Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

Overcoming paralysis

ArchitectureAU •
November 15, 2026 • 11:30:29 PM
4
4 reads 0 reactions

Faced with the ever-increasing responsibilities of architectural practice, some students are hesitant to pick up a pencil. But doing nothing isn’t an option: it’s time to move past fear and lead.

1 / 6
Swipe Photos

Faced with the ever-increasing responsibilities of architectural practice, some students are hesitant to pick up a pencil. But doing nothing isn’t an option: it’s time to move past fear and lead.

Rory Hyde writes, “The goalposts have moved a long way in the time since many of today’s practice directors studied. Two or three decades ago … you could draw a glass tower, make a big cantilever or pour a load of concrete without that nagging sense of guilt.”

There’s something odd happening with the students I’m teaching today. The most engaged ones, who would normally be brimming with confidence, seem to have become paralysed, afraid to draw a line on the page for fear of causing harm.

It’s understandable. Throughout their time as students, we are constantly warning them of the potential destructiveness of architecture. We warn them of architecture’s role in the climate emergency, with the built environment by some measures responsible for 40 percent of carbon emissions. We warn them of architecture’s role in the housing crisis, that to make anything “nicer” will only make it more expensive and further out of reach from those who need a place to live. And we warn them of architecture’s historical disregard for First Peoples, and the responsibilities we have to not cross “the line,” to not make a mistake.

It is important and necessary to understand how architecture is entangled within these larger forces of extraction, pollution, economics and colonialism; to ensure that our graduates recognise the responsibilities of architects as they enter the profession, and how these responsibilities extend beyond those clients who commission them, to wider society and the wider world. And yet many of our students are now terrified.

This fear seems to be pervading the profession also. The goalposts have moved a long way in the time since many of today’s practice directors studied. Two or three decades ago, architecture was less burdened by these concerns – you could draw a glass tower, make a big cantilever or pour a load of concrete without that nagging sense of guilt.

The question we now face – students and practitioners alike – is: what do we do? How can we reckon with these challenges, while also recovering our confidence? Here I attempt three broad paths forward.

Perhaps we could hope things just go back to how they once were? It’s a quietly whispered dream of the architect to return to being an artist, unburdened by social or environmental obligations.

It’s awful to think, but for many in this country, the failure of the Voice referendum may seem like permission to wind the clocks back a few decades. “We tried,” they shrug, as they shift their minds to a time when Indigenous issues didn’t seem so present.

The profession has been largely silent, for example, on the demolition of Melbourne’s 44 public housing towers, doing little to convince us that it cares for those residents who have the least. And with the government continuing to approve coal and gas developments at pace, any efforts by architects to reduce carbon in their projects can seem meaningless. Many have now set aside their sustainability ambitions to join the gold rush of extractive, polluting and socially destabilising data centres.

It’s shocking how quickly we seem ready to drop any principles of public good. Surely we are better than that?

Perhaps our students are right. Faced with architecture’s destructive impacts, perhaps it is best to just do nothing – to refrain from drawing anything, for fear of polluting the environment or further worsening social outcomes. It can sometimes feel like the more you know about architecture’s interconnectedness with larger systems and forces, the more conscious you become of its potential harms.

Architect and academic Charlotte Malterre-Barthes advocates for a “moratorium on new construction” – the effective cessation of all new buildings, until we as a profession have worked out how to radically reduce our emissions. The Pritzker-winning French architects Anne Lacaton and Jean-Philippe Vassal have added further support for this path, telling The Guardian in 2021, “if you take time to observe, and look very precisely, sometimes the answer is to do nothing.” This path sounds critical and clever, and is intriguing in how it might require the restructuring of the profession – perhaps to one that produces “intelligence” instead of square metres.

But this interpretation of architecture’s impacts only tallies the negative column, ignoring its capacity to do good. It ignores the schools, hospitals, libraries and housing that are needed to ensure a healthy and fair city. And besides, even if architects were to down tools, our influence is not so great that the whole machine would grind to a halt. Development would continue to churn on, only with poorer design outcomes for everyone.

There is a third path here: to show the way forward. This path requires an almost contradictory resurrection of our civic principles, combined with the suppression of any fears of causing harm. It requires a belief in architecture’s capacity for joy and positive impact, alongside an unflinching critique of our part in the problem.

Needless to say, architects are already out there doing it.

The Australian Institute of Architects’ First Nations Advisory Committee recently published Walk Together: Design Guided by Country , a document offered with an open hand to show a path forward for Indigenous and non-Indigenous architects alike. As the committee writes, Walk Together is an invitation for architects “to shift their minds and hearts to impactfully support First Nations Peoples, cultures, rights, as well as the health and wellbeing of Country.” A profound act of generosity, at a time when it can sometimes feel unearned. The range of work presented in Architecture Australia ’s August 2026 Indigenising Practice issue attests to the growing momentum in this field.

The imperative to retrofit what we have, instead of demolishing and starting anew, seems to have moved from the fringe to the mainstream. The redevelopment of Sydney’s Quay Quarter Tower in 2022 led the way (3XN in collaboration with BVN; see Architecture Australia Sep/Oct 2022), proving that sustainable outcomes are aligned with hard-nosed economic feasibility. More recently, Kosloff’s Latelab (2024) at Swinburne University takes an unglamorous 1980s building and converts it into a vibrant student hub by repurposing much existing material. Recent research at the University of Melbourne aims to take this thinking further, proposing buildings of carbon-negative biomaterials.

On housing affordability, new architect-led initiatives such as Ys Housing are becoming developers themselves, in order to propose new typologies that can offer quality, affordability and social connection – a combination that’s absent from the ever-expanding suburban fringe.

And architects are increasingly leading in the fields of social justice and inclusion. Those projects highlighted in the ArchitectureAu Award for Social Impact demonstrate the power of architecture to do more than merely provide space. The 2026 winner, Truth Telling at Wybalenna by Taylor and Hinds, “demonstrates that design can be measured by the healing it makes possible, the voices it amplifies, and its capacity to act without ego,” as the jury writes.

In each of these cases, it is architects who are showing the way. They are challenging the status quo, not accepting the ways things are done. This is often difficult work, redefining how practice operates, with few guides on how to get there.

So next time you see a student hesitate, their pen hovering over the page, unable or unwilling to make a mark, show them this list. Show them all that there is to do, and all that is possible. Show them how architecture can be transformative, a necessary tool in making things a bit better.

We don’t have the luxury of paralysis – there’s so much to do.

— Dr Rory Hyde is a designer, researcher, writer, curator and broadcaster. He is associate professor in architecture, curatorial design and practice at the University of Melbourne.

Published online: 16 Nov 2026 Words: Rory Hyde Images: Graphic by Lucia Amies

Architecture Australia, November 2026

The Commonwealth Association of Architects’ Survey of Architecture Students, Graduates and Early Career Professionals highlights the critical challenges facing the next generation of architects.

Aaron Peters provides a critical appraisal of this year’s Australian Architecture Conference, observing how the profession – and the conference itself – must evolve to …

Prev Swipe Story Next

Related Stories

Building & Construction
Build #2612