Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

Review: This Italian restaurant in a $30,000 private club is open to all, but will everyone love it?

Sydney Morning Herald (SMH) •
November 16, 2026 • 06:00 PM
• By Myffy Rigby
3
3 reads 0 reactions

Sydney’s been hit with a new wave of flash Italian restaurants. Where does Spezia sit in the conversation?

1 / 15
Swipe Photos

Let’s start with a small amount of tedious, convoluted admin.

Spezia, the newest Italian restaurant to hit Gresham Street, isn’t part of boutique hotel Capella but it is Capella-adjacent. The luxury hotel may own the Federation-era Department of Lands building (now called The Lands by Capella and separate to Capella’s existing outpost in the Department of Education building) the restaurant is located in but the venue itself is owned by lifestyle company Florence Guild. That same company opened the members-only Sandstones Club earlier this year on the same site. So far, so confusing. But stay with me.

Membership to that club is a cool $30,000 – an annual fee that grants access to “the space leaders need”, according to its website. That includes a private cocktail bar, work zones, meeting rooms with (and I’m guessing here) many leather-bound books, and a wellness centre complete with a hyperbaric chamber. Rarefied air, truly.

But here’s the bit that everyone can digest: the 130-seat restaurant is open to the public. No special passes, no membership. If you can afford the bill, you can take the ride.

Restaurant reviews, news and the hottest openings served to your inbox.

The Moroccan tile-paved courtyard, dotted with pink Breccia Rosso marble-topped tables, was once private to the Department of Lands. Now open to the public, it feels a little like a hidden piazza in the middle of the Sydney CBD.

Start with a Spezia cocktail (gin and Campari shaken with lemon juice and egg white ’til it’s sharp, dry and fluffy) and a serve of pane soffiato (AKA everybody’s favourite fun-times puff-bread) crusted in a mix of salt and aniseed and oregano as a thinking snack.

Chefs Jae Bang and Aaron Caccia, who worked together for several years at three-Michelin-starred coastal Norwegian restaurant Re-naa, are behind the menu here. The carte, it says, traverses the Silk Road, with a solid foundation of Italian food. On paper that’s very exciting. On the plate it’s a little hit-and-miss.

Check out the chargrilled baby eggplant splayed over a puddle of stracciatella and herb oil, finished with a “soy crumble”, which translates as a sort of salty rubble of deep-fried then blitzed soybeans, garnished with fresh basil leaves. Plenty of ingredients but, strangely, not a lot of flavour.

And that’s a bit of a party line here, despite the name (Spezia is Italian for spice).

Medjool dates are stuffed with gorgonzola, dusted with sweet smoked paprika, drizzled with a little honey and balsamic. By all counts these should be gooey, oozy, hot and rich, with a sweet little dusty bite. But flavour-wise they’re a little two-dimensional.

Kingfish crudo is beautifully presented. The sashimi-grade raw fish is thatched with radish slices and finished with little pops of finger lime. Green Sichuan pepper is also listed as an ingredient but I can’t detect it, which is a bit disappointing. The floral, numbing spice would really light that dish up.

There are some real highlights. Fried honeycomb tripe is spongy on the inside, crisp on the outside; these little bites are best eaten as soon as they hit the table. (The longer you leave fried tripe cooling, the, um, tripier it gets. But straight out of the fryer? Delicious.)

The wine list, too, is impressive, with plenty of reasonably priced drops by the glass, along with a lengthy collection of primo wines poured via Coravin. And if you really want to go for it, the by-the-bottle list shines a light on cult areas such as Etna and Friuli-Venezia Giulia, and classic heavy hitters Chianti and Piedmont.

Pasta hits all the right notes and it’s here I can see a bit more of that promised refinement at play. Thick strands of eggy, Abruzzo-style spaghetti alla chitarra are napped in a rich and slightly piquant blue swimmer crab bisque, all topped with finely minced raw prawn. It really works.

A trio of sorbet and gelati is a beautiful palate cleanser, though service (every bit as stylish as it is relaxed about delivering dishes in a timely manner) is a little vague on the flavour details. Our waiter takes a swing at it, guessing strawberry and vanilla instead of the far more exciting reality of blood-orange sorbet, pistachio and fior di latte.

Mellow seems to be the name of the game here. I’m not sure if the restraint with spice and seasoning is deliberate but the kitchen could afford to turn the volume up a little on some of these dishes. Imagine the fun they might have if they let a little loose. Live by the spice, die by the spice, I say.

Atmosphere: Italian food for masters and mistresses of the universe

Go-to dishes: Fried tripe with Tasmanian mountain pepper ($17); prawn spaghetti chitarra with star anise and crab bisque ($48); spatchcock alla diavola ($48); trio of gelati ($14)

Drinks: A deep dive into cult wine producers with an impressive by-the-glass selection sits alongside a smart, summery cocktail list

Cost: About $150 for two, excluding drinks

Good Food reviews are booked anonymously and paid independently. A restaurant can’t pay for a review or inclusion in the Good Food Guide .

You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

Remove items from your saved list to add more.

You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.

Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 6 other independent news outlets reported on this story.

6 Publications
BBC News
6h ago
Friselle: The ingenious Italian bread that can last for a year

Friselle: The ingenious Italian bread that can last for a year

As governments urge households to stock up on emergency supplies, a traditional bread from southern Italy offers a centuries-old lesson in making food last.

#italian
Compare →
The Guardian
23h ago
Ronaldinho makes debut for Italian side Ravenna after 11-year hiatus in playing career

Ronaldinho makes debut for Italian side Ravenna after 11-year hiatus in playing career

The 46-year-old Brazil legend Ronaldinho played the first half for the Serie C club

#italian
Compare →
Al Jazeera English
4d ago
More than 1,800 Italian schools targeted by new hoax bomb alerts

More than 1,800 Italian schools targeted by new hoax bomb alerts

The latest warnings come amid rising concerns ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠in Europe about hybrid warfare threats.

#italian
Compare →
The Age
5d ago
We blindly picked an Italian town on a map and found paradise

We blindly picked an Italian town on a map and found paradise

It took a little town on Italy’s Adriatic coast to teach me how to be present. Not bad for a place I picked with my eyes closed.

#italian
Compare →
The Australian Financial Review (AFR)
5d ago
Australia news live updates: Anthropic IPO hugely oversubscribed, Italian schools evacuated

Australia news live updates: Anthropic IPO hugely oversubscribed, Italian schools evacuated

The $2.2 trillion Anthropic float is said to have attracted huge interest from investors; bomb threats continue across Europe, this time targeting schoolchildren. Follow live updates.

#italian
Compare →
ABC News Australia
3d ago
Victorian woman aims to grow 300,000 snails for restaurants

Victorian woman aims to grow 300,000 snails for restaurants

French expat Coralie Schaff aims to house 300,000 snails at her Otways property to supply restaurants.

#restaurant #000
Compare →

Related Stories

Australia & Pacific
Build #2612