Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

Australian cricket spent the week tearing itself apart and there is no end in sight

The Age •
November 17, 2026 • 12:40 AM
• By Will Macpherson
2
2 reads 0 reactions

Not so long ago, the warring sides in Australian cricket were intergenerational. Now the fighting is within the same changing room.

1 / 15
Swipe Photos

More than 100 months have passed since Cameron Bancroft smuggled sandpaper into his briefs, but at the end of this extraordinary and often unedifying week of blood-letting, an end does not seem in sight.

With two factions poles apart, consensus over who knew what in Cape Town, and the notion of a single version of events for the public to digest and accept, seems as unlikely as ever. The only certainty is that, even after his epic and authoritative press conference, Pat Cummins’s assertion that he had spoken about the matter publicly for the final time seems wishful in the extreme. Gerard Whateley, a respected sports broadcaster, has compared sandpaper to the JFK assassination. It will rumble on.

The Test captain’s press conference left those hunting for common ground between Camp Usman Khawaja and Camp Cummins clutching at thin air. Not so long ago, the warring sides in Australian cricket were intergenerational, after Cummins’s team effectively toppled Justin Langer as head coach, provoking the fury of the great group of 25 years ago, led by former batsmen Matthew Hayden and Ricky Ponting. Now the fighting is within the same changing room.

While Cummins spoke for 68 minutes, giving the media more access than they could ever have asked for, really the whole engagement boiled down to one one-word answer. He was asked if he was aware of any plot to tamper with the ball in South Africa at all.

By quickly answering “no”, there was no longer any hiding behind semantics or grey areas; not only was Cummins claiming not to know about the taking of sandpaper onto the field on that specific day in Cape Town, he was claiming not to know about any plans to tamper with a cricket ball on that tour of South Africa. He was refuting Khawaja’s testimony directly, all while delivering a personal drive-by, criticising how he had acted as a friend, and questioning why he had not spoken up himself, given he knew what Bancroft was planning. Khawaja had been at pains not to name individuals, but Cummins did make it personal, and operated in specifics. If it emerges that he is lying, there is no way back.

How on earth does anyone move forward from here? Cummins said he would not be going legal, despite receiving advice that some of the contents of the book were defamatory. That is not to say others will not.

For now, the ball is back in Khawaja’s court, and he will have the opportunity to return serve in the coming days, including in Hobart on Wednesday, when he is slated to commentate for Fox Sports, the Australian broadcaster, for the third ODI against England, alongside his friend David Warner and Alyssa Healy, Mitchell Starc’s wife. He is also due to appear on some podcasts, although at least one has been delayed until after Hobart. Khawaja has seemed less assured when receiving a grilling from journalists , such as the ABC’s veteran political reporter Sarah Ferguson than in the breezily-written 17th chapter of his autobiography Sabr where he alleged that “we all knew”.

So perhaps it is more likely that Warner, the childhood friend Khawaja was trying to protect, moves us forward. On Friday he accused Cummins of “throwing Khawaja under the bus” , betraying his fury. For the remainder of the day in Perth, he stalked around looking mournful and wronged, so it was little surprise that he stuck out a statement on Instagram on Saturday morning, suggesting that more was to come.

“As far as I am aware, CA [Cricket Australia] did not interview Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc or Nathan Lyon in their 2018 investigation,” the statement read. “If that’s correct, then how can CA push the idea that the bowlers didn’t know?

“It looks like they had decided who they wanted to blame from the very beginning [and] ran a shoddy investigation to serve the purpose and now they want to maintain the false narrative that the bowlers had no idea. That stinks of a cover-up.”

Cricket Australia have denied Warner’s allegations. “As we have stated previously, all players were given the opportunity to speak at the time of the initial investigation [into the ball-tampering saga] and have had the ability to come forward with new evidence in the eight years since,” a CA spokesman said.

“Subsequently, CA has respected every player and former players’ right to provide their own version of events.”

Khawaja’s version of events has been supported by Warner, plus back-up players on the tour Chadd Sayers and Jon Holland, who have no apparent axe to grind. Bancroft said five years ago that the bowlers knew. When he was briefly stopped by the TV cameras at an airport this week, he said he had nothing to say “at this time”, and flashed a knowing smile. Khawaja’s testimony has been refuted by Cummins, Starc, and various coaches from the tour. After his long press conference Cummins headed to the nets with Starc and Josh Hazlewood, with the trio seeming as simpatico as ever.

There are a number of others we are waiting to hear from, with whispers of what they think doing the rounds. Mitchell Marsh fell over himself not to engage in a car-crash press conference on Thursday, while his forgotten brother Shaun, Peter Handscomb and Tim Paine, who replaced Steve Smith as captain, have all kept their counsel, too.

In one way or another, all but Shaun Marsh are conflicted. Handscomb is still a domestic player tipped for the Test tour of India in the New Year as a spin specialist, Mitch Marsh is a friend to everyone and Australia’s white-ball captain, and Paine is a CA employee as coach of Australia A. The forgotten man of the whole saga is Steve Smith, the captain who turned a blind eye but copped his punishment. As so often, the intense and restless veteran is keeping a low profile in New York. He will be desperate not to revisit a difficult time.

Reading Khawaja’s account, it is hard to understand what Warner did wrong at all. But he bore the heaviest punishment for his part in sandpaper, so it is not surprising he felt wronged. If he is so certain he has been stitched up, surely he and his agent have some evidence from the time that they could make public?

That would at the least put pressure on Cricket Australia to publish their investigation in full from the time, which was completed by a head of integrity Iain Roy, who left the organisation soon after and has not commented since the episode has been reopened. Better would be interviewing all parties again and coming to a conclusion, which may or may not be the same as the previous one. Given the time has passed there does not need to be new punishments for those who knew – Khawaja would be one of them – but it would give some closure for an issue lacking it.

You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

Remove items from your saved list to add more.

You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.

Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 6 other independent news outlets reported on this story.

6 Publications
Sydney Morning Herald (SMH)
1h ago
Australian cricket spent the week tearing itself apart and there is no end in sight

Australian cricket spent the week tearing itself apart and there is no end in sight

Not so long ago, the warring sides in Australian cricket were intergenerational. Now the fighting is within the same changing room.

#cricket #spent #tearing
Compare →
ABC News Australia
3d ago
Australian cricket urged to stop 'eating itself' as Sandpapergate rolls on

Australian cricket urged to stop 'eating itself' as Sandpapergate rolls on

The ball-tampering scandal doesn't look like it's going away any time soon, with Greg Chappell fearing Australian cricket could "eat itself".

#cricket #itself
Compare →
The Guardian
21h ago
Gideon Haigh on how cricket can get out of this mess - podcast

Gideon Haigh on how cricket can get out of this mess - podcast

Journalist and author Gideon Haigh joins Reged Ahmad as we return to ‘sandpapergate’ and discuss whether an apology is in order

#cricket
Compare →
BBC News
3d ago
Pat Cummins: Australian cricket's sandpapergate is back, reopening wounds in a 'nation of good sports'

Pat Cummins: Australian cricket's sandpapergate is back, reopening wounds in a 'nation of good sports'

Claims the entire Australian team knew of the 2018 sandpaper cheating plot are dividing the cricket world.

#cricket
Compare →
The Australian Financial Review (AFR)
4d ago
Sandpapergate scapegoating is not cricket. It’s a way of life

Sandpapergate scapegoating is not cricket. It’s a way of life

According to Usman Khawaja, everyone was in on it. Surely, in Australia, we do not sweep a systemic problem under the carpet by pinning it on a few bad apples?

#cricket
Compare →
Al Jazeera English
14h ago
Which cricket teams can qualify for the LA 2028 Olympics and how?

Which cricket teams can qualify for the LA 2028 Olympics and how?

Six men's and six women's teams will compete for the medals in T20 format as cricket returns to the Olympics in 2028.

#cricket
Compare →

Related Stories

Sports
Australian teen rugby prospect arrested after nightclub brawl in France
Sydney Morning Herald (SMH) • 58m ago
Leave requests jump 29pc as Australians prepare for GTA VI
The Australian Financial Review (AFR) • 2h ago
Build #2612