The Albanese government wants to push down gas prices by engineering a "modest oversupply" of gas but a proposed reservation scheme is deadlocked in the Senate due to disagreements over its design.
The proposed rules to force Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) exporters to pump more gas to Australians are problematic for the industry, the Coalition and the Greens said, for different reasons, including whether they encourage or discourage new supply.
The government needs the backing of either the Greens or the Coalition to pass the bill, as manufacturing unions urge the Senate to pass it before the end of the year.
The laws would create a Domestic Supply Obligation (DSO) to force big LNG exporters to reserve and supply up to 20 per cent of their annual export energy to Australians as calculated by the Australian Energy Regulator (AER), starting in 2028.
The AER will forecast domestic demand, add a 10 per cent market oversupply buffer, subtract non-exporter supply, and spread the remaining amount across LNG exporters.
Your trusted source for staying up-to-date with the world around you. Get free daily news updates and analysis, straight to your inbox.
Resources Minister Madeleine King said the policy will shield households, gas-powered electricity generators, and local manufacturers from international price spikes and domestic shortfalls.
For the law to be constitutional, it must apply to all states, but Australia has two disconnected gas markets. Western Australia's pipelines don't connect to the east coast because they don't run across the Great Sandy Desert and the Nullarbor Plain.
King acknowledged the issue and said the law allows DSO for the Western Australian market to be set at zero, or very low levels.
The Coalition and WA gas industry want a carve-out from the rules but Labor is only allowing adjustments through a ministerial decision. King argued that including WA helps make the scheme constitutionally robust.
Opposition leader Angus Taylor told reporters on Monday: "Our position is very clear that WA shouldn't be in it because they don't have the problem we have on the east coast".
"We do not need WA being part of this scheme," Taylor said. "WA says that. The WA premier says that, so sort it out. It's pretty simple."
Grattan Energy and Climate Change deputy program director Hamish McKenzie told SBS News that a WA parliamentary inquiry found exporters were "significantly under-delivering gas".
"The brutal reality is that the state gas reservation in WA is full of holes," McKenzie said.
"The federal scheme is much, much stronger, and if it was applied in WA, it would probably result in substantially more of West Australia's gas being kept onshore for West Australian users.
"Gas producers don't want that, and they are running a campaign to make sure that WA is exempt."
The minister's power to reduce or exclude gas companies' obligations from the scheme is controversial because one of the three east coast exporters — Gladstone LNG — has signed contracts to export much more gas than its planned production until at least 2036.
If a company's obligations under the new law require them to break an export contract and if they take "active steps" to try to deliver domestic gas, they may be excused.
"The minister of the day has a huge amount of discretion as to how they will implement the reservation," McKenzie said.
There aren't a lot of guardrails around the minister's ability to dictate supply and waive obligations, he said.
"The thing that should really be fixed is probably not the fine details of how it will be applied, but the circumstances in which the minister can actually use that discretion."
The minister can set an "oversupply" percentage, between 0 and 10 per cent of demand, which is the "biggest problem with the legislation", McKenzie said.
"Forcing 10 per cent more supply into the market than is demanded every year risks massively tanking the price, putting unviable pressure on domestic gas producers in a way that could, after a couple of years, leave the east coast gas market even more reliant on the exported sea gas supply, which is actually the opposite of what the reservation is trying to do," he said.
Taylor told reporters on Monday that to get prices down, you need more supply, and you won't have more supply if you trash the industry.
"So, they will push too much supply into the [Australian] market, but we need investment," Taylor said.
"We need to see a price that's going to get the investment, as well as the price to consumers, industrial and household, small business. That is achievable whilst we're still getting the investment."
Australia must produce more gas, not simply shuffle existing supplies around, Opposition resources spokesperson senator Susan McDonald said.
"Labor’s proposal in its current form will drive away investment, destroy domestic-only producers, discourage new production and ultimately leave Australians with less gas and higher prices.
The Greens won't support the bill unless it includes a 25 per cent tax on gas exports. Greens senator Steph Hodgins-May said the government should "do a deal for everyday Australians, not for gas donors", warning the new law may make it easier to open new gas fields and "make the climate crisis worse".
Independent senator David Pocock said Australia "needed a better return for its exports" and continues to push for a 25 per cent tax.
"I think it’s a good start, but I’m going to continue to push for a fair return for all Australians and for future generations of Australians on a resource that, once it’s sold, is gone," he told Channel Nine on Monday.
"We’ve got to get better at capturing long-term benefit from the sale of our resources."
King has rejected this, saying nothing gets cheaper after it's taxed.
"We have seen other countries where they do introduce what Senator Pocock has suggested, like a windfall tax, and what that has ended up doing is driving the industry basically away."