The Saturday Night Live sketch " Sister " went viral this week for its satirical take on the family dynamics surrounding elder care. I can't be the only one who watched with a bit of discomfort.
In the sketch, comic John Mulaney pitches men a free, 24/7 system for taking care of aging parents: your sister. "Now I don't have to worry about Dad getting the care and attention he needs, because my sister will do it and I can get back to my life and the stuff I like to do."
It's funny because it's true. Study after study shows that daughters are more likely than sons to become caregivers to aging parents and tend to spend far more time on caregiving responsibilities — often to the detriment of their careers .
This is where I tell you that my parents are doing great. They're spending their retirement golfing and traveling, and they just downsized into a house that will make aging in place easier.
But that sketch revealed an uncomfortable truth: If something were to happen, and one or both of them needed one of us kids to help with care, I maybe kinda assumed my sister would take the lead.
On paper it makes sense! She still lives close by; I moved away. She owns a house with multiple bedrooms; I rent a one-bedroom apartment. She's a former estate attorney, experienced with handling matters of inheritance and the legal ins and outs of end-of-life planning; I'm… not.
But this isn't going to happen on paper. It's real life, and what SNL does a great job satirizing is that, absent real communication , someone can get defaulted into a role that they don't really want.
"I love my mom more than anything. That doesn't mean I want to help her in the bathroom," SNL cast member Andrew Dismukes says to camera. "'Sister' doesn't either, but she will, whereas I won't."
So I sent the sketch to my sister, and then I called her. When she picked up the phone we both said, "Not it!" Just kidding.
But it became clear that we both felt the same way about sacrificing both personally and potentially financially to care for our parents: We hope it doesn't come to that. If it did, both of us are confident we could provide excellent care for them. But neither of us is, like, champing at the bit.
It also became obvious that neither of us really knew what our parents wanted. Would they want to live with one of us? Would they prefer a professional nurse or home health aide provide care? We had no idea.
My sister knows the rough terms of their will, but wasn't sure if they had a long-term care policy . We'd both picked up some ideas about how our parents would or wouldn't want to live in old age, but neither of us had had a serious conversation with them about it — not only about their wishes, but about their estate.
To the latter point, one situation described in the sketch is all too common, my sister told me, putting on her lawyer hat. As SNL cast member Kenan Thompson says in the sketch as he reclines in resort wear, "Since your parents' will predates their dementia, using 'Sister' won't change your inheritance. You'll still get 50% of the house she's currently deep cleaning."
I asked my sister if people tend to change their estate planning to account for a child who is putting in labor and making other sacrifices to provide care.
"If they're thoughtful about it and capable of doing it at or before the time they need care," she told me. Some families may gift the caregiving child money during their lifetime or leave more to them in the will, she said. "I've also seen people who, if the child moves in with them, they give that child the house."
As far as I'm concerned, that's all on the table. And we need to keep discussing this with each other — and with our parents.
My sister and I are smart to be wading into these conversations now, when everyone is happy, healthy and independent, says Megan McCoy, a financial therapist and professor at Kansas State University.
"Having those conversations early on, before anyone gets sick, is the greatest gift a family can have," she told me.
Because conversations around money, mortality and inheritance are always going to be tricky, McCoy suggests starting small. "You're not trying to tackle everything at once. You're just trying to get the conversation broached," she says. "Maybe you start with asking them about their experience caregiving for their parents. Or ask them to look back and think about what they're most proud of. Then you slowly edge into specifics."
The goal, she says, is transparency. Maybe your parents are adamant that they'd prefer a professional caregiver to a family member. In that case, you might want to explore if they've set aside money for that possibility, or if that's something you and your generation need to help with financially.
When it comes to your siblings, conversations can revolve around divisions of labor, and it may turn out that you're able to share caregiving responsibilities equally. In the cases where one person has to be more hands on, McCoy says it's important to acknowledge that caregiving can be both financially and emotionally taxing — and being there to help with one or the other can make things feel less burdensome and avoid the kind of unspoken resentments SNL is poking fun at. If one sibling is contributing more money, she suggests, the other might be willing to be a sounding board for the parents or to delve deeper into research around prescriptions.
"It's about breaking down all the different ways we support people and saying, 'How can we parse this out to take a little bit off your shoulders?'"
Overall, do your best to have short conversations around these topics early and often. Think of it as getting "reps" in, McCoy says. Doing so can take some pressure off of everyone and help you process these decisions more organically, she says.
"Don't put any anticipation of this great emotional breakthrough on Conversation 1," she says. "It probably won't happen until Conversation 60."
CNBC Select is editorially independent and may earn a commission from affiliate partners on links.