Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

Leanne’s ex was convicted of abusing her. A court mandates she co-parents with him

The Age •
November 18, 2026 • 06:00 PM
• By Amber Schultz
5
5 reads 0 reactions

The Family Court is “ill-equipped” to deal with domestic violence cases, with instances of judges minimising claims of abuse, an inquiry has warned.

1 / 8
Swipe Photos

You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

Remove items from your saved list to add more.

You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.

When Leanne* learnt the Family Court granted her ex, who was convicted of abusing her, overnight stays with their two young daughters, she walked outside and had a panic attack.

“I had a nervous breakdown ... I just screamed blue murder and hit my steering wheel,” she said. “I was so angry.”

The process has had an immense toll on Leanne’s physical and mental health, while the court gave confusing and extreme orders including mandatory therapy.

Scores of recent parliamentary inquiries, studies and reports have highlighted how the courts are contributing to further harm for people experiencing violence, while an investigation by The Sydney Morning Herald and The Age has revealed systems abuse, where perpetrators weaponise legal processes to continue domestic and family violence, is endemic.

Leanne still has a visceral reaction when she sees her ex, who was convicted of multiple offences including three counts of assault. He was fined and sentenced to a 12-month community correction order.

She was awarded sole parental responsibility, but must advise her ex on decisions about their daughters and facilitate handovers.

A judge ordered Leanne to attend therapy and submit proof to her ex and the court to keep her children. The reports had to include notes from a psychologist stating that Leanne understood that her ex posed no risk to the children. If she did not comply, the children would be removed from her care and placed with the father full-time.

Despite having no documented history of violence, Leanne was also ordered to complete a domestic violence prevention course.

While the Federal Family Circuit Court of Australia has implemented a raft of reforms to address domestic and family violence, including training for judges, screening parties for risk, and making family violence a consideration in the property and finance division, survivors and advocates argue more needs to be done to assist victim-survivors.

The Family Court is one of Australia’s most secretive jurisdictions, where publishing any identifying details of parties, witnesses, or children is illegal. Eighty-four per cent of parenting cases in the Family Court contain allegations of domestic violence.

We want to understand how systems abuse occurs and how to address it, and we’d like to hear from you. You can share your story with the reporter using the form below. By law, we cannot publicly identify parties to Family Court proceedings.

Leanne’s husband allegedly twice choked her in the weeks after she gave birth to their youngest child. While he was found not guilty of the choking charges, he was convicted of three counts of assault, one count of harassment, and twice breaching an AVO issued after his arrest.

In 2023, Leanne fled with their two young children to the US, where she had family, to escape further abuse. Her ex filed a Hague Convention abduction application , an international treaty drafted more than 40 years ago to address a spate of fathers taking their children abroad, which triggered an INTERPOL alert. Leanne returned with the children.

Upon returning, she unsuccessfully fought a ban on relocating abroad in the Family Court. Her mental health, which had been affected by the trauma of the abuse, worsened with the stress of court and the thought of losing her children to her abuser.

The AVO protecting her expired last year.

His legal team scrutinised her “fawning” text messages sent in the year after the abuse, questioning the legitimacy of her fear and using her mental health to challenge her fitness as a parent. He also admitted to pouring water over her head and verbal abuse.

Despite the convictions and further admissions of abuse, which a judge noted “raise serious concerns about father’s capacity to parent the children”, the court accepted the Independent Children’s Lawyers report that the children should have unsupervised time with the father.

Leanne said that before a final hearing, the judge told them to return to mediation, which was unsuccessful.

The court then granted final orders, giving the father increasing time with the children and required Leanne to submit psychological reports helping her accept he posed no “unacceptable risk” to their safety.

The judge also found her ex had “done nothing” to address his violent behaviour towards her.

Three appeal judges overturned the therapy order, calling it “vague”, “likely futile”, and “confusing”, and ruling that removing the children for non-compliance would be “sudden and extreme”.

The toll the proceedings had on Leanne was immense. She said she was hospitalised before the final hearing for a panic attack, had started taking antidepressants, and her hearing loss had worsened. “I shake … I have dizzy spells,” she said. “I’ve lost weight.”

She became fearful when she had to provide her address to the court and when he suggested home drop-offs. He now collects the children from locations close to her home. “That’s very, very scary,” she said.

Though eligible for legal aid, the former lawyer has spent thousands on court-ordered evaluations. She is often self-represented. Her ex spent close to $500,000 on legal fees.

A Family Court spokesperson said it couldn’t comment on individual cases, and declined to say whether the judge who made the initial orders requiring therapy was required to undergo additional training.

The spokesperson said the courts assessed safety before mediation, holding most electronically to manage risk where family violence made negotiating freely “unsafe or impossible”.

A 2023 review found the court exacerbated survivors’ trauma and routinely dismissed abuse claims, while a 2023 study on GPs treating domestic violence survivors found they were reluctant to seek necessary treatment from their GPs out of fear their clinical notes would be used against them in court. A 2015 study found mental health was used to limit child contact for 30 per cent of cases with mothers, but just 2 per cent of cases with fathers.

Meanwhile, Domestic Violence Commissioner Michaela Cronin said in September some judges still held horrendous views about women, with researcher Jess Hill noting an evaluation of the Family Court reforms had revealed some judges resisted domestic violence training. A 2025 study found family court judges reinforced gender bias.

Domestic Violence Action Centre chief executive Amie Carrington said women sometimes chose to stay in a violent relationship because they feared a court would award unsafe and unsupervised contact between the children and the perpetrator.

“They may choose to stay [to] remain supervising the child … as a protective mechanism for their children because they’re so afraid,” she said.

The resulting anxiety is then used to paint mothers as unfit parents, she said, with courts sometimes treating abuse as isolated incidents rather than a cumulative pattern.

Carrington said courts needed to start looking at patterns to distinguish coercive control from parental conflict. While there had been strides towards this, Carrington said there was more work to be done. “There needs to be stronger accountability for people who are using violence,” she said.

Reforms implemented in 2024 have included training for judges on domestic violence and expanded risk assessment screening, and removed the legal presumption of equal shared parental responsibility, focusing instead on a child’s best interests.

However, Carrington said a cultural approach still existed where children were treated as the property of biological parents instead of autonomous and victims.

DVNSW Deputy chief executive Pia Birac said protracted court proceedings could have an immense psychological impact on victim-survivors.

“There’s an idea that after a relationship ends, so too does the violence or coercive control,” she said. “Instead, many find themselves in proceedings that are not only hugely costly, but they have this ongoing relationship with the other person in the courts.”

Birac said the impact extended to children, too: “Children are not just exposed to violence; they experience it. They live with the consequences of a profound breach of trust by an adult who was supposed to keep them safe.”

Unless a perpetrator took meaningful action to address the drivers that led them to abuse their loved ones, Birac said, the risk was still present post-separation.

Birac said facilitating children’s time with an abuser could be construed as them not being protective, while not facilitating time meant they were viewed as obstructive. “Women in this process are caught in a double bind,” she said.

A 2025 parliamentary inquiry, which Independent MP Kate Chaney sat on, found the Family Court was ill-equipped to respond to family violence , and kept victims tied to abusers.

The inquiry found some judges even overrode state violence orders to grant perpetrators access to children. While the government backed 10 of its 11 recommendations, Chaney warned of “very little accountability” around implementing them.

“These reviews that talk about the deep systemic problems, and there’s very little accountability about what happens to those recommendations,” she said.

“[People in the court are] being further attacked by their ex-partner, who they’re trying to escape, by the very system that’s meant to help them resolve those issues.”

Chaney is calling on the government to implement time-bound, measurable reforms, as recommended by the Domestic Violence Commissioner.

Attorney-General Michelle Rowland acknowledged that, while there had been significant reform to address domestic and family violence, there was still a long way to go.

Rowland said training judges, lawyers and other court staff was a key focus of the government. Judicial staff must undergo annual training on domestic and family violence, while the government had also launched a national training program on coercive control.

The government had also agreed in principle to a 2022 Australian Law Reform Commission recommendation to establish a judicial commission as an oversight mechanism for the courts.

Leanne does not believe the Family Court is an appropriate mechanism for those who have experienced domestic violence, and gives too little weight to her former partner’s convictions.

“The court empowers [abusers] … they feast on it, and it will literally lead to more domestic violence.”

The National Sexual Assault, Domestic and Family Violence Counselling Service 1800RESPECT (1800 737 732) offers support for emotional, physical and financial abuse. Support is also available from Kids Helpline 1800 55 1800; Lifeline 131 114; Beyond Blue 1300 224 636.

Tags:
Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 1 other independent news outlet reported on this story.

1 Publication
Sydney Morning Herald (SMH)
3h ago
Leanne’s ex was convicted of abusing her. A court mandates she co-parents with him

Leanne’s ex was convicted of abusing her. A court mandates she co-parents with him

The Family Court is “ill-equipped” to deal with domestic violence cases, with instances of judges minimising claims of abuse, an inquiry has warned.

#leanne #convicted #abusing
Compare →

Related Stories

World News
Build #2612