Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

So You Are’s horrifying final fate in a skip bin with an old couch is beyond unacceptable

Sydney Morning Herald (SMH) •
November 17, 2026 • 09:15 PM
• By Neil Breen
2
2 reads 0 reactions

He won eight races and $1.4m on the track, yet So You Are’s final fate was to lie dead in a skip bin. How racing NSW boss Graeme Hinton reacts will be one of the industry’s greatest tests.

1 / 15
Swipe Photos

You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

Remove items from your saved list to add more.

You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.

Disgusting doesn’t even scratch the surface when describing the final fate of Melbourne Cup runner So You Are .

The five-year-old gelding was celebrated, along with his fellow Cup runners, for his magnificence as he paraded Flemington minutes after Robbie Williams entertained us all ahead of the nation’s greatest horse race.

Thirteen days later, on Monday, he was lying in a skip bin at Cleanaway’s Lucas Heights dump, next to an old couch and other various flotsam, his head jammed against the steel side.

The uncensored raw image is haunting.

All of that horse’s dignity had been stripped as he lay in the rubbish, as had the reputation of an industry.

So You Are was filmed by a builder at the dump who spoke for us all in his Facebook post when he repeatedly said: “There’s a f...ing horse in the tip. That’s not normal.”

As it turns out, to the shock of everyone including hardened industry participants, it is normal.

And that is the true horror of this story.

Today, Racing NSW’s newly installed chief executive Graeme Hinton has to bring in a whole new set of strict protocols to end that “normality”.

No matter how long he runs racing in this state, this will be Hinton’s greatest test.

There are many villains in this sordid tale.

Let’s start with one of the city’s top veterinary clinics, REC Equine Specialists, which charges huge fees to thousands of clients to care for their horses.

It boasts on its website that it’s a “time-honoured, globally recognised equine veterinary practice dedicated to delivering the highest possible veterinary care for horses.”

Its time ran out yesterday when a horse in their care ended up in a skip.

So You Are was euthanised at its Horsley Park facility on Monday after suffering a severe bout of colic.

Its managing partner Dr Andrew Lumsden said yesterday in a statement: “What happened was unacceptable and disrespectful to So You Are and to everyone who cared for him.”

That line in his statement is disgraceful. The horse was in your clinic’s care, and your clinic ultimately showed the horse a lack of respect. For that, you have failed an entire industry.

Lumsden said much further down in the statement: “We did not carry out the burial ourselves, but we chose the provider and the arrangements, and we take full responsibility for that.

“We should have known exactly how horses are handled after leaving our hospital, and we did not. That process is not good enough. And it must change.”

So, one of the city’s biggest vets, which has humanely euthanised hundreds of horses, did not know where they went after old mate hoisted them into the back of his mini tip-truck?

To educate Lumsden, we refer him to the statements of Racing NSW and the dump operator Cleanaway.

Cleanaway said it held a licence to handle livestock carcasses and that So You Are was delivered to the dump in a small tipper truck which was not permitted on the landfill site for safety reasons.

“In accordance with established procedures, the carcass was transferred into a skip bin to enable its safe disposal at the landfill.”

Who established the procedure? Well, Cleanaway did. It’s clearly using language here to make it all sound official and proper when, in fact, horses are routinely dumped, firstly into the skip and secondly into the landfill.

That must be the “burial” Lumsden, the esteemed vet, did not know about.

Racing NSW said what happened was “distressing and completely unacceptable” and confirmed that licensed landfills were used for euthanised horses because of the chemicals involved in the process.

Today Hinton has to assure the public, who will rightly be baying for blood, and industry participants that that licence does not extend to a tip truck being backed up to the skip at the dump, the tray raised, and the horse dumped and left waiting for the skip to fill before it is dumped into the rubbish pile. For goodness’ sake.

Industry veterans I spoke to yesterday were horrified by the images, captured by the builder Greg Jowett whose short video has shaken the industry to its core.

Trainer Bjorn Baker, who is not at fault here, was inconsolable yesterday. Baker, like the rest of the industry, put his faith in vets to care for their animals.

I have owned small hobby shares in several racehorses and have paid good money to vets to care for them. And have been happy to do it.

To think REC Equine Specialists did not know where the horses go when loaded into a tip truck horrifies me. It is beyond offensive.

So You Are won eight races and $1.4 million in prizemoney. Yet in death he was devalued to the level of a worthless couch.

You have reached your maximum number of saved items.

Remove items from your saved list to add more.

You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.

Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 5 other independent news outlets reported on this story.

5 Publications
The Age
47m ago
So You Are’s horrifying final fate in a skip bin with an old couch is beyond unacceptable

So You Are’s horrifying final fate in a skip bin with an old couch is beyond unacceptable

He won eight races and $1.4m on the track, yet So You Are’s final fate was to lie dead in a skip bin. How racing NSW boss Graeme Hinton reacts will be one of the industry’s greatest tests.

#horrifying #fate #skip
Compare →
SBS News Australia
12h ago
Investigation launched after Melbourne Cup runner dumped in skip bin

Investigation launched after Melbourne Cup runner dumped in skip bin

An equine hospital has apologised after Melbourne Cup runner So You Are was left in a skip bin at a Sydney waste facility.

#skip #bin
Compare →
BBC News
15h ago
So You Are: Body of Melbourne Cup horse found dumped in Sydney skip bin

So You Are: Body of Melbourne Cup horse found dumped in Sydney skip bin

The remains of a top Australian racehorse that died of colic on Monday were found at a public rubbish tip.

#skip #bin
Compare →
The Guardian
15h ago
‘Disgusted by it’: body of Melbourne Cup race horse found dumped in Sydney skip bin

‘Disgusted by it’: body of Melbourne Cup race horse found dumped in Sydney skip bin

So You Are placed eighth in race just two weeks ago and was put down after a severe bout of colic

#skip #bin
Compare →
ABC News Australia
17h ago
Breaking: Dead Melbourne Cup runner So You Are found in Sydney skip bin

Breaking: Dead Melbourne Cup runner So You Are found in Sydney skip bin

Melbourne Cup runner So You Are has been found in a Sydney skip, one day after the racehorse died from colic.

#skip #bin
Compare →

Related Stories

World News
Build #2612