Topic: Fishing and Aquaculture Industry
Flyfisher Geoff Baker has memories of good fishing, but that has changed, he says. ( ABC News: Georgia Hogge )
A Tasmanian freshwater flow-through salmon hatchery will have enforceable limits placed on its effluent discharge for the first time, starting this month.
Data shows it could face challenges in meeting the EPA's new limits which the owner describes as "extremely low".
The EPA says it plans to further tighten regulation on effluent discharge into river systems, but a water quality scientist has questioned if it is acting fast enough.
Every time Geoff Baker returns to flyfish in the upper South Esk River, he thinks of his father.
"That was the main reason I came back here, because of those memories, knowing how good it was," he said.
It's near the source of the river as it winds its way through north-east Tasmania.
Geoff Baker says the waterway is devoid of life. ( ABC News: Georgia Hogge )
As well as trout, Mr Baker said he would regularly see platypus and other aquatic life, including different species of fish.
He said this has progressively been changing.
"In all other places, you find the aquatic water plants. You can't find one here. That tells you there's an issue straight away," Mr Baker said.
Upstream, the water flows past areas that have been cleared and logged.
The water is also used at a flow-through salmon hatchery called Millybrook, where juvenile salmon are grown before being moved into open water pens.
The water is filtered before being discharged back into the river.
Geoff Baker says he is ready to move on. ( ABC News: Georgia Hogge )
Mr Baker has questioned the Environment Protection Authority (EPA) extensively about the downstream effects, but the EPA and the hatchery's owner, Huon Aquaculture, say their monitoring has not detected water quality issues.
From this month, enforceable EPA limits on the concentration of nutrients in the water will come into effect for the first time.
Huon Aquaculture's Millybrook Hatchery, near Mathinna, in Tasmania's north. ( ABC News: Georgia Hogge )
Data obtained by the ABC shows how Millybrook's effluent discharge has been stacking up against the soon-to-be-imposed limits.
Up until August this year, it has been above the upcoming median limit for nitrogen discharge for 13 out of 15 months.
It was also just above the median limit for phosphorus for one month, before being on the limit for eight consecutive months.
Signage at Huon Aquaculture's Millybrook Hatchery. ( ABC News: Georgia Hogge )
Nutrient discharge peaks during periods of high stocking from January through to April.
During these months, the site regularly exceeded an upcoming investigation trigger, when it would be required to report to the EPA about the reasons for the figure, and ways of rectifying it.
At Tassal's Karanja hatchery in the state's south, failures to address repeated nutrient exceedances resulted in the EPA issuing four fines totalling $78,000 in 2024.
The EPA plans to further tighten the median limits for Millybrook, measuring them for six-month medians rather than 12 months.
A Huon Aquaculture spokesperson said the EPA limits being set for Millybrook are "extremely low", and it is investigating its stocking, equipment and infrastructure to meet the requirements.
Tasmania has 14 main freshwater hatcheries, of which four remain fully flow-through, like Millybrook.
Another nine are partially flow-through, and three are fully recirculating — including the state's largest, Huon Aquaculture's Whale Point nursery — which don't rely on river water flowing through.
The EPA has progressively been adding increased conditions and monitoring for these sites in a process it calls "continuous improvement".
Algae growth in the upper South Esk River in July this year. ( Supplied: Bob Brown Foundation )
The limits were set based on the natural occurrence of nutrients in the upstream river 80 per cent of the time, including for Millybrook.
EPA director of finfish compliance Darryl Cook said its approach was to gather years of monitoring data, assess upstream and downstream conditions, and then set limits.
"We also undertake biological monitoring, which really looks at the impact on the ecosystem downstream by comparing to the upstream ecosystem.
"We can also look at how much algae is growing in the environment; the amount of algae itself is not necessarily an indicator of harm, it's more about whether you're changing the function of the ecosystem by those invertebrates or bugs being changed."
Darryl Cook says increased regulatory measures are being introduced for flow-through hatcheries. ( ABC News: Cameron Atkins )
New methods of measuring algae are being developed.
The ABC assessed all available data for the state's freshwater hatcheries, which showed some had regular exceedances during peak periods, resulting in companies investigating the source of the issue.
Mountain Stream hatchery at Targa had exceeded its suspended solids limit in mid-2025.
The downstream environment received a 'B' rating, or 'significantly impaired'; the hatchery's owner was contacted for comment.
Several hatcheries, including Huon Aquaculture's Meadowbank on the Derwent River, have not had enforceable effluent quality discharge limits.
The EPA has confirmed it plans to introduce these in the next six months.
The Meadowbank Hatchery is located about 20 kilometres upstream from New Norfolk, in southern Tasmania. ( Facebook: Huon Aquaculture )
Instead, it has had a standing biomass limit and monitoring requirements.
The site sits upstream of the Bryn Estyn water treatment plant, which is Hobart's primary source of drinking water.
Mr Cook said Meadowbank has various filtration methods.
"We have had a freshwater improvement plan in place with the company over a period of time, and there's monitoring going on all of the time so we're able to keep a watch on that," he said.
A Huon Aquaculture spokesperson said it welcomes the setting of "appropriate limits" for Meadowbank.
The EPA was given the power to regulate freshwater hatcheries in 2017. Prior to this, their effluent discharge had much less regulation.
They continue to pay just under $500 per year for access to the river water, provided the same volumes are returned to the river.
Scientist Christine Coughanowr believes further studies are needed into the scheme's potential impacts on environmental flows. ( ABC News: Emily Smith )
Tasmanian Independent Science Council chair Christine Coughanowr said the limits being set appeared to allow the operators to continue operating at their current limits.
She said she had concerns about the levels of effluent discharge allowed during peak periods, particularly as companies pay less than $500 per year to access the water.
"The production peaks in the summer … that's when you get your highest discharge of these bioavailable compounds.
"And that's the time of year when rivers are most vulnerable to overproduction of algae downstream because the river flows are usually quite low and water temperatures are high and the days are long."
She wanted to see conversion to recirculating aquaculture systems (RAS) happening much quicker.
Mr Cook said companies were increasingly looking to do this.
"If they don't have a RAS, they're just a flow-through farm; they're at the mercy of the next great drought, or climate change increasing the water temperature and reducing the water flows.
"Companies want to have better control over the processes for growing their fish."