Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

‘Good luck to police on this one’: What thieves could do with three stolen Melbourne Cups

The Age •
November 17, 2026 • 12:57 AM
• By Elias Visontay
2
2 reads 0 reactions

Experts say it would not take long for criminals looking to cash in on the theft to make the gold from the trophies “totally untraceable”.

1 / 5
Swipe Photos

Three historic Melbourne Cup trophies won by Makybe Diva are still missing more than a day after two thieves reportedly disguised as construction workers allegedly stole them from behind a display cabinet at Flemington Racecourse.

Now, experts say authorities’ chances of recovering the trophies intact is unlikely. But as attention shifts to the secondary gold market, criminals looking to cash in from the theft must navigate a tricky but achievable path to profit.

A Melbourne Cup weighs nearly two kilograms and takes more than 10 days to make. Each cup is valued at more than $1 million.

The trophies contain about 1.69 kilograms of 18-carat gold, which Adrian Dickens, founder of Melbourne’s Circa Ad Jewels, told this masthead would be worth about $233,000 each, for a combined total of $699,000. The $3 million combined estimate would be the value of the trophies if still intact, Dickens said.

How easy will the trophies be to sell?

Experts who have spoken to this masthead all broadly agree the thieves would be smartest to melt the gold down as opposed to attempting to sell them intact. This would avoid raising suspicion in the search for a trustworthy buyer interested in the trophies for their historical value - most likely a collector or a black market dealer.

Dickens, of Circa Ad Jewels, said it would only take about an hour to melt down the trophies, which would render the gold “totally untraceable”.

“If [the thieves] had any intelligence, they would have melted them down last night,” Dickens has said. “There would be a small amount of extra value [if the trophies were not melted] because they are Melbourne Cup trophies… but with the price of gold as it is, it would be far easier to get away with them being melted down.”

How hard is it to melt down a Melbourne Cup without arousing suspicion?

Very easy, according to Allan Trench, a professor of mineral and energy economics at the University of Western Australia’s business school.

“My first thought is good luck to police on this one,” he said.

Not only can a trophy be easily melted down in an hour, “you can literally melt it down in your backyard”.

“I’d be amazed if they (the thieves) hadn’t already lined up a furnace,” Trench said.

Where do they sell the melted-down gold? Are there checks and balances to detect criminals?

The thieves have a few options as to how they melt down the gold.

Trench said it would be easiest to pour the melted-down gold into a bar-style chunk. But anyone bringing in such a large chunk of gold to a refinery, trader or jeweller would likely arouse some suspicion, especially with an industry in Australia on alert after the thefts.

Precious metals fall under Australia’s anti-money laundering legislation. Traders buying or selling precious metal products - including the metals themselves as well as jewellery pieces - valued at $10,000 or more are legally obligated to report the transaction, according to regulator AUSTRAC.

“An overseas buyer wouldn’t be on the lookout for this,” Trench said. Transporting such an amount of gold outside of Australia would also be a logistical hurdle.

However, if the gold from the stolen trophies is melted down and poured into a vast number of smaller pieces, this would make criminal activity much more difficult to detect.

Can anyone just turn up at a gold trader or jeweller and trade in the gold?

In theory, smaller pieces could be taken to a range of smaller retail jewellers in the same way customers can trade in regular items containing gold, Trench said.

While anti-money laundering obligations cover transactions above $10,000, businesses buying gold are also required to try to detect and report “linked” transactions in the event two or more smaller transactions that exceed $10,000 appear related in nature.

However, a criminal with a scheme to melt the stolen gold into multiple smaller pieces and delegate the task of trading in the pieces across different individuals visiting various different traders and jewellers could avoid detection, experts said. Spacing such efforts out over time could also lower the risk of triggering suspicion.

The Business Briefing newsletter delivers major stories, exclusive coverage and expert opinion. Sign up to get it every weekday morning .

You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

Remove items from your saved list to add more.

You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.

Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 3 other independent news outlets reported on this story.

3 Publications
Sydney Morning Herald (SMH)
1h ago
‘Good luck to police on this one’: What thieves could do with three stolen Melbourne Cups

‘Good luck to police on this one’: What thieves could do with three stolen Melbourne Cups

Experts say it would not take long for criminals looking to cash in on the theft to make the gold from the trophies “totally untraceable”.

#melbourne-cups #luck #thieves
Compare →
ABC News Australia
21h ago
Breaking: Three Melbourne Cups won by Makybe Diva stolen from Flemington

Breaking: Three Melbourne Cups won by Makybe Diva stolen from Flemington

The Melbourne Cup trophies had been on display at the racecourse since September.

#stolen #melbourne #cups
Compare →
The Guardian
3h ago
Police raid fails to locate three stolen Melbourne Cup trophies worth $1m each

Police raid fails to locate three stolen Melbourne Cup trophies worth $1m each

Officers searched a Mount Waverley home in Melbourne after trophies belonging to winning horse Makybe Diva were stolen from Flemington racecourse

#stolen #melbourne
Compare →

Related Stories

Australia & Pacific
Build #2612