Once called the 'worst house on the best street', this property has been transformed into a modern, light-filled home with views of koalas in the treetops .
An unassuming 1970s brick home spared from demolition and reimagined as a contemporary, sunlit residence, has hit the market.
Once dubbed the 'worst house on the best street', this Burleigh Heads home has been transformed into a modern home embracing its mid-century heritage. Picture: realestate.com.au/buy
Owners Tessa Penny and fiance Rob Bare are preparing to farewell 22 Pindari Avenue, Burleigh Heads after a transformative renovation that kept its original character while leaning into its mid-century feel.
When the couple bought the Queensland home for $1.075 million in 2020, it ticked all their boxes: a north-east orientation, three bedrooms, solar panels and a positioning in the pocket locals affectionately call “Koala Park”.
The property is located directly opposite a koala sanctuary. Picture: realestate.com.au/buy
“It was like the worst house on the best street kind of scenario,” Tessa said.
“I had heart palpitations when we inspected it.”
The couple initially considered knocking down the home and starting again, but after a brief stint on the market in 2022 failed to generate offers enticing enough to move, they decided to renovate instead.
The home when it was purchased in 2020, before the renovation. The 1977-built property had later additions that concealed its mid-century bones. Picture: realestate.com.au/sold
“There were a lot of add-ons to the house that people just didn't understand, and some of those add-ons weren't compliant with the building standards of today,” Tessa said.
“We decided to go through the renovation with a baby. And then weirdly, it was all just really organic.
“We just fell in love with the location more than anything else.”
A newly constructed extension created an open-plan living space. Picture: realestate.com.au/buy
The couple engaged Fouche Architects, who coincidentally had inspected the property themselves as potential buyers, and Habel Constructions, who was already familiar with the site after spending 10 months working next door.
Completed in November 2025, the 11-month renovation reconfigured the layout without major structural changes, extending the living room towards the street and introducing high windows that frame views of the treetops in the protected bush reserve opposite.
“We’re in our living room having our coffee, and can see a koala in the trees, which is lovely,” Tessa said.
Sliding doors extend the living space outside. Picture: realestate.com.au/buy
A brick wall was also replaced with oversized sliding glass doors, allowing the living area to open into the garden and drawing natural light into the home.
The master bedroom’s ensuite also opens to a private garden.
“We wanted to bring a bit of that Australian aesthetic in too,” Tessa said, explaining they wanted to be sympathetic to natural surroundings and avoid creating another “white box” coastal-style home.
The extension has opened up the previously-cramped floor plan. Picture: realestate.com.au/buy
Inside, timber detailing adds warmth and mid-century charm, while outdoors bush rock and native plants attract local wildlife including king parrots and possums.
The owners say today the now-four-bedroom home is “unrecognisable”, but they are pleased they chose to preserve it.
“So many people are saying to us, "I love what you've done with the house. Thank you for not knocking it down and rebuilding something new.”
The flexible floor plan includes a ground floor studio connected to a retreat that opens onto a native garden and lush lawns. Picture: realestate.com.au/buy
With a return to Sydney now calling, the couple admits leaving will be difficult.
“I think I'll cry. So much love has gone into this project, and we've invested so much ourselves. It certainly has been a labour of love,” Tessa said.
COASTAL agent Linda Covino said the distinctive home was drawing strong interest ahead of the private sale, with almost 50 groups inspecting across its first two open homes.
The upstairs bedrooms offer bushland views of the neighbouring koala sanctuary. Picture: realestate.com.au/buy
She said it would appeal to a broad range of buyers, from families to professionals and creatives, given the separate studio.
“They’ve created something here with different tones, mood and character,” she said.
“Locals love that it captures that Koala Park essence and is quite different to what has been brought to life here in the past.”
This article was originally published on 16 Nov 2026 at 2:03pm but has been regularly updated to keep the information current.
Help us improve your reading experience
Got a minute? Your feedback will help us build a better experience for you.