small group of very vulnerable young people who are overrepresented in mental health and suicide statistics.

Your trusted source for staying up-to-date with the world around you. Get free daily news updates and analysis, straight to your inbox.

He argued that the issue should be referred to the Australian health and medical research body "rather than have debate settled by commentators in our big newspapers".

Butler also defended the research behind the guidelines, which found a low level of certainty for better mental health outcomes for trans and gender diverse teenagers who accessed puberty blockers.

"It's not unusual to have guidelines indicate a level of low certainty around evidence. More recently, I've seen that in pregnancy care guidelines, dementia care guidelines, arthritis, and even stroke management as well," Butler said.

Equality Australia welcomed the guidance on Monday, with CEO Anna Brown saying it "reinforces that the care trans young people are receiving in Australia today is grounded in evidence, informed by clinical expertise and guided by the individual needs of young people".

The Queensland and Northern Territory governments immediately rejected the NHMRC advice on Monday, insisting they will maintain their bans based on their own reviews of the evidence.

Queensland Health Minister Tim Nicholls said the state had already conducted its own independent review and that the NHMRC's advice won't change its decision.

The state introduced a ban on public hospitals prescribing any gender-affirming hormone treatments in January 2025, following research in the United Kingdom by paediatrician Hilary Cass.

The Cass review of youth gender identity services in the UK found the international and local evidence base supporting early puberty suppression for minors with gender dysphoria or gender incongruence is "remarkably weak" and lacked long-term data on clinical effectiveness or safety.

Butler said Queensland's own review didn't have the status, scope, or "purpose" of the council, and the UK review was influenced by "questionable private prescribing practices" that do not occur in Australia.

The biggest local gender clinic, in Melbourne, prescribed puberty blockers to an average of eight young people over eight years, with wait times for treatment averaging 530 days, Butler said.

Nicholls said the state's position "remains unchanged and we will continue to prioritise the health, safety and wellbeing of young Queenslanders".

Queensland's ban was briefly overturned by the Supreme Court last year , but Nicholls used ministerial powers to immediately reinstate it hours after the court's decision.

The NT government also said in a statement that its ban will remain in place.

A spokesperson for the Northern Territory government told Nine Newspapers that its decision is consistent with those of Queensland, the United Kingdom and Finland, "which have all taken a cautious approach".

Labor ordered the NHMRC review into the prescription of gender-affirming hormones for young people two days after the Queensland government's 2025 ban.

The new guidelines do not require a child to be diagnosed with gender dysphoria, which is psychological distress caused when someone's gender identity does not align with the sex they were assigned at birth.

Greens leader David Shoebridge told SBS News Australia should be taking the best advice from the best experts.

"This seems like a very credible policy that's been considered not by politicians who are trying to make a political point, but by the medical experts," Shoebridge said. "I think the more we listen to the medical and ethical experts, and the less we listen to the likes of the NT chief minister or the Queensland premier in this space, the more the country will be on the right track."

Liberal senator Andrew Bragg told Channel Nine on Tuesday the transgender community should not be used as a "political football".

"I think there are people in politics who've used them [as] part of their kind of hate campaign," Bragg said. "They are a tiny minority and we should be kind to one another. We've got to live and let live ethos in this country."

The senator said that decisions about gender-affirming treatment were, for the most part, "not judgements children should be making", but said there were rare circumstances in which accessing puberty blockers would be appropriate for a child's health.

A One Nation spokesperson said it would fight to ban the treatment if elected in Victoria or federally.

The federal Coalition noted the new advice deviates from the UK Cass review and does not require a gender dysphoria diagnosis.

The advice is open for public comment until 18 January, with clinical guidelines, beyond the use of puberty suppressants, developed "probably into 2028", Butler said.

Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 4 other independent news outlets reported on this story.

4 Publications
The Age
53m ago
‘A second opinion is common sense’: Wilson promises review of puberty blockers

‘A second opinion is common sense’: Wilson promises review of puberty blockers

A day after new guidelines were released for puberty blockers, the Victorian Coalition has promised to review their use in the public health system if it wins the state election.

#medical #puberty #blockers
Compare →
CNN International
4h ago
Forensic expert says Epstein was likely killed, but NYC medical examiner stands by suicide ruling | CNN

Forensic expert says Epstein was likely killed, but NYC medical examiner stands by suicide ruling | CNN

A forensics expert on Monday announced findings that he says points to Jeffrey Epstein having been killed while in custody, contradicting the New York City Office of Chief Medical Examiner’s ruling that the disgraced financier died by suicide.

#medical
Compare →
ABC News Australia
9h ago
Half of senior Qld doctors fear fatigue could contribute to errors, survey finds

Half of senior Qld doctors fear fatigue could contribute to errors, survey finds

A new survey shows half of senior doctors in Queensland are concerned fatigue could contribute to a clinical error, and almost a quarter anticipate quitting in the next two years.

#medical
Compare →
Sydney Morning Herald (SMH)
1d ago
Butler challenges states to allow puberty blockers

Butler challenges states to allow puberty blockers

Health Minister Mark Butler has challenged states and territories that have banned puberty blockers for children to comply with new national guidelines.

#puberty #blockers
Compare →

Related Stories

Australia & Pacific
Build #2612