Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

The private schools finding their way back to the top of AFL draft lists

The Age •
November 18, 2026 • 12:50 AM
• By Danny Russell
2
2 reads 0 reactions

Education might not be everything, but top-end schools continue to draw the attention of AFL recruiters.

1 / 8
Swipe Photos

Victoria’s private schools will reclaim their place as the No.1 football nurseries in the country at this year’s AFL draft.

Early predictors suggest that a third of the first 20 names to be called out by AFL clubs across Thursday and Friday nights will be students from Melbourne’s exclusive, high-end secondary schools.

That is in stark contrast to last year.

Only three of the top 20 picks from the class of 2025 were from the privileged private sector – Penleigh and Essendon Grammar School student Cooper Duff-Tytler joined the Eagles at No.4, Richmond took Camberwell Grammar’s Sam Grlj at No.8, while the Eagles also took Josh Lindsay, of Geelong Grammar, at No.19.

A large chunk of last year’s top 20 consisted of interstate selections – five south-east Queenslanders, four South Australians, two from NSW and one from Western Australia.

There were also three state school recruits last year. The Eagles plucked No.1 pick, Willem Duursma , from Foster Secondary College after he shot to prominence as captain of Talent League team Gippsland Power, while Rowville Secondary College threw up pick 11 Xavier Taylor (Eastern Ranges) and pick 16 Lachy Dovaston (Eastern Ranges).

However, this year, only three of the projected top 30 have been educated at government secondary schools, with likely No.1 selection Dougie Cochrane attending Henley High School in Adelaide, top-10 prospect Clancy Snell going to Mirboo North Secondary College, and Caylen Murray attending Maroochydore State High in Queensland.

Once again, Brighton Grammar is expected to continue its proud history of nurturing gun teenagers.

The Brisbane Lions’ premiership-winning brothers, Will and Levi Ashcroft, were educated at Brighton, as was Essendon captain Andy McGrath, who was taken at No.1 in 2016, and Greater Western Sydney star Josh Kelly, who joined the Giants at No.2 in 2013. The school had five draftees in 2024.

The Age ’s draft expert Marc McGowan is predicting two Brighton Grammar products will be snapped up in the top 10 on Thursday night – Arki Butler at No.4 and Tyson Bradley at No.10.

Butler started at Brighton Grammar in year seven, while Bradley’s father was a former student, and he joined in year 10.

The Age ’s phantom rankings have 10 teenagers from the Associated Public Schools of Victoria (APS) competition making the top 40 – two from Brighton Grammar, two from Geelong Grammar, two from St Kevin’s College, two from Wesley College and one each from Haileybury and Caulfield Grammar.

“The first 18 programs now are really well resourced,” Brighton Grammar director of coaching Simon McPhee told The Age on Tuesday.

“We’ve got strength and conditioning coaches and a rehab coordinator, we’ve got good help from a medical point of view, and then we’ve got good coaching [at the schools].”

McPhee highlighted three members of the Haileybury College coaching staff as a prime example – former AFL captains in Matthew Lloyd, who is head coach, Scott Pendlebury and Aaron Hamill.

“Obviously, it’s good for the schools and the APS program when we get kids into the AFL system,” McPhee said.

“But we also take a lot of pride when the boys go on to play VFL footy, and VAFA footy.

“We just want to prepare the boys to play the highest level they can, and obviously, it’s nice for the school when a few make it to the top.”

Brighton Grammar won this year’s first APS grand final, beating Caulfield Grammar by nine points, after the competition shifted away from awarding the premiership to the team that finished on top.

Butler and Bradley were part of that premiership-winning outfit, as was another Brighton draft hopeful Jasper Williams.

“The school system, I think, complements the [AFL] Talent League,” McPhee said.

“In the Talent League they look for the athletic profiles of the boys and showcase that, whereas the schools produce a different style of footy, a little bit more contested.

“The kids really embrace playing for their school and playing with their mates, so there’s character traits that come through in the school as well … we help prepare them pretty well.”

McGowan’s predicted rankings have two students from Ballarat’s St Patrick’s College going top 20 – Ethan Drever at No.2 and Archie Elliott at No.18 – while Parade College is also looking at two top 20 selections with Sam Gayfer at No.11 and Toby Krasna at No.15.

You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

Remove items from your saved list to add more.

You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.

Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 4 other independent news outlets reported on this story.

4 Publications
Sydney Morning Herald (SMH)
7h ago
He ‘shrunk’ this year, but this draft hopeful could be one of the AFL’s biggest achievers

He ‘shrunk’ this year, but this draft hopeful could be one of the AFL’s biggest achievers

George Dimer is one of the smallest players in this year’s AFL draft class, but what he lacks in height he makes up for in impact and leadership.

#afl #draft
Compare →
ABC News Australia
1d ago
Where you go to school might impact whether you're drafted to the AFL

Where you go to school might impact whether you're drafted to the AFL

An ABC News analysis of the last 10 AFL national drafts show nearly three quarters of South Australian recruits are privately educated, but one public school is bucking the trend.

#afl #draft
Compare →
RealEstate.com.au News
5d ago
AFL star Heath Shaw sells renovated Kew home for $2.9m - realestate.com.au

AFL star Heath Shaw sells renovated Kew home for $2.9m - realestate.com.au

Former Collingwood footballer Heath Shaw has inked a deal worth $2.9m to set him up for his next move.

The Australian Financial Review (AFR)
6d ago
James Turrell’s new installation and the ex-AFL player who made it work

James Turrell’s new installation and the ex-AFL player who made it work

The American artist’s latest Skyspace at ARoS Denmark needed a fine edge. Only Australian designer (and former Saint) Darryl Cowie knew how to make that happen.

Related Stories

Education & Youth
AFL player banned for betting on games
Sydney Morning Herald (SMH) • 3h ago
Riverside chalks up mega return on Smartways sale to UPS
The Australian Financial Review (AFR) • 1h ago
Build #2612