Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

You be the judge: should my friend stop eating smelly meals at work?

The Guardian •
November 19, 2026 • 08:00 AM
5
5 reads 0 reactions

Mina’s substantial and aromatic workplace breakfasts and lunches are a worry for her friend and colleague Jackie. You decide who’s making a meal of the disagreement

You be the judge: should my friend stop eating smelly meals at work?

double quotation mark I recommended Mina as an intern but now worry as she’s always eating pungent food at her desk

Mina and I have known each other since university and now we both work at the same company – she is on an internship that I helped her get. I have just completed mine and now work there part-time. It’s a nice company and it’s fun to see a friendly face in the office.

My only gripe is Mina’s office breakfasts and lunches. I feel second-hand embarrassment for her sometimes because she insists on bringing in elaborate meats and cheeses that she eats at her desk. She should be able to eat what she wants, but when I was an intern I’d eat breakfast at home and then have something quick at my desk for lunch.

I think it’s important to make a good impression, and to not stand in the kitchen putting together a complicated meal at nine in the morning. But Mina doesn’t care. She is obsessed with hitting her protein goals and says: “I need to eat this now!” I think there are other ways of hitting your goals.

Mina will have hoisin duck with pancakes or a honey-glazed salmon with spinach for breakfast. I can smell her meal in the office as I walk to my desk first thing in the morning. I think she should be a bit more conscious of the aromas her food is bringing into the office early in the morning, and how long she spends eating at her desk.

She rarely pops out to eat with the team. I know from experience that managers assess behaviour as well as competency, and I want her to get a permanent role. It’s about how well you get on with the company culture and no one else eats like she does.

There’s such a thing as trying to fit in when you’re on probation or starting out. I’m not aware of anyone saying anything negative about her, but I want to protect her reputation as well as my own, because I recommended her. Maybe I’m just overthinking it because I really care about what others think – clearly more than Mina does at least – and I don’t think you should make yourself stand out for your food choices in a new job.

double quotation mark Who says you can only eat simple meals in the office? It’s fun to be creative with food

I’m vehemently against western breakfast ideals. Who says that you can only eat fruit and yoghurt for breakfast? I much prefer to have a whole duck leg or half a chicken in the morning to ensure I hit my protein goals, then the same again at lunch.

It’s fun to be creative with what I eat, and I don’t think being an intern should mean that I compromise on that. Also, I think Jackie needs to be careful with the comment about the smell of my food because I’m not white. These days telling ethnic minorities that their food stinks could result in a tribunal.

I know we’re mates and she’s looking out for me, but I’ve had good appraisals so far and no one else seems to mind. I don’t know if she feels partly responsible for me as she brought me in, but if I’m not kept on, it won’t reflect badly on her. It’s between me and our boss.

The smell issue is funny because everyone’s food smells. If someone makes porridge and cinnamon, that smells. Coffee smells. Someone’s leftover curry smells. We all have to share a workplace with other people, and that means encountering things we wouldn’t personally choose. The notion that there’s a hierarchy of smells – or that fish can only be microwaved after 1pm – is archaic.

Unless my breakfast is genuinely making people uncomfortable or disrupting their work, I don’t think it’s reasonable to expect me to change my routine. Lots of people also eat breakfast and lunch at their desks, so I’m not an anomaly. I don’t go out for lunch with colleagues much because I can’t afford it.

Jackie seems to think that when you’re an intern, you should keep your head down and avoid attention. I think doing good work and treating colleagues well are more important.

Just because Jackie wouldn’t eat duck for breakfast doesn’t mean it’s wrong. And if that’s the only thing our company has to say about me, I think my professional reputation is just fine.

Jackie, wind your neck in, kiddo! If there’s an issue in the workplace, then Mina’s manager will handle it. This is 2026 – if people have an issue with food smells, that’s not a work culture you want to be in. Manisha, 53

It might be wise of Mina to be aware of the smells of her food. No one has complained, but maybe they won’t because of the reason she has stated. But Jackie should realise that nobody is judging her for this situation, and that it’s not her business. Bonnie, 71

It sounds like Mina has her life sorted: hitting nutrition goals, eating nice food and sticking to her budget. She certainly shouldn’t let the corporate grind guilt-trip her into the Pret queue. Ananya, 29

Mina should be judged on her work, not her diet. However, shared workspaces require consideration, and while there’s no “smell hierarchy,” certain foods smell strong regardless of origin. So if you have a communal area, maybe enjoy them there rather than at your desk. Michael, 29

I’m still mortified by the time I was told off for eating lasagne at my desk as a fashion intern 10 years ago, so I understand Jackie’s concern. It seems that everyone is happy with Mina’s work so far, however. Eat those duck legs to your heart’s content! Rebecca, 32

In our online poll, tell us: is Mina quackers for preferring roast duck to a bowl of cereal for breakfast?

The poll closes on Wednesday 25 November at 9am GMT

We asked whether Maddie should stop calling sister when she’s on the move.

56% of you said yes – Maddie is guilty

44% of you said no – Maddie is innocent

Tags:
Prev Swipe Story Next

Related Stories

World News
Build #2612