Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

Nervous about having honest family conversations over the holidays? You can 'be more forthcoming than you think,’ says psychologist

CNBC World •
November 20, 2026 • 05:00 PM
• By Vanessa Bohns, Contributor
3
3 reads 0 reactions

Social psychologist Vanessa Bohns explains how to share good news, open up about setbacks and ask personal questions with more care during the holidays.

Nervous about having honest family conversations over the holidays? You can 'be more forthcoming than you think,’ says psychologist

You've had a great year. Or you've had a terrible one. Either way, you're getting together with friends and family over the holidays.

You might be wondering how open you should be about your successes and setbacks — and how much should you ask about theirs?

As a social psychologist, I've long been interested in why it can be so hard to figure out what to share and what to keep to ourselves. That question led me to write " Should I Say Something? " a research-backed guide to help people make those decisions.

When it comes to holiday conversations, research suggests you can probably be more forthcoming than you think, with some caveats.

If you worry that you'll hurt someone's feelings, provoke envy or sound like you're bragging, that could lead you to downplay or hide your successes.

But sharing good news can make you feel even better about what happened and bring you closer to the people you tell. Having people who are there for you when things go right is an important form of social support .

Our successes can also give people close to us something to feel proud of. When you share your good news, your relatives get to brag about what their cousin or niece is doing. Researchers call this " basking in reflected glory ."

Of course, some people may feel a little envious. But that's not always a bad thing . Envy can sometimes take the form of admiration. It can even inspire friends and family to follow your lead rather than resent you.

Some people will have mixed feelings about your good news. That's okay. People can be simultaneously proud of you and feel a little envious, or even resentful, especially if you've achieved something they've wanted for themselves that feels out of reach.

But that's not a reason to hide or downplay your success. If they hear the news later, they may feel hurt that you didn't tell them. And trying too hard to sound humble can come across as disingenuous . So share your good news with care, and give people room to feel however they feel.

It can be embarrassing to say you were rejected by every graduate program you applied to, got laid off or are going through a separation. How will that conversation go? What will people think?

Research finds people often respond better than we expect. In one study , people who shared fears and insecurities were liked more than they expected. They even made a better impression than people who shared neutral or positive information about themselves.

When we're deciding whether to open up about our insecurities, we tend to focus on the thing we're embarrassed about. But the person we choose to share with also learns that we are honest and trust them enough to share — qualities people really like.

Does that mean you should dominate Thanksgiving dinner with your sad stories? Of course not. No one wants to be a Debbie Downer at the dinner table.

In research on couples who successfully talked through disagreements, psychologist John Gottman and his colleagues identified a " magic ratio " of about five positive interactions for every negative one.

I recommend borrowing that idea for Thanksgiving. Once you've bravely opened up about how you got fired, give the conversation a few lighter turns before you tell everyone how your apartment got broken into.

If your cousin says they've had a rough year, you may be inclined to say you're sorry to hear that and leave it there. Why not ask, "What's been going on?" Research finds that people who ask more follow-up questions are better liked.

We tend to assume it's safer to talk about lawn care and the weather than to ask about family relationships or finances. But research shows that asking sensitive questions is less awkward than we expect, and that asking personal questions can lead to conversations that bring us closer .

Before you ask a personal question, though, be honest with yourself about why you want to ask. Are you asking out of a genuine desire to connect, or to satisfy your own curiosity?

In other words, do you really want to understand what's been going on in your cousin's life, or do you just want to know how much money they make?

The same goes for questions about someone's appearance. If the first thing you notice is that your uncle's weight has changed since the last time you saw him, it's better to keep that observation to yourself and ask about him rather than his weight.

Over the holidays, you may find yourself hesitating to bring something up with your loved ones. But remember that they are probably more willing than you think to celebrate with you, support you through a hard time and tell you how they're really doing.

Vanessa Bohns is a social psychologist and the author of " Should I Say Something? The S cience of W hat to S hare—and W hat to K eep to Y ourself ." Bohns is the Braunstein Family Professor and Chair of Organizational Behavior at Cornell University's ILR School. She holds a Ph.D. in psychology from Columbia University and a bachelor's degree from Brown University.

CNBC Select is editorially independent and may earn a commission from affiliate partners on links.

Prev Swipe Story Next

Related Stories

World News
Build #2612