Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

As an oncologist, I’ve received my fair share of thank you notes, but nothing like this | Ranjana Srivastava

The Guardian •
November 16, 2026 • 02:00 PM
4
4 reads 0 reactions

Every year I receive a letter from the daughter of a patient I treated. It’s an act of unbelievable grace in a job that often feels thankless

As an oncologist, I’ve received my fair share of thank you notes, but nothing like this | Ranjana Srivastava

Many years ago, in early November, I received a note.

It read: “Dear Doctor, Dad would have been 78 years old today. Of course, no amount of time would have been enough. We think of him and miss him every day.”

My patient’s daughter went on to write that by talking to her dad every day, she was keeping his memory alive – and partly, that meant connecting with the people who knew him. In the final few years of his life, this included me.

I was reminded of a man who had been a pleasure to know, right up to the visit that we both quietly understood to be his last . We had tried all kinds of treatments and trials, and his health was now steadily declining. I stressed the importance of good palliative care, but for the family, reeling in shock, it had felt like the “there is nothing we can do” speech.

Soon afterwards, he died peacefully, surrounded by his loving clan.

In 25 years of practice, I have received my fair share of thank you notes, but nothing like this, on the birthday of a deceased patient. Touched by the gesture, I showed it to my kids and filed it away.

The next November, I received another note.

“Dear Doctor, Dad would have been 79 today. We remain ever so grateful for your care.”

Well, you know where this is going. Many seasons have passed, but it’s November and, with it, another note.

“Dear Doctor, today we remember Dad and are reminded of your contribution to our lives.”

This annual gesture is the only communication from a daughter whom I have never seen again, save for the time shortly after her father’s death when she and her mother came with a gift. Unexpectedly unsettled by the waiting room that looked the same, minus their father and husband, they hurried out in tears, making me wish they had never come.

Between one November and the next, there is no request for a conversation, no demand for an explanation. She was close to her dad, so I imagine she has questions for me. Did I do my best? Have treatments advanced in the intervening years? Are other patients like her dad doing better? But there is nothing of the sort. And then, in November, this act of unbelievable grace that must surely pierce a tiny bubble of grief.

Oncologists are trained to help people navigate some of the most challenging times of life. When patients die, an essential consolation is believing that you gave them the best of your mind and manner. Indeed, this is an important aspect of sustaining the energy to care for other patients.

Sometimes, the job can seem thankless.

My midwife friend, driving home from a long day in the labour ward, rues that no woman will remember her. I joyfully refute this every time. Which woman doesn’t remember her midwife? I have lost track of mine but not their acts of kindness.

Perhaps this is one of the more humbling aspects of working in medicine: the extraordinary asymmetry of remembering.

Over the course of a career, we see thousands of patients. Not uncommonly, patients themselves will say, “I don’t expect you to remember me, you’re so busy”. We can care about all our patients and remember some more vividly than others – that’s just human nature. But for the patient sitting across from us, we might be their only doctor or midwife. Which means that an ordinary encounter late on a Wednesday afternoon may be a defining moment in a patient’s life. To meet this recognition not with hubris but with humility is the calling of good medicine.

We tend to think of our work in terms of what we do: the diagnoses we make, the treatments we prescribe, the decisions we get right. I remember how much I coveted these skills as a trainee.

So it has been a revelation of a lifetime to discover that patients and families remember something quite different. A reassuring word, a slow explanation, the feeling of being listened to, or simply the sense that someone cared enough to stay a little longer.

I wonder how often we underestimate the significance of these small encounters. We are inclined to think that the important work happens in the consulting room, in the operating theatre or on the labour ward. Yet the things people carry away with them may be much less tangible. My midwife friend cannot know that she may one day feature in the story a woman tells her grandchildren about the day their mother was born.

And so it should be. We cannot work with the expectation of being remembered, any more than we can demand gratitude from our patients.

But it’s worth remembering that we might be.

If you had asked me years ago, I would have assured you that although I missed my patient, my role was over. But for his daughter, it seems not. Every year, with one dignified note, she brings together the dad she misses with the oncologist who had the privilege of knowing him.

We never speak but all at once, she reminds me that the work of medicine is not always triumphant. It can also be quiet, its impact reverberating long after the encounter.

Sometimes, without knowing it, we become part of the memory that people are trying to keep alive.

This is one of the great privileges of medicine – but, as I now see, no less a responsibility.

Tags:
Prev Swipe Story Next

Related Stories

Health & Wellness
Build #2612