Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

Paine the peacemaker: Ex-skipper looms as key figure in Sandpapergate talks

Sydney Morning Herald (SMH) •
November 22, 2026 • 08:40 AM
• By Daniel Brettig
2
2 reads 0 reactions

The former Test skipper, thrust into the captaincy by Steve Smith’s ban, remains a respected figure on all sides of the debate.

1 / 5
Swipe Photos

Former Test captain Tim Paine has emerged as a key figure in any possible peace talks between warring members of the 2018 South African tour party who became embroiled in the Sandpapergate scandal.

As Cricket Australia works to finalise terms of reference for its truth forum, in which players and staff from the scandal eight years ago will be asked to share their honest recollections, a parallel line of private conversations are taking place.

While the positions of Usman Khawaja , David Warner, Chadd Sayers and Cameron Bancroft have been made publicly clear about collective knowledge, and therefore a need for collective responsibility, current captain Pat Cummins and fellow bowlers Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Starc have also made their differing views plain.

Nathan Lyon has not spoken publicly, meanwhile, but was a signatory to the 2021 statement denying any knowledge of sandpaper being taken onto the field.

According to a source with knowledge of discussions, Paine, thrust into the captaincy by Steve Smith’s ban , remains a respected figure on all sides of the debate, in particular for how his leadership was shown in picking up the pieces from Newlands and the remainder of the tour in 2018.

Importantly, Paine was the first player to publicly argue that the team should have taken collective responsibility in 2018, rather than allowing the full weight of CA’s penalties fall upon Smith, Warner and Bancroft.

Paine is the coach of the Adelaide Strikers in the Big Bash League and has also held numerous coaching roles for CA in recent times. He resigned as Test captain in 2021 after a sexting scandal.

He declined to comment when contacted by this masthead, but his 2022 autobiography, The Price Paid , makes things clear.

“I have wondered if there was a point where we could have said something or done something differently,” Paine wrote, in a chapter on the saga that otherwise sticks closely to CA’s official version of events.

“Everyone was a part of it to some degree – would it have worked out better for those three players if we had owned it as a team? I think it would have.”

All-rounder and now white-ball captain Mitchell Marsh is held in similar regard by both sides of the argument, and his vexxed position has been made plain by a haunted visage in recent days, when he was also kept away from media duties after being persistently asked about the affair in his pre-series press conference in Perth.

“I respect Uzzy for telling his story and for writing his book, and I don’t sit here coming from a place of judgement,” Marsh had said. “Everyone’s got their story. Some will be willing to share it, and others might not, purely on the basis of the fact that they’ve moved on. It’s really important that at some stage we do.”

Players Association boss Paul Marsh advocated in this masthead for collective responsibility to be taken by all players and staff from the 2018 tour, in addition to CA for leading the team in a win at all costs direction in the preceding few years.

“They are a team, and you win, you lose as a team,” Marsh said. “I just think it’s something that maybe we need to be able to do collectively, so that, so everyone can find a way to move on here.”

Those words found a sympathetic ear across much of the cricket community over the weekend, although some senior figures conceded, there is a significant amount of “scar tissue” that needs to heal before all players could be expected to get together and talk through matters.

Captain Cummins was grateful to be supported both in private and in public by CA chief executive Todd Greenberg and chair David Boon, although he is still facing some harsh critiques, including by the respected former England captain Mike Brearley.

“It is hard to see Cummins remaining as captain for long, even if Cricket Australia is so far backing him,” Brearley wrote in The Times . “He has so much the bearing and look of a heroic and honourable leader, clean-cut, handsome, with the image of an outback hero.

“He has been a wonderfully consistent, top-level Test cricketer, and as captain has much modified the team’s bad reputation. But the cover-up, if it is so, has been worse for him than any crime or misdemeanour. Perhaps he should bow out with as much grace as he can find.”

Greenberg and Boon have made it clear CA are in no mood to move Cummins on, but are aware he will need plenty of support in coming days and months.

“I think he’s going need some help in that, and I think he’s going to need some other leaders to step up, and we’re gonna need to take the temperature down a little bit,” Greenberg told SEN radio on Saturday. “I think this has got very messy and very emotional very quickly, and it’s clearly it’s an emotional issue for a lot of people.

“I think in a lot of ways, that’s the standing of the Australian cricket team, we’re the nation’s national sporting team, and it’s cared about deeply. So when these things come up, we have to remind ourselves that emotional energy that comes with it can be good and bad.”

You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

Remove items from your saved list to add more.

You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.

Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 6 other independent news outlets reported on this story.

6 Publications
The Age
1h ago
Paine the peacemaker: Ex-skipper looms as key figure in Sandpapergate talks

Paine the peacemaker: Ex-skipper looms as key figure in Sandpapergate talks

The former Test skipper, thrust into the captaincy by Steve Smith’s ban, remains a respected figure on all sides of the debate.

#paine #sandpapergate #peacemaker
Compare →
ABC News Australia
1d ago
Trying to get your head around Sandpapergate? We're here to help

Trying to get your head around Sandpapergate? We're here to help

Here's a quick guide to the Sandpapergate drama — absolutely zero knowledge of cricket rules needed.

#sandpapergate
Compare →
BBC News
2d ago
'The truth has to come out' - Broad on Lehmann after Sandpapergate

'The truth has to come out' - Broad on Lehmann after Sandpapergate

'The truth has to come out' Broad on Lehmann after Sandpapergate

#sandpapergate
Compare →
SBS News Australia
3d ago
Why Sandpapergate is the 'perfect recipe' for scandal

Why Sandpapergate is the 'perfect recipe' for scandal

What makes a scandal and why Sandpapergate was bound to come back into global conversations.

#sandpapergate
Compare →
The Australian Financial Review (AFR)
4d ago
Bancroft writes explosive column on Sandpapergate scandal

Bancroft writes explosive column on Sandpapergate scandal

Cameron Bancroft has hit out at cricket captain Pat Cummins over the Sandpapergate scandal that has rocked Australian cricket, deepening fissures in the team.

#sandpapergate
Compare →
Hamro Patro News
1w ago
Stench of 'Sandpapergate' set to linger as scandal reignites

Stench of 'Sandpapergate' set to linger as scandal reignites

SYDNEY, Nov 14: Australian captain Pat Cummins wants to draw a line under "Sandpapergate" and move on, but the stench of the 2018 ball-tampering scandal is set to linger after a week of sensational...

#sandpapergate
Compare →

Related Stories

Sports
Build #2612