I realise it’s only the most annoying people on Earth who say this sort of thing, but I’m going to bravely say it anyway: I am an empath. I have always felt in tune with other people’s emotions and can easily take them on. The emotion I am most intensely attuned to, the one that takes the strongest hold of my body when I see someone going through it? Embarrassment.
There is nothing I hate more than seeing a person embarrassed, even if it’s a person I don’t like. I have always been like this. I remember sitting in the cinema watching There’s Something About Mary, all of my friends dying over a scene where Ben Stiller gets his testicular skin stuck in his zipper in front of his crush. They were rolling in their seats while my insides were rolling around. I felt physically ill. I knew logically it was a funny scene, that a normal person would laugh at the plight of this poor boy and his ball skin, but my humour bone was being crushed in a vice grip, as it always is when embarrassment abounds.
I presume the reason I find cringe comedy like that so hard to stomach is because embarrassment is the emotion I hate feeling the most. I guess people find something fascinating about watching someone else make a fool of themselves, provided they’re protected from their own failures by a screen. I do think a lot of why I can’t find it funny comes from being fat and experiencing so many public humiliations myself just for existing. Especially when I was younger, I often had attention drawn to me in cruel ways, and consequently felt painfully embarrassed nearly all the time.
So even as cringe comedy became popular in my youth, I couldn’t really enjoy it. I couldn’t find American Pie very funny, I certainly can’t do any of the various exercises in secondhand humiliation known as the Focker family films (sorry to Ariana Grande but I won’t be seeing your new big role), and was always turned off by Sacha Baron Cohen’s Borat and all the rest for not only embarrassing people, but for laughing at those not in on the joke. My stomach capsizes when people are made to feel stupid. Those examples don’t make it seem as though I’ve really been missing out on much, and usually it’s not that difficult to avoid. Until the last few years, as one name has come to rest on everyone’s lips: Nathan Fielder .
As a comedy fan who loves unique and smart work, it has been very difficult for me (you may understand this if you’re an empath) to avert my eyes while Nathan Fielder continues to make things. I know his brain is up my alley. He is so interesting and the situations he creates are special. I should love it. Except, I can’t watch it. I understand the scope of what he’s doing, I understand how deeply funny a lot of it is, but it also involves a lot of people not being in on what is happening, and a lot of awkward moments. This is not an insult at all – what he does is very driven by intention and curiosity. I love that it exists, and I’m jealous that other people can indulge without wanting to tear their own skin off.
I’ve managed to survive not being able to fully watch his previous works such as Nathan For You and The Rehearsal, but I have come to the conclusion I am going to have to see You Can See Everything. I love cinema, I love indulging in movie talk and podcasts and Oscar campaigns; I simply cannot avoid it. The movie is everywhere. I mean everywhere . It’s lucky I live in Australia, which has provided me with rigorous training in spoiler-avoiding, as all the movies I am interested in aren’t released here until a few months after everywhere else. My eye-flitting muscles are strong. But I can’t rely on these skills for much longer.
I can’t override my beautiful ginormous empathy for much, but for this movie I am going to have to shut it down for a few hours. I simply have to see it, I have to … see everything. I don’t know how it’s going to make me feel; I assume bad. But I will take the psychic damage, and the risk I’ll vomit into my popcorn bucket mid-screening – I’ll do it for the culture. I need to get involved in the conversation so I can know what other people are thinking and feeling, and so I can tell them all my important opinions – because I’m an empath.
Rebecca Shaw is a writer based in Sydney