Trending
Prev Story
Next Story

City of Masks review – theatreland ghost story with female phantom of the opera out for revenge

The Guardian •
October 27, 2026 • 07:00 AM
1
1 reads 0 reactions

In a West End theatre, a young actor hears a disembodied voice coaching his singing. It’s the start of an icky ghost-on-human romance

City of Masks review – theatreland ghost story with female phantom of the opera out for revenge

T his ghost story set in a West End theatre is creakier than the old wooden floorboards on stage. It’s a gender reversal of Phantom of the Opera with a female phantom: wildly talented composer Eve (Amanda Jiang), who died tragically in a theatre fire. Or did she? That’s the question for earnest young actor Christian (Charlie Goddard) cast as the lead in a revival of Eve’s hit musical, City of Masks. It’s being staged in the very theatre where she died. Then Christian starts hearing a ghostly disembodied voice coaching his singing.

Part of the problem with the film is a clash of acting styles. Jiang seems to have stepped out of a David Lynch film to play Eve; sensual and mysterious. Meanwhile, actor Deano Bugatti Mitchison channels Al Pacino in Scarface levels of intensity to play the revival’s director, coked-up theatre impresario Victor – surely the only director in the West End to keep a loaded gun in his desk drawer

Victor is suspected of involvement in the fire that killed Eve and the tabloids are sniffing around. Meanwhile, Eve is all out for revenge: lights flicker, bits of rigging fly off the walls. Whether or not she is a ghost, Christian seems to be developing big feelings for her – and as in any film with the prospect of ghost-on-human romance, it gets a bit ick. And as it goes on the film gets more and more baffling, so confusing that I went back and watched it again, convinced I’d missed something vital that would make sense of it. But no.

Prev Swipe Story Next

Same Story from Other Publications

Compare how 2 other independent news outlets reported on this story.

2 Publications
ABC News Australia
1w ago
NT architect wins top honour, joining ranks of Sydney Opera House designer

NT architect wins top honour, joining ranks of Sydney Opera House designer

The Alice Springs architect behind the NT's only 6-star green rated building has been awarded the industry's highest honour. The win sees Susan Dugdale join the ranks of other influential designers, including the architect behind the Sydney Opera House.

SBS News Australia
6d ago
Australia's biggest cultural project since the Opera House goes live

Australia's biggest cultural project since the Opera House goes live

The NSW premier has hailed the riverfront marvel, but the Coalition is demanding credit for the project Labor once opposed.

Related Stories

Entertainment & Cinema
Build #2612