To submit a letter to The Age , email [email protected] . Please include your home address and telephone number. No attachments, please include your letter in the body of the email. See here for our rules and tips on getting your letter published.
Cricket Australia must be held accountable for its handling of sandpapergate. There are serious questions about whether players have been pressured to toe the official line rather than speak openly about what happened. What began as a scandal over cheating on the field has now become a much bigger question of transparency, integrity and accountability. In many respects, the cover-up has become more damaging than the original offence. Cricket Australia owes the public and its supporters some honest answers, and a secret forum won’t solve anything Linelle Gibson, Williamstown
Heed Orwell on erasure of the truth Those involved in this sandpapergate saga should heed George Orwell’s warning, ″The past was erased, the erasure was forgotten, the lie became the truth.″ Henry Herzog, St Kilda East
Little imagination needed Applying sandpaper on varnished red leather does not require much imagination of what it might subsequently look like. Roughed up and unvarnished, unlike the investigation into this balls-up. Patrick Alilovic, Pascoe Vale South
From sandpaper to scapegoat Well, Cricket Australia, looks like sandpapergate might be morphing into scapegoatgate. Ron Stone, Kangaroo Flat
Bringing the shine back requires true grit The halo over the Australian 2018 cricket team is a bit tarnished at the moment. Maybe the bowlers and team manager could help bring back the shine by standing up and rubbing it with the gritty truth. It might be tough but I’m sure they could do it. Paul Chivers, Box Hill North
A forum will resolve nothing So now we have a ″forum″ for disillusioned and disgruntled former players to tell their stories and vent their anger. What a smart move by Cricket Australia. It won’t provide a solution or fix the problem, but hey, let’s keep it in a forum away from the press, so we can all continue to turn a blind eye, and pretend it doesn’t exist. Benedict Luiz, Mt Waverley
Some perspective, please Good God! Everybody take a deep breath. There’s genocide being conducted in Gaza and a lot of you are bent out of shape over a piece of sandpaper. Get over it. John Cain, McCrae
How many gates can there be? What a classic ″sandpapergategate″. Will Cricket Australia’s forum become SandpaperGateGateGate? Peter O’Brien, Newport
Open the gate to find a ‘libfix’ Gate, gate, gate, nothing but gate ... So, after reading The Age letters this week, I asked AI why ″gate″ is tacked onto any political or sporting cover-up or scandal? The answer I received fired up my linguistic curiosity. According to AI, your correspondent (Letters, 19/11) is correct to mention the 1972 Watergate break-in as AI considers it the start of adding ″gate″ to the end of a scandal. Explaining why it stuck, AI provided three main reasons: instant context, media catchiness and easy to adapt. Interesting to learn is that adding part of a word to another, unlike prefixes or suffixes, is called ″libfix″, which is short for liberated affix, a term coined by American linguist Arnold Zwicky in 2010. If rabbit holes are not an issue, there are many libfixs such as -core, -maxxing, -zilla, -cation, -holic to entice the linguistically curious who also read The Age. Judith Hudson, Elwood
Don’t regret your vote Voters should seriously consider their choices this election. They should vote on local issues not federal ones and consider the suitability of the parties and which one/ones are experienced and best to govern our state. Preferences are also a consideration; you do not have to just endorse the party line. On a recent trip to Britain I was reminded of the Brexit referendum. Britons were unhappy about issues, particularly migration and refugees. They felt their jobs and homes were being taken. Many now regret this decision, they say things have not improved, they are worse off; in fact it would be better to rejoin the EU. Many voted for Brexit just to register a protest, to show the government how unhappy they were, not believing that it would actually happen. In Australia we must learn from that lesson. It is not a time to vote for a party to register a “protest” vote. It is a time to consider who is best to govern and see Victoria through the next four years. Who has experience, who has the policies (costed). Who will take us forward not backward. We do not want to be in a position where we regret a decision made, possibly in haste, because we were angry at the time. Rhonda Ward, Mont Albert
Labor’s track record Your correspondent (Letters, 19/11) in panning Ben Carroll for being a member of the Labor government for 11 years and eight months before becoming leader over the past four months seems to have overlooked the fact that Labor won a hat-trick of elections, the last two by landslides. This would suggest the government of which Carroll was a prominent minister must have done a lot right over that period. Phil Alexander, Eltham
Cheaper energy needed Jess Wilson has promised to maintain Labor’s net zero goals, but also to scrap the policy of no new gas connections to households. This doesn’t make sense when the road to electrification is well underway. Cheaper and cleaner energy is urgently needed. The challenge for a new government will be how to achieve this fairly and justly, especially for rural communities. Judy Williams, Beaumaris
Can’t please everyone My electorate (both federal and state) is rusted-on Liberal, but Labor has given my suburb a new railway station and removed a rail crossing that had caused long wait times with traffic backed up on both sides of the railway line. None of our parties can please us all. Be careful what you wish for. Wendy Baker, Lilydale
Poor form, PM Anthony Albanese told the COP31 Leaders’ Summit that his government had sought the role of president of negotiations because ″we wanted to speak for the people of the world who need urgent action″ on climate, including those from ″our Pacific family″. Our Pacific family must be very grateful that the Albanese government has taken on the role of their climate saviour as it continues to approve the expansion of the fossil fuel industry, and maintains its climate-wrecking role as the world’s second largest exporter of coal. Albanese made no mention of fossil fuels in his speech. What a condescending, hypocritical performance. Angela Smith, Clifton Hill
It’s the same coin Your correspondent (Letters, 19/11) hits the nail on the head. Treating the cost of living and climate action as separate issues ignores a basic truth: economy and ecology are two sides of the same coin. Voters worried about grocery bills, insurance premiums, and damaged roads are already paying the price of extreme weather. Jess Wilson’s “opening the doors to gas”, and scrapping or delaying decisions on critical renewable energy infrastructure may be considered politically expedient – yet climate policy is surely a pay now or pay more later proposition. Are we happy to delay securing a safer, cheaper energy mix? Karen Campbell, Geelong
Cruel policy On Wednesday morning, I was talking to someone who fled persecution and hardship in Vietnam 48 years ago. He made a perilous boat journey with others, experiencing a terrifying boarding by pirates before making landfall in Malaysia. While in a camp there, immigration officials from Australia, the US, Canada and Switzerland visited and made offers of resettlement to the refugees. My new friend chose Australia, a decision he says was the best he has ever made. Over the 48 years, he has worked hard in many jobs and has been a volunteer in his retirement. Later on Wednesday, I learnt that One Nation would reduce Australia’s annual humanitarian intake by 90 per cent to a paltry 2000 people. Compared with the Fraser government’s enlightened and compassionate refugee policies of almost 50 years ago, One Nation’s proposal would see so many people who are suffering discrimination, persecution and hardship not being given the chance to rebuild their lives and make great contributions to our society. One Nation’s continued demonisation of migrants, refugees, Indigenous Australians and minorities is hateful, divisive and against Australia’s interests in so many regards. Andrew Trembath, Blackburn
Convention protections Pauline Hanson should note that the UN Refugee Convention came into effect in 1951 and was ratified by the Menzies Government in 1954. Under the Convention, a refugee is someone outside their country of nationality (or former habitual residence) who cannot or will not return due to a well-founded fear of persecution. Robin Rothfield, Brighton East
It is not love Pauline Hanson spitefully describes One Nation’s proposed reduction in Australia’s annual refugee intake from 20,000 to 2000 people as ″tough love″. It is sheer cruelty. Dorothy Scott, Macclesfield
An each-way bet Ross Gittins ( Comment , 18/11) is justified in being irritated by Anthony Albanese’s record of having an each-way bet on climate change issues. Here is another recent example. A few weeks ago, Albanese warned of a climatically dangerous forthcoming Australian summer and said: “We cannot let 1.5 degrees slip from our grasp.” But he failed to make any comment on the fact that the NSW Independent Planning Commission had just approved the biggest coal mine expansion in the history of that state. The IPC had approved a Glencore-Yancoal plan to expand the Hunter Valley operation until 2045. This would result in the release of 800 million tonnes of greenhouse gas emissions over the life of the project. But after his warning Albanese’s silence was deafening. Ian Bayly, Upwey
Fallen out of love I developed a real love of horse racing as a working class kid. Loved the punt at the local TAB years before I was 18. Loved the race callers, trying to work out a system, looking for trends, following hot jockeys and trainers, the thunder of the galloping down the straight mixed with the excited roar of the crowd. All of it. The last bet I placed was March 23, 2024. The horse was Tintookie. The result was a sad and painful death behind a plastic green sheet trackside after a catastrophic leg injury. Never again. Simon Williamson, West Footscray
Crime and punishment I thought it would be a no-brainer as to which crime was the more severe: placing a few (losing) bets on some football games, or partaking of illicit drugs then getting behind the wheel of an automobile. But I was wrong. It seems betting is twice the crime compared to drug-driving. Greg Brown, Tarneit
Run out of puff It is indeed remarkable that Victoria has met every renewable energy target so far, with clean energy now supplying 44.6 per cent of our electricity (Letters, 18/11). As a result, Victoria’s default electricity offers are now 14 per cent cheaper than they were in 2019. That’s a cost-of-living win worth protecting, whoever governs. Yet Labor has barely mentioned it this campaign, while the Opposition is promising more expensive, polluting gas. One side won’t talk about our biggest energy success; the other wants to undo it. Sarah Hegarty, Hawthorn East
The ball in space Modifying the surface of a leather cricket ball seems a far worse problem that doing something similar to the atmosphere. Yet while COP31 is charged with ameliorating and removing the causes of rising temperatures, the fossil fuel modifiers squabble and say nothing to see here. Anthony Barnes, Kinglake
Lance this boil, CA Cricket Australia: Lance the sandpapergate boil with an independent inquiry, or face the ignominy of having cricket-loving Australians putting your organisation under further scrutiny. Eric Palm, Gympie, Qld
Tossed a googly Pat Cummins expects us to believe that Steve Smith, David Warner and Cameron Bancroft, got together and said, ‘Hey, let’s use sandpaper on the ball, but don’t tell the bowlers.’ Craig Jory, Albury, NSW
Oh dear, he forgot I think it’s only a matter of time before we hear about the most serious OH&S issue on the Big Build. Rapid Memory Loss looks like it’ll be manifesting in epidemic proportions in the coming weeks and given the nature of those involved it’s hard to think who, exactly, wouldn’t have second thoughts about telling the truth. Julian Guy, Mt Eliza
Promises come forth I suggest there is a fourth certainty in life (Letters, 19/11) politicians making promises they know they can’t/won’t keep. Jane Ross, San Remo
Politics By standing for a photo with Vladimir Putin, Anthony Albanese has brought shame on Australia. Alan Williams, Port Melbourne
Couldn’t Anthony Albanese have pulled a sickie? Fiona White, Alfredton
Interesting state election. For the first time I started with whom I didn’t want and so on until I was left with my first choice by default. Les Aisen, Elsternwick
When considering the election, two terms come to mind, ″out of the frying pan″ and ″into the ’fire″. James Proctor, Brown Hill
To your correspondent (Letters, 18/11), you might not want to buy anything from that poorly stocked shop but you’re going to go home with something. You can choose with your vote or let someone else choose for you with a donkey vote. Cao Phan, Glen Iris
″Take Back″ was a theme for both Brexit and MAGA. Neither has ended well. Steve Melzer, Hughesdale
For the first time since my arrival as a migrant in 1970, I have voted for the Liberals and it broke my heart. But it had to be done. Laura Mecca, Windsor
Cricket No son, The Sandpaper Boys is not the name of a new pop band, it’s the Australian cricket team. David Lyall, Mt Eliza
After the sandpaper saga Australia lost so I guess they needed an 80 grit paper rather than a 120 grit. Come on boys do your homework. Ian Holton, Yarraville
Could the Big Build Royal Commission find time to question Australian cricketers? Malcolm McDonald, Burwood
Furthermore Two weeks ago, I’d have said the word of the year was ″redacted″. I now wish to include another – ″disendorsed″. David Cayzer, Clifton Hill
The thugs pretending to represent workers prosper, but they make unionism, and all it stands for, a dirty word. Bill Burns, Bendigo
You have reached your maximum number of saved items.
Remove items from your saved list to add more.
You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.