NSW pubs made more than $1 billion in poker machine profits over three months, government data reveals, as the outgoing head of the state’s casino watchdog warns hotels are escaping the same scrutiny applied to multimillion-dollar clubs.
Premier Chris Minns on Monday defended Labor’s record on addressing the social harm of poker machines , arguing his government’s gambling reforms were helping, and that advocates had overstated the benefits of mandatory cashless gaming. He foreshadowed further reforms were unlikely before the March state election.
The government figures, released earlier this year, paint a picture of the profitability of the state’s estimated 87,000 poker machines. Labor has faced sustained criticism of its gambling reforms, which include opt-in, rather than mandatory, account-based gaming.
The Minns government has repeatedly pushed back on calls to implement cashless gaming, contradicting longstanding appeals from law enforcement and advocates.
The reforms have drawn criticism from the Labor rank-and-file and influential party members, including Inner West Mayor Darcy Byrne, who labelled the latest August tranche of proposed changes “half-hearted”.
The data, collected from April 1 to June 30 this year, reveals that the Markets Hotel in Homebush West collected the highest net profit from gaming machines of any pub in NSW. It was followed by the Ambulance Station Hotel in Auburn and Crossroads Hotel in Casula. Each venue houses the maximum 30 poker machines permitted in a NSW pub.
Poker machines in the City of Sydney council area’s 148 hotels delivered a windfall of nearly $100 million in net profit – an average of $33,812 for each of the 2924 machines – over three months. It was the highest of any council area in the state.
Hotels in the Canterbury-Bankstown LGA cleared $87 million in net profit, despite being home to only 33 venues, making an average of nearly $94,000 on each of the 924 gaming machines. Poker machines in the Fairfield and Cumberland local government areas made $116,000 and $117,600, respectively.
On average, each of the 22,486 gaming machines in NSW hotels raked in $46,829 net profit over three months. In contrast, the 65,553 machines in clubs generated almost $1.33 billion between March and May this year, at an average of $20,256 per machine over a three-month period.
The June budget forecast that revenue from pokies in hotels was expected to grow on average by 7.5 per cent over each of the next four years, rising from $1.63 billion to $2.2 billion by 2029-30. In 2023-24, poker machines in NSW generated an $8.4 billion profit for clubs and hotels . NSW is on track to eclipse $10 billion in poker machine losses this year.
In his final interview as chief commissioner of the NSW Independent Casino Commission, Philip Crawford said that pubs, which house a quarter of the state’s poker machines, flew under the radar when it came to gambling reform.
Entitlements for poker machines in pubs trade for about $500,000, Crawford said, compared with clubs, where an entitlement is worth less than one-tenth of the cost on average.
“Just have a look at the price some of these suburban pubs are trading for these days,” he said. “That’s not on bar sales or food.”
The Australian Hotels Association, the peak body for pubs across the country, was contacted for comment.
Speaking before his retirement next week, Crawford criticised the Minns government’s inaction on poker machine reforms and called for a centralised regulator to oversee the state’s casinos, clubs and pubs.
Responding to Crawford’s criticism, the premier said cashless poker machines would not be a “silver bullet” and that advocates had overstated their benefits. The government maintains its proposed alternatives equal the anti-money laundering and harm minimisation benefits of cashless gaming.
“Some people say it’s the panacea to gambling ills. We didn’t see it as transformative as that, but you know I respect [Crawford’s] opinion,” Minns said.
“The latest version of that has been cashless gaming, but I’ve looked at it closely about how it would roll out, and I’m not convinced it would be the great relief that some suggest.”
Pressed on reforms, Minns pointed to the government’s August tranche of policy changes, which include the use of facial recognition technology in gaming rooms, a third-party exclusion scheme, and the scrapping of gaming VIP programs.
“I can’t go through in chapter and verse how bad it would be without these reforms. But I do believe it made a difference,” he said.
Asked if the NSW government had a greater obligation to protect the public from gambling harm, Minns said: “There’s an obligation on all of us in relation to social harm or negative externalities from that part of our economy.”
You have reached your maximum number of saved items.
Remove items from your saved list to add more.
You've used all of your gift articles. 3 more will become available on the 1st of every month.