First published 17 Nov 2026, 9:10am
Scrapping the price disclosure reform intended to thwart underquoting is a lost chance for buyers.
Price transparency will likely fade from many marketing campaigns, as estate agents slip back to ‘price on inquiry’.
The NSW state government has failed buyers who’ll now continue to spend many hours and dollars on false hope endeavours.
The shelved reform was principally set to require an asking price, or price range, on all fresh ads starting Tuesday November 17.
MORE: Dubai flight hijack Aussie victims just paid out $75m
Scrapping the price disclosure reform intended to thwart underquoting is a lost chance for buyers.
At the eleventh hour on Monday, Premier Chris Minns scrapped its introduction , which the industry had been conscientiously working toward compliance with since June.
The major flaw I raised two weeks ago, and which proved fateful, was that agents could not advertise a price lower than any formal offer the seller had rejected or below the highest bid at a passed-in auction.
Even in an obviously falling market.
Some misinterpreted the legislation, believing agents could not lower the guidance even when conditions changed or when comparable sales data indicated the initial estimate was no longer reasonable.
Paul Mulligan was among the many buyer’s agents who forewarned that the flawed rule would cause an honest, professional agent and a desirous seller to be “stuck” after realising they made a mistake by not accepting the prior offer.
“What if the banks knock on the door? Or one needs to go into a nursing home. What if they get diagnosed with a terminal illness?,” Mulligan asked.
MORE: Nathan Cleary’s $5.5m move amid Fowler uncertainty
At the eleventh hour on Monday, Premier Chris Minns scrapped the laws introduction. Picture: Gaye Gerard/ NewsWire
In a deteriorating market, this was going to be an everyday handbrake for many vendors’ marketing, rather than an occasional circumstance.
Last week NSW Fair Trading advised a workaround, allowing ads to say: “previous written offer rejected at advertised price but seller open to offers outside price guide due to change in seller circumstance.”
One agent in Austral had already included that wording in their marketing.
The overly prescriptive edict copied the Victorian government’s rules, but NSW Premier Chris Minns is no socialist.
“It’s not the seller or the agent’s fault if the price of real estate is dropping,” Mr Minns said, overruling Anoulack Chanthivong, his besieged Minister for Fair Trading, who was facing an even bigger drop in stamp duty revenue should confidence in the market fade further.
“The legislation, at least intuitively, believed that prices would always rise,” Minns said.
MORE: Sneaky new tactic bosses use to underpay workers
The new wording has already started appearing on property marketing.
“A deteriorating real estate market may mean that you rejected an earlier offer, but in actual fact, you’ll take it a month later, particularly if it’s a distressed sale.”
A recent survey by Homer on underquoting laws in Victoria found that only 43 per cent actually sold within the initial price guide.
The reality is no one truly knows what properties will sell for as buying is an emotional decision, not one based alone on data.
Any rethink by Macquarie Street needs to ensure best practice regarding transparency on list prices, price adjustments, and enhanced real-time reporting of sold prices.
The balancing act requires consumer protection along with a free market for vendors.
Help us improve your reading experience
Got a minute? Your feedback will help us build a better experience for you.